Pretty confident. What about dow
2017 Draft rumours
- Thread starter king rising
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Pretty confident. What about dow
Wot if he's also gone?
We're certainly being linked a lot to Brayshaw and Bonar. Also Murphy.
- Dec 21, 2012
- 19,993
- 15,760
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
- Other Teams
- Chelsea, Redbacks, Adelaide United
Seems about right, Swans seem to love picking up the SA boys and have had a decent amount of success with them recently (pretty early to tell though).
Hayward and Hewett look like guns, Dawson will be good in time I reckon and not convinced on Pink and Rose.
- Sep 13, 2013
- 23,950
- 62,601
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
That means we get one of Dow or LDU mama mia.
When's the last time that happened?
Ldu goes to freo,a lock.
The 2008 trade period didn't have a first round pick moved so all 16 clubs went in with their first pick as given after the Grand Final.
The first 12 picks in 2007 were all individual clubs with no repeats
8 clubs in the top ten is the best we've gotten since
HBF
Flying Scotsman
- Sep 24, 2002
- 156,163
- 100,982
- AFL Club
- Carlton
I don't know why. The guy couldn't make it on an AFL list after how many years.
The tall and initially lanky sorts can be like that though. I know Liam Jones had showed a bit more of his talent at the top level with the Dogs in comparison, but he's a reasonable example of what can happen once a critical mass of experience and clear expectations combine. Elton did seem to at least be starting to make some strides towards being a competent AFL footballer so I can see why clubs might think he's worth giving a go.
- Nov 22, 2014
- 1,003
- 3,527
- AFL Club
- Richmond
Yes I believe so. Would fit into their group well
Surely Roos prefer Beau Maister
If Cerra or Brayshaw are not available at 6, the Pies will take Nathan Murphy. He is my draft bolter.
- Dec 5, 2012
- 12,743
- 34,368
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Other Teams
- Knicks, Giants
He would make a good combo with sideshow bob
Cerra no chance,brayshaw big chance.
- Jan 1, 2007
- 6,665
- 10,137
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
Not Coffield? I'd be stoked if you took Murphy
I know we are keen on Murphy whether we use 6 on him is the question, and he wont last until our next pick 39. The club likes his ability to play forward or back, very good overhead, excellent below his knees for his size and uses the ball very well.
In my opinion he could be this years bolter at 6, if Brayshaw and Cerra our gone. lf Brayshaw, in particular is still there at 6, the Pies will take him. Coffield l dont believe we have an interest.
sonnywalters
Cancelled
Is that just because all three live within a 5km radius or Moorabbin?
- Jan 1, 2007
- 6,665
- 10,137
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
Source or gut feel? I've seen Coffield linked with you guys a few times, all on here I think.
My Western Jets source reckons West Coast are into Lachie Fogarty at both picks 13 and 21 but I presume he’s gone by the latter
On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app
On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app
I was Coffield’s first big fan on the Collingwood board and feel I got a bit of a rush going but personally I’ve gone cold on him. He doesn’t have the defensive mindset I thought he did and I’m not totally convinced he’ll be a gun midfielder.
I’d prefer a number of types before him, including Brayshaw who Pies supporters aren’t too keen on. He’s not as silky or quick as Coffield but he’s way better defensively and he creates attack more which I like, specifically the defensive work. Collingwood’s midfield is pretty one-way a lot of the time so adding a Brayshaw type wouldn’t be the worst thing ever but he’s not my favourite either.
Favourite: Aaron Naughton for needs and because I think he’ll be a ripper anyway. Seems very professional and has a love for the club that should see him put everything into his footy.
2nd fav is Darcy Fogarty for his versatility and creativity. Chuck him in either 50 and he makes a world of difference.
3rd fav is Stephenson who doesn’t have the defensive game that I like but his firepower and smarts are just so good. A great forward marking target who is splendid in midfield and is (in my opinion) the biggest game changer of the draft, should be wanted by every club in the league.
4th is Brayshaw, 5th is Coffield. I’m convinced Cerra at latest will go to Freo at 5 hence why I’m not including him.
On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app
I’d prefer a number of types before him, including Brayshaw who Pies supporters aren’t too keen on. He’s not as silky or quick as Coffield but he’s way better defensively and he creates attack more which I like, specifically the defensive work. Collingwood’s midfield is pretty one-way a lot of the time so adding a Brayshaw type wouldn’t be the worst thing ever but he’s not my favourite either.
Favourite: Aaron Naughton for needs and because I think he’ll be a ripper anyway. Seems very professional and has a love for the club that should see him put everything into his footy.
2nd fav is Darcy Fogarty for his versatility and creativity. Chuck him in either 50 and he makes a world of difference.
3rd fav is Stephenson who doesn’t have the defensive game that I like but his firepower and smarts are just so good. A great forward marking target who is splendid in midfield and is (in my opinion) the biggest game changer of the draft, should be wanted by every club in the league.
4th is Brayshaw, 5th is Coffield. I’m convinced Cerra at latest will go to Freo at 5 hence why I’m not including him.
On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app
Do they!?
I still think the Blues will take Dow with pick 3.
A bit of both, knowledge that we are keen on Murphy, but just a gut feel that we will take him with 6. In saying that l think Freo will take Brayshaw with pick 2, so this could still leave us Cerra or Dow as possible options. I think Freo will take Naughton with pick 5.
Similar threads
