2017 Non Crows AFL Discussion Thread part 2

[The Sloane Ranger]

Hopefully Collingwood repeat this 1st half effort against Port in 2 weeks

 

[The Sloane Ranger]

Hopefully Collingwood repeat this 1st half effort against Port in 2 weeks

 

[subaru]

What an idiot

He's the same guy that implied after 1 game that Sam Powell-Pepper was the best player in the draft should have been taken at pick 1 and "any club that had a pick before Port all now have egg on their face for not picking him".

The back tracking this week will be delicious !
He arced up Saturday night too.

Now he's saying on the Melbourne commentary, "hack" kicking in the backlines doesn't work.....he'd know, after all he was the exponent of the "hack" kick!

 

[Scorpus]

Melbourne losing the game more than Collingwood winning it

 

[The Sloane Ranger]

Melbourne losing the game more than Collingwood winning it

Bit unfair on the Pies IMO

Collingwood mids dominating Melb mids and not letting them play the game on their terms

 

[hey shorty]

Lever, McGovern and Doedee the concerns on that list.

First and last are no concern.

Geez Lynden Dunn is awful, and Howe is a great mark.

 

[flashcrow]

 

[Thetrader15]

What an idiot

He's the same guy that implied after 1 game that Sam Powell-Pepper was the best player in the draft should have been taken at pick 1 and "any club that had a pick before Port all now have egg on their face for not picking him".

He also gave them an A for their season so far less than a week ago

A week is a long time in football

 

[spexau]

Bit unfair on the Pies IMO

Collingwood mids dominating Melb mids and not letting them play the game on their terms

I picked the Pies because I thought it would be a mid v mid battle. Both forward and defenses are pretty average for both teams but rate the Pies midfield over the Dees.

 

[Drugs Are Bad Mackay?]

Is Jack Viney over-rated?

 

[Elite Crow]

Geoffa called that 5 years ago - Trengove being his main example. Even Pre Hinkley

Kane the Failed Firey on radio now saying Port will struggle to make 8 - "some people were saying top 4 " - what - people like YOU Kornes you complete flog!
How he can have the front to say shit like this astounds me !

And no one picks him up on it

 

[Rotayjay]

I picked the Pies because I thought it would be a mid v mid battle. Both forward and defenses are pretty average for both teams but rate the Pies midfield over the Dees.

I picked Dees because I think they're the better team and also the recent history between these sides. Having a mare in footy tips this week

 

[Elite Crow]

Is Jack Viney over-rated?

Not when he played us

 

[officialjc]

although they are trailing atm, i am very envious of the dees talent. just look at their list. hogan, jones, salem, watts, petracca, lewis, viney, brayshaw, gawn, tyson, oliver, hibberd, vince, mcdonald, hunt, garlett, jetta. do you think they have a better list than ours?

 

[hippyhippy]

although they are trailing atm, i am very envious of the dees talent. just look at their list. hogan, jones, salem, watts, petracca, lewis, viney, brayshaw, gawn, tyson, oliver, hibberd, vince, mcdonald, hunt, garlett, jetta. do you think they have a better list than ours?

Well.. When you get top 5 picks every year.. What do you expect?

 

[The Sloane Ranger]

although they are trailing atm, i am very envious of the dees talent. just look at their list. hogan, jones, salem, watts, petracca, lewis, viney, brayshaw, gawn, tyson, oliver, hibberd, vince, mcdonald, hunt, garlett, jetta. do you think they have a better list than ours?

If they do, they are not showing it on game day

 

[Big Gazoongas]

The more I see Maynard the more disappointed I get we weren't able to pick him up.
He's a fierce competitor.

 

[CrowsB4hoes]

Hasn't been for a long time. Sunday mornings have been completely changed for some reason. Stupid health and wellness show is on for hours then only an hour for Sunday roast.

I hate that show

 

[Elite Crow]

Hasn't been for a long time. Sunday mornings have been completely changed for some reason. Stupid health and wellness show is on for hours then only an hour for Sunday roast.

Well if you think that's bad, we've had two Friday night games and they decide to put that Graham Cornes chat show from 6pm. It's just dumb because they gift the audience to MMM if you want to listen to the build up.

 

[Scorpus]

Getting out of defence against Melbourne is extremely difficult. Practically impossible.

 

[BRL121]

although they are trailing atm, i am very envious of the dees talent. just look at their list. hogan, jones, salem, watts, petracca, lewis, viney, brayshaw, gawn, tyson, oliver, hibberd, vince, mcdonald, hunt, garlett, jetta. do you think they have a better list than ours?

I would desperately like us to steal Petracca: just the right combination of body type and skill set that we need.

 

[Drugs Are Bad Mackay?]

Now that Queen's Birthday has become about MND awareness and fundraising, and Neale Daniher in particular, should it be Melbourne vs Essendon instead?

 

[hey shorty]

Aish is a very very poor footballer.

Melbourne lifting

 

[CrowsB4hoes]

Now that Queen's Birthday has become about MND awareness and fundraising, and Neale Daniher in particular, should it be Melbourne vs Essendon instead?

That's secondary to the primary purpose of Melbourne getting some coin.

So it will stay Collingwood

 

[Drugs Are Bad Mackay?]

That's secondary to the primary purpose of Melbourne getting some coin.

So it will stay Collingwood

Would have thought they're interchangeable