No doubt Gibbs was a punt he could have been ordinary this year but I guess you reap the rewards, but how big was the punt Gibbs is quality
On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app
On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app
Also, if this year we can get a FA like Rockcliff - who would have been an ever better addition this year - or a Kelly, Dusty or Hopper, then its a different story. The Gibbs trade would have blocked any chance of getting that player. We can complete our judgement after this years trade period. But we will also have to weigh up how close we came to the flag this year and if Gibbs would have likely affected our outcome.

