Position 2017 Rucks

[Hairy Lager]

You know what you need to do JC.

View attachment 340249

I want to like this but WTF is it?

 

[gutsroy]

In case not posted:

Witts Watch: Looks like he'll be playing in JLT 3, good news for those considering him.
Grundy / Keeffe: Mason Cox apparently hamstring trouble. Would guess Keeffe and Grundy could be the beneficianados of that with more ruck contests.

Bucks is too shrewd to risk a Rolls Royce like Jesse White* by throwing him in the ruck. (* I like old Jesse, reckon he is judged pretty harshly.)

 

[gutsroy]

I want to like this but WTF is it?

Guessing maybe something like this? Archie might be sleeping with the stingrays soon, by the sounds.

 

[Pea Nut]

Because he will be suspended for the remainder of the season.

All seriousness, if Goldy is even slightly underdone for Rd1, he will play.

Regarding Preuss, I think he plays regardless, with Mason Wood and Ben Jacobs now out for up to 2 months. Seems to be the consensus on the North board as well. Plays forward and chops out in the ruck. Might get people thinking twice about picking Goldy this year. See how he goes in North's JLT3 game, but if he plays well and named round 1, will more than likely be my R2. Super risky, but I am liking the look of it at the moment.

 

[CaptainChardonnay]

Is anyone else concerned that Gawn is going to get a role change? If he's not rucking solo, this could be Martin all over again.

If Spencer is named rd1, I'll be getting off the Gawn express.

 

[stevebbb]

Is anyone else concerned that Gawn is going to get a role change? If he's not rucking solo, this could be Martin all over again.

If Spencer is named rd1, I'll be getting off the Gawn express.

I'm over thinking about the rucks until the round 1 teams are selected.. no point doing your head in over it

might have to go into round 1 with Preuss and Cameron as R1 and R2


on topic though, if Spencer is named I have no idea what i'll do, but Gawn should still dominate as he's very dangerous in the forward line

 

[G-TRAIN07]

I'm over thinking about the rucks until the round 1 teams are selected.. no point doing your head in over it

might have to go into round 1 with Preuss and Cameron as R1 and R2

If that occurred than ^ more mid price madness for you stevebbb lol

on topic though, if Spencer is named I have no idea what i'll do, but Gawn should still dominate as he's very dangerous in the forward line

 

[Goats]

I want to like this but WTF is it?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tonya_Harding#Attack_on_Nancy_Kerrigan_and_aftermath

 

[toxic]

With Regards to Preuss

Has everyone forgotten about Ben Brown

Goldy
Brown
Waite

Do they then take Daw or Preuss or neither

 

[Pea Nut]

With Regards to Preuss

Has everyone forgotten about Ben Brown

Goldy
Brown
Waite

Do they then take Daw or Preuss or neither

this intrigues me so I was looking into it. The vibe I got from the North board was Preuss over Daw based on their first two jlt matches.

 

[toxic]

this intrigues me so I was looking into it. The vibe I got from the North board was Preuss over Daw based on their first two jlt matches.

I cannot see Goldy, Preuss/Daw and Ben Brown all playing

would be like Jurassic Park

but i could be very wrong

 

[TheOz]

I cannot see Goldy, Preuss/Daw and Ben Brown all playing

would be like Jurassic Park

but i could be very wrong

I reckon they should just forget about Daw, he's been on their list for what seven years now? Hasn't shown anything to suggest he's an AFL player, Preuss showed more in his one game.

 

[PoopingHindi]

Daw wasnt best 22 last year so Pruess being above him in the pecking or doesnt mean much.

...unless Waite gets injured/suspended again which is fairly likely

 

[stevebbb]

I cannot see Goldy, Preuss/Daw and Ben Brown all playing

would be like Jurassic Park

but i could be very wrong

2 tall forwards in Waite and Brown
2 ruck/3rd tall in Goldy and Preuss/Daw

could easily work

 

[gutsroy]

How long are WBD Campbell and Roughead out for?

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

How long are WBD Campbell and Roughead out for?

Ruff 6-8
Campbell 4?

 

[toxic]

2 tall forwards in Waite and Brown
2 ruck/3rd tall in Goldy and Preuss/Daw

could easily work

Where does The Daw/Preuss play

Would be the tallest fwd line ever assembled

 

[toxic]

How long are WBD Campbell and Roughead out for?

Agree..Won't make the 8

Sportsbet here i come

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

Where does The Daw/Preuss play

Would be the tallest fwd line ever assembled

certainly wont be the shortest, we have that covered

Ebert
Young
Gray
Wingard
Neade
Impey

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

Agree..Won't make the 8

Sportsbet here i come

i cant figure out who will over take them, so ive got them 5th now

GWS
Sydney
Melbourne/Saints
Melbourne/Saint
Dogs
Hawks
Geelong
Eagles

Richmond

 

[buttox]

Where does The Daw/Preuss play

Would be the tallest fwd line ever assembled

replaces petrie imo.
was just as tall last year.

 

[toxic]

replaces petrie imo.
was just as tall last year.

Petrie was mobile

Daws a spud, experiment over
Preuss is a wrecking ball in a straight line, after that its queen mary style.

Fwiw i loved Preuss' aggression

Is Waite fit?

 

[stevebbb]

Where does The Daw/Preuss play

Would be the tallest fwd line ever assembled

replaces petrie imo.
was just as tall last year.

what he said

though not as tall, Pies have done with Cloke, Moore, Cox/White and Grundy

Hawks even? so much more mobile, but still.. Roughy, Gunston, Hale, McEvoy/Ceglar

Waite and Brown are pretty mobile for big boys

 

[Hairy Lager]

Where does The Daw/Preuss play

Would be the tallest fwd line ever assembled

Worsfold use to play Cox and Nutnut in the Rucks and then Kennedy, Darling and Lynch Forward.
This strategy never paid off, we were to slow and unbalanced.

 

[toxic]

what he said

though not as tall, Pies have done with Cloke, Moore, Cox/White and Grundy

Hawks even? so much more mobile, but still.. Roughy, Gunston, Hale, McEvoy/Ceglar

Really

Pies fwd line was dysfunctional on a good daywith those boys playing

Hawks are so mobile there is chalk and cheese comparison to the kangas