Position 2017 Rookies

[Faz 2000]

How do you replace defender Smith with Forward Hannan ?

The wonders of DPP.

(Don't Google it at work though).

 

[patfootball04]

How do you replace defender Smith with Forward Hannan ?

1. Press T on Smith
2. In the trade screen, if you have a DEF/MID player in the midfield such as Hibberd, press the blue "S" to send them to DEF
3. Then press the blue "S" on a FWD/MID in your forward line such as Pickett, which opens up a spot to trade in a forward (Hannan)

 

[stevebbb]

Most people took Hibberd as a defender, not as a mid, so going Smith to Hannah will be impossible for most

 

[CrozaN]

Most people took Hibberd as a defender, not as a mid, so going Smith to Hannah will be impossible for most

I thank EVW not being named for this .

 

[nameless]

Most people took Hibberd as a defender, not as a mid, so going Smith to Hannah will be impossible for most

I took him as mid for this exact situation.

Should post that in the "Nailed It" thread...

 

[Jiska]

Joel Smith is set to miss up to 4 months, opting to have surgery to repair his dislocated shoulder.
Highly disappointing as he looked like a very good cash cow option, scoring 23 points in his first and only 18 minutes of AFL.

Well *. That's a long time to hold him as a loophole.

Problem is there are no other DEF rookies to take his spot.

 

[Jiska]

How do you replace defender Smith with Forward Hannan ?

SC Board Rules / FAQs / Helpful Links and Info - READ BEFORE POSTING

 

[Changa10]

So, decisions I have are Rooey, Smith and a number of underperforming rookies. Smith has to go, whether it be this week or next. Rooey, I'm thinking hold at this point in time.

Rookies;

Def: Marchbank, Hampton, Hibberd, Smith, Stewart
Mid: SPP, SPS, Barrett, Mountford
Fwd: Taranto, Simpkin, Eddy, Parfitt & Pickett

Rookies I missed/didn't select after Round 1 - Hannan, Butler, Houston, Troy Menzel, McGrath, Ainsworth, Bowes, Otten, Florent.

If I could do Smith to Hannan I would probably do that this week, but I think I will hold fire, at least until selection night rips apart my team......

If Pickett, Taranto, Simpkin or Eddy are dropped, then they may become Hannan.

 

[Significant]

I reckon I will pull the trigger on Pickett > Hannan, allowing me to do two trades next week to fix my team if other issues present themselves.

I have seen enough from both Pickett and Hannan to suggest that Hannan is the better rookie.

People can say "Pickett may pull out an 80" and "Hannan may pull out a 40" but one round of scoring has shown me that it may just take Pickett to score another sub 40 for his value to stop going up, or Hannan an 80 to pick back up again.

I don't even think Carlton played bad in Round 1, considering the score they kicked. Pickett couldn't get near it.

Hoping he gets dropped anyway just to justify my decision even more!

 

[King_Steele]

I reckon I will pull the trigger on Pickett > Hannan, allowing me to do two trades next week to fix my team if other issues present themselves.

I have seen enough from both Pickett and Hannan to suggest that Hannan is the better rookie.

People can say "Pickett may pull out an 80" and "Hannan may pull out a 40" but one round of scoring has shown me that it may just take Pickett to score another sub 40 for his value to stop going up, or Hannan an 80 to pick back up again.

I don't even think Carlton played bad in Round 1, considering the score they kicked. Pickett couldn't get near it.

Hoping he gets dropped anyway just to justify my decision even more!

To many ifs

Just wait a week it won't kill ya, trades are gold.

 

[The Lemon]

I reckon I will pull the trigger on Pickett > Hannan, allowing me to do two trades next week to fix my team if other issues present themselves.

I have seen enough from both Pickett and Hannan to suggest that Hannan is the better rookie.

People can say "Pickett may pull out an 80" and "Hannan may pull out a 40" but one round of scoring has shown me that it may just take Pickett to score another sub 40 for his value to stop going up, or Hannan an 80 to pick back up again.

I don't even think Carlton played bad in Round 1, considering the score they kicked. Pickett couldn't get near it.

Hoping he gets dropped anyway just to justify my decision even more!

Pickett is probably my worst rookie (Barring J Smith), and I want to do that trade too...but I will give it one more week.

I just want a second look at both of them. We will find out a bit about Pickett. Still think he won't score much and I will end up doing that trade anyway

 

[The Lemon]

Pickett is probably my worst rookie (Barring J Smith), and I want to do that trade too...but I will give it one more week.

I just want a second look at both of them. We will find out a bit about Pickett. Still think he won't score much and I will end up doing that trade anyway

* it, I can't afford to give it one more week.

I might need to move Taranto and Smith...so i gotta pull the trigger on Prickett.

29 left

 

[Boris the Contradiction]

I took him as mid for this exact situation.

Should post that in the "Nailed It" thread...

I did the same!

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

**** it, I can't afford to give it one more week.

I might need to move Taranto and Smith...so i gotta pull the trigger on Prickett.

29 left

I went Pickett to Hannan
Smith to McGrath

Trades are for pussies

 

[vast]

I went Pickett to Hannan
Smith to McGrath

Trades are for pussies

Same trade but Ive swung McGrath to the backline.

Using the double substition during the trade.

 

[rocker_oz33]

With smith and hibberd if dropped.

If cant trade them to Hannan.
Can always wait zfew weeks for other rooks in def,bit s**t buts that SC sometimes.

If hannan kills it again and pickett or barlett sink it up or dropped to him.
Means Bowesmovements goes to the mid bench ummm.
But cash comming in.

 

[The Lemon]

I went Pickett to Hannan
Smith to McGrath

Trades are for pussies

Don't have that cash. Would love to have done Smith to McGrath. Next week.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

The wonders of DPP.

(Don't Google it at work though).

Isn't pr0n banned on this site .....Ahhh you have another Dual position you'll move back into Smiths role, got it

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

Don't have that cash. Would love to have done Smith to McGrath. Next week.

I scraped in by .01k

 

[WaynesWorld19]

1. Press T on Smith
2. In the trade screen, if you have a DEF/MID player in the midfield such as Hibberd, press the blue "S" to send them to DEF
3. Then press the blue "S" on a FWD/MID in your forward line such as Pickett, which opens up a spot to trade in a forward (Hannan)

Thanks .....worked it out that there needed to be a 3rd party (threesome) .....i want Hibberd in the midfield though as a dual position to interchange Adams

 

[WaynesWorld19]

SC Board Rules / FAQs / Helpful Links and Info - READ BEFORE POSTING

Knew the process .....didn't factor in the hidden 3rd player required on the grassy knoll

 

[stevebbb]

If Hibberd gets dropped, I can loophole Otten and Stewart

happy days

 

[rocker_oz33]

Hibberd dropped smith inj = no cover = no loopy.

Week after one of Hampton,otto,steward gets dropped.

No cheap rookie backs get picked.

.

Hey you rookie backs im sitting here with itchy feet and fading smiles.While sitting here n@ked bye the to take your calls.

 

[Significant]

To many ifs

Just wait a week it won't kill ya, trades are gold.

Okay Jackie, what about if I wait up until the Blues-Demons game on the weekend and if sh** goes down and it looks likely I'll need two trades the week after - do I have your blessing to trade Pickett > Hannan then?

 

[The Lemon]

If Hibberd gets dropped, I can loophole Otten and Stewart

happy days

J Smith's only purpose this week!!!!!