2017 Planning thread

[Here2tellyouwhy]

Even Shuey had a better year than Selwood.
Doc over Rampe.
Jenkins over Buddy.

 

[toxic]

Even Shuey had a better year than Selwood.
Doc over Rampe.
Jenkins over Buddy.

Jenkins over Lynch based on team structure

My mum over toby greene

Gaff over Sloane on a WING

Bonts on a hff over Cyril EASILY

Neale over Jelwood

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

Jenkins over Lynch based on team structure

My mum over toby greene

Gaff over Sloane on a WING

Bonts on a hff over Cyril EASILY

Neale over Jelwood

I'd still like to see Sloane in over Parker on the bench.
Much more consistent year.

Toby got in based on the highest scoring assist stat.

Whay give shit trucks like him or guys like Cyril with bugger all stats a role in their rightful possesions in the forward pocket , but not give gaff a wing. He's the best winger in the league, although he didn't have a super year this year.

 

[Hairy Lager]

Toby Greene's head will enlarge so much over the preseason.

 

[Judd_Magic]

Neale...

How the fk lachie neale is not the starting rover is testimony that this team is picked on ladder position not player performance

I'd just like to thank Neale for not choosing to go in for shoulder and wrist surgery last week and going in to get it done this week instead.

Without him I may have lost a couple of my SC finals as I would have had to play Kerridge instead!

 

[Hairy Lager]

I'd just like to thank Neale for not choosing to go in for shoulder and wrist surgery last week and going in to get it done this week instead.

Without him I may have lost a couple of my SC finals as I would have had to play Kerridge instead!

You owe him a wristy.

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

You owe him a wristy.

serious lols

 

[big bootaaaaah]

Jenkins over Lynch based on team structure

My mum over toby greene

Gaff over Sloane on a WING

Bonts on a hff over Cyril EASILY

Neale over Jelwood

Toby Greene has to be the current holder of the most annoying punchable face in the afl imo

 

[Judd_Magic]

You owe him a wristy.

He's been through enough already with his sore shoulder and wrist without me going anywhere near him. LOL!

 

[SC fish]

Will be watching Ryder with interest in the preseason, particularly if he has FWD/RUCK DPP. Might even consider him as R2. Gawn R1

 

[Pedro]

http://www.scpaige.com.au/10-first-picked-supercoach-players-in-2017/

Article here on who should be the first 10 picked in your side next year. Not going to go into the particular merits of each player, because there's several I disagree with. But one question - They list Braydon Fiorini and then go on to state: "He’ll remain basement price when SuperCoach opens in 2017 and firms as a cash-cow with a high ceiling next year."

Won't he start at the average he scored this year? I thought it was the case of those rookies who play 1 or 2 games late in the year really stuff up their starting price the following year.

 

[toxic]

http://www.scpaige.com.au/10-first-picked-supercoach-players-in-2017/

Article here on who should be the first 10 picked in your side next year. Not going to go into the particular merits of each player, because there's several I disagree with. But one question - They list Braydon Fiorini and then go on to state: "He’ll remain basement price when SuperCoach opens in 2017 and firms as a cash-cow with a high ceiling next year."

Won't he start at the average he scored this year? I thought it was the case of those rookies who play 1 or 2 games late in the year really stuff up their starting price the following year.

You are correct

Don't believe he'll be rock bottom at all

 

[dlanod]

http://www.scpaige.com.au/10-first-picked-supercoach-players-in-2017/

Article here on who should be the first 10 picked in your side next year. Not going to go into the particular merits of each player, because there's several I disagree with. But one question - They list Braydon Fiorini and then go on to state: "He’ll remain basement price when SuperCoach opens in 2017 and firms as a cash-cow with a high ceiling next year."

Won't he start at the average he scored this year? I thought it was the case of those rookies who play 1 or 2 games late in the year really stuff up their starting price the following year.

He'll be at the 86.5 average minus some discount, probably about 40% for playing only two games. But it is SCPaige.

 

[BC__]

He'll be at the 86.5 average minus some discount, probably about 40% for playing only two games. But it is SCPaige.

Previous years 2 games with an av over 60 is usually 30% discount.

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

You have to play 3 games before your price goes up during a season. It woud be nice if they just waivered his two games this year and started him at this years rookie price.

He will get plenty of games early as half of Gold Coasts midfield leaves during the off season.

 

[Hairy Lager]

Grundy sounds risky as **** with Cox looming, Jeager lock hhmmm, No.
Swallow no, she don't either.

Not a bad effort, she pants me so not my place to critic the old chook.

 

[Fyfetheknife]

lol why calls for Jenkins in the AA team? Joking or nah? And Toby Greene has been the best HFF of the year easily. Gaff too? WTF. Thank God the public can't vote.

 

[Fyfetheknife]

Rampe has also been sensational, maybe look at something other than SC scores for once...

 

[Hairy Lager]

 

[Broar]

Know I'll be stewing on this for months; do you start with both Simpson & Doc?

 

[BC__]

Depleted suns midfield. Do we gaz?

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

Depleted suns midfield. Do we gaz?

I'd do him.
Hard to ignore if he has a faultless pre season.

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

Know I'll be stewing on this for months; do you start with both Simpson & Doc?

Not for me. Doc a likely starter. Can only get better.

 

[BC__]

I'd do him.
Hard to ignore if he has a faultless pre season.

Tend to agree. If there's such a thing as an upside to his shoulder issues the last couple years, it's the miles saved in his legs which should give him every oportunity to tear 1 more season apart hopefully

 

[Broar]

Not for me. Doc a likely starter. Can only get better.

I wasn't meaning picking one but do you start with both? Simpson had a pretty incredible season not one score under 79.