Not quite, my attack against him in the final sentence was relevant to the argument, and is therefore not a fallacy. His attack against me had no bearing on what I was saying (which was really me making a childish intimation that they have a tendency to choke in finalss).
To be fair though, the discussion has been, from start to finish an excuse to abuse each other with little actual content, and I was being disingenuous for the sake of some low quality humour. They don't really have a finals issue. they have an issue dealing with close games, and a separate issue with GWS.
To be fair though, the discussion has been, from start to finish an excuse to abuse each other with little actual content, and I was being disingenuous for the sake of some low quality humour. They don't really have a finals issue. they have an issue dealing with close games, and a separate issue with GWS.
The Defence Rests.

