Remove this Banner Ad

Roast 2017 Never Again List

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Josh Gibson
Daniel Rich
Elliot Yeo
Charlie Dixon
Sam Mitchell (the week I trade him in for over $600,000 he gives me 5 weeks of scores in the 70-80 range)

I had Yeo and Dixon in my team for the majority of the year. Burnt me big time.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

GWS
Its the Sydney midfield problem, but the entire team-not just the midfield.
I can totally see them having 15 players averaging around the 90-100 mark, and no player averaging enough to be a positional top 6 player.
They have so much rookie depth that their cows(starting expensive due to high picks) get SFA game time.
I don't think that H Shaw will score well as consistently this year as last. He will still be decent, but its been downhill for him since 2015.
Ward is solid, but doesn't have the ceiling of the the top mids. The rest of their quality on ballers also have to compete with their mobile forwards of greene/SJ/D Smith/Delidio as well as their mobile defenders.
Great team, but i'm not having any of them in my team this year.
 
Last edited:
GWS
Its the Sydney midfield problem, but the entire team-not just the midfield.
I can totally see them having 15 players averaging around the 90-100 mark, and no player averaging enough to be a positional top 6 player.
They have so much rookie depth that their cows(starting expensive due to high picks) get SFA game time.
I don't think that H Shaw will score well as consistently this year as last. He will still be decent, but its been downhill for him since 2015.
Ward is solid, but doesn't have the ceiling of the the top mids. The rest of their quality on ballers also have to compete with their mobile forwards of greene/SJ/D Smith as well as their mobile defenders.
Great team, but i'm not having any of them in my team this year.

Lids will be a top 6 fwd imo
Mummy will be a top 6 ruck imo
 
Lids will be a top 6 fwd imo
Mummy will be a top 6 ruck imo
If Mummy's fit he's top 3 ruck, top 6 a shoe in. A safe pick at R2 if Goldy isn't your flavour.
Lids I'm still a little unsure of, calves and role etc.
 
Mummy and safe pick have never been used in the same sentence before. If he's not injured he's suspended, if he's not suspended he's getting bent over by CD.
Last year he played 20 games at just under a 100 average. Will be an important player in a team that wins 16+ games next year. Better pick than everyone except GawnStein IMO.
 
Lids will be a top 6 fwd imo
Mummy will be a top 6 ruck imo

Mummy will have a top 6 average.......
lids may do well. Previously has was was sharing points with cotchin and martin.
now he is sharing points with ward,greene,shiel,griffin,SJ,Smith.........

The saving grace may be that because of his delivery he will be targeted by his teammates for disposal inside 50. I wouldnt count on it though. And thats ignoring his recent injury dramas.
 
So, one year from the last eight...I also remember him getting screwed on quite a few occasions.
Yeah and I've never had him so avoided the carnage but for the price he's a decent R2.
It's slim pickings this year.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

So, one year from the last eight...I also remember him getting screwed on quite a few occasions.
I can vouch for that. Dominated games but CD we're looking the other way.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

I got him in with like 5 rounds to go left of SuperCoach and he was putrid. Because his scores leading up to those last few rounds were actually good. When I got him he turned to shit

Turned? :D
 
I couldn't have him anyway. He's a midget with an annoying head and I can't see him getting that much better scoring wise. Plenty of others with proven performance at a cheaper price this year.
Who?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top