Remove this Banner Ad

Position 2017 Forwards

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Status
Not open for further replies.
G-TRAIN07 said:
Who are the top 10 CD favourites?
Click to expand...

Cotchin
Rioli
Rance
Bont
Wingard
Goldy
Dusty
Naitanui
Gaj

Nine that come to mind that are currently playing that seemed to get marked up generously, especially for those little things that aren't defined by the scoring system. Not to say they don't deserve to be scored highly, they're all guns, but watching the game with live SC scores CD are certainly more forgiving with them than others.
 
G-TRAIN07 said:
Who are the top 10 CD favourites?
Click to expand...
Rances left buttock.
Rancces right buttock.
Rances jet black locks.
Rances strut.
Rances muscular tanned arms
Rances pearly white teeth.
Rances God like stature
Rances Boyish good looks
Rances swagger
Rances big barrel chest
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Hairy Lager said:
Rances left buttock.
Rancces right buttock.
Rances jet black locks.
Rances strut.
Rances muscular tanned arms
Rances pearly white teeth.
Rances God like stature
Rances Boyish good looks
Rances swagger
Rances big barrel chest
Click to expand...
Rance's triumphant phallus.
 
pulpdriver said:
Cotchin
Rioli
Rance
Bont
Wingard
Goldy
Dusty
Naitanui
Gaj

Nine that come to mind that are currently playing that seemed to get marked up generously, especially for those little things that aren't defined by the scoring system. Not to say they don't deserve to be scored highly, they're all guns, but watching the game with live SC scores CD are certainly more forgiving with them than others.
Click to expand...

Cotch and Dusty?
Dusty gets shafted by them due to his poor DE at times and getting cheap 1-2s.
I still can't believe how hard he got shafted in round 10 last year, 38 posis, 9 score involvements and 10 marks for 111 points.
Cotch's numbers have stayed relatively similar the the last 6 years and his average has drop a stack since 2012 because he kicks sideways and doesn't hurt teams, fail to see how he's a CD favourite.
Rance is, but he's beautiful. Can't blame 'em.
 
Seymour Skinner said:
Cotch and Dusty?
Dusty gets shafted by them due to his poor DE at times and getting cheap 1-2s.
I still can't believe how hard he got shafted in round 10 last year, 38 posis, 9 score involvements and 10 marks for 111 points.
Cotch's numbers have stayed relatively similar the the last 6 years and his average has drop a stack since 2012 because he kicks sideways and doesn't hurt teams, fail to see how he's a CD favourite.
Rance is, but he's beautiful. Can't blame 'em.
Click to expand...

I would say the opposite on Dusty, he has games where he has 35 disposals, 30% effective along with 2 goals and he's at 130+. He's one of the situations where the things he does which aren't defined by the listed stats account for big scores. I'm not arguing, goals at the right time should be worth big points. However, even on his shitty days he is given a lot of leeway on effective disposals and his score boosted more than others by goals. Robbie Gray would have be a 125 average if he were treated in a similar manner.

Cotch has as many inconsequential disposals as Rocky but less total possessions and less effective ones. He's had quite a few games where he's been given favourable treatment: that tap to advantage against Freo still comes to mind. Not complaining, I had him and enjoyed his score, I just thought it was bullshit and he's received many a favourable score relative to impact over the journey.

You'll get no argument from me on Rance. He gets kissed on the dick by CD but so he should. The impact he offers can't really be measured in stats and whilst it's arguable you could say the same for the former two I don't think it's even close to the extent of Rance. Top 3 player in the league and sometimes one percenters should be scored up for SC to reflect that.
 
Anyone else tempted to pick Jesse Hogan? Could easily kick 50+ goals if his kicking straightens up, 95+ average?
 
TheBeardAmigos said:
looks to be around the 92-94 average mark for a top 8 fwd this year.

makes Miller/Heeney/Wingard etc all very good options for cheap
Click to expand...
sounds about right
I reckon there will only be 1 or 2 that go 100+
 
TheBeardAmigos said:
Roo and Dahl probably

Chad still my smokey, but we as a team need to improve for him to do that
Click to expand...
Yeah, I was thinking those 2

I'll be very happy with 22 games, 90 SC avg
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Hairy Lager said:
Jeez thats been a horror trade for Brissy.
Click to expand...
Well if bundy wasn't playing hide the sausage or what ever naughty stuff he was into,he would prob still be at the cattery.
Stanley hasn't set the world on fire either,who we got in that trade.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Gerald Preston said:
Thoughts on Toby Greene? Have him F3 atm, should score well with GWS dominating? Anyone think he can average 95-100?
Click to expand...
Rate him highly, the only reason he's not in my side is because I highly rate a bunch of the mid price forwards

I think he's finally found consistency in his game and he'll keep on scoring goals.

90-100
 
G-TRAIN07 said:
Just swapped miller for petracca just to see how it looks. 114k in the bank. Is it risky to start with him
Click to expand...

Didn't see him play, so can't comment on that.

Had a look at 2011-2015 debut players (was only 25-odd blokes who had been relevant at least year between 2012 and 2016)- blokes like Wines who take that sort of step in their second season and can be held for most / all of the year seem the exception.
 
G-TRAIN07 said:
Just swapped miller for petracca just to see how it looks. 114k in the bank. Is it risky to start with him
Click to expand...
He could do anything score wise this year, however i reckon he will be in the mid 80's

Sent from my SM-P555 using Tapatalk
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Similar threads

B
SuperCoach team picker
Replies
5
Views
259
vjknight
vjknight

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top