2017 Supercoach / DreamTeam / Fantasy questions

[Blue__Balls]

Marchbank or Plowman. Plowman or Marchbank. It's a doozy.

I'm in a draft league and have had this trade offered to me. I am at a loss trying to split the two even after watching a couple of Blues games.

Going on the first month Plowman has the superior efficiency but Marchbank has more tackles. Marks and disposals are near identical.

You guys know them both, who would you take as a defender for the rest of the year? Leaning towards Lachie due to being a couple of year older but really I'm sumped.

Cheers

Marchbank will be relying on intercept marks to get decent scores, while Plowman does a bit more rebounding. Plowman for me, as he's a more versatile player who can change positions if he's having an off day, Marchy more likely to be given a shut down role.

 

[Prochard123]

Hey guys how are the job securities of Fisher and Williamson?

 

[juzza316]

Hey guys how are the job securities of Fisher and Williamson?

Rookies get a 2 year contract I think, so pretty good security until end of 2018

 

[slashin_velvet]

Rookies get a 2 year contract I think, so pretty good security until end of 2018

Hahahahaha perfect

 

[Prochard123]

Rookies get a 2 year contract I think, so pretty good security until end of 2018

Ok ahaha let me rephrase this.

Is either likely to get dropped in the upcoming weeks assuming the same level of performance.

 

[juzza316]

Ok ahaha let me rephrase this.

Is either likely to get dropped in the upcoming weeks assuming the same level of performance.

Sorry i couldn't help myself lol. Fisher is too early to jump on unless you have to. wait one more week.
Williamson could go well, but only one game away from being dropped.
Personally I am not touching williamson and waiting until fisher is on the bubble

 

[Pea Nut]

What are the general thoughts on Polson ?? What does he bring to the side, and who else is pushing for the same spot in the 22 ??

 

[iBeng]

Any truth in Murphy being out for a few months?

 

[Aphrodite]

Any truth in Murphy being out for a few months?

The rumour came from on of those Facebook fan pages and that same person has a Twitter fan account.



From the Club's website:-

http://www.carltonfc.com.au/sites/Carlton/news/2017-04-24/murphy-gibbs-update

 

[iBeng]

The rumour came from on of those Facebook fan pages and that same person has a Twitter fan account.



From the Club's website:-

http://www.carltonfc.com.au/sites/Carlton/news/2017-04-24/murphy-gibbs-update

Yeah, I suspected it was mostly horse radish.

 

[SC fish]

Sorry i couldn't help myself lol. Fisher is too early to jump on unless you have to. wait one more week.
Williamson could go well, but only one game away from being dropped.
Personally I am not touching williamson and waiting until fisher is on the bubble

Any update on Fisher after his second game? He looked like he went OK on Friday but will he stay in the team?

 

[Cripps 'n' Blue Bloods]

The rumour came from on of those Facebook fan pages and that same person has a Twitter fan account.



From the Club's website:-

http://www.carltonfc.com.au/sites/Carlton/news/2017-04-24/murphy-gibbs-update

Interestingly Supercoach has run with it, saying he's out for 4 weeks in his notes.

 

[Jedstar]

Hey guys, best of luck this week.

Just wondering, does this mean Murph is alright? I jumped on him at the start of the year with my SC team and was depressed after I heard about his injury thinking I'd need to trade him out. Should I keep him in then or will be a late withdrawal?

Sent from my D6603 using Tapatalk

 

[Cripps 'n' Blue Bloods]

Hey guys, best of luck this week.

Just wondering, does this mean Murph is alright? I jumped on him at the start of the year with my SC team and was depressed after I heard about his injury thinking I'd need to trade him out. Should I keep him in then or will be a late withdrawal?

Sent from my D6603 using Tapatalk

Should be good to go, although it appears Cuningham has been named as an emergency just in case.

 

[Jeremias]

Any update on Fisher after his second game? He looked like he went OK on Friday but will he stay in the team?

Kept his spot in the side for this week.

He'll be rested at stages throughout the year, but I'd expect to see him feature quite regularly at AFL level this year.

Same as can be said for most of our young players, really. We'll be seeing plenty of all of them.

 

[Prochard123]

What's happening with Sam Kerridge?

Is he just no longer in the primary rotation or just horridly out of form?

If it's the first case, could he get a more midfield-centric role in the upcoming weeks?

 

[Cripps 'n' Blue Bloods]

What's happening with Sam Kerridge?

Is he just no longer in the primary rotation or just horridly out of form?

If it's the first case, could he get a more midfield-centric role in the upcoming weeks?

Solid VFL form, but disposal has always been an issue. On the peripheral, but others likely to get a call up before him. Probably more injury protection these days.

 

[Yellow Feathers]

Any chance of seeing Polson and Fisher again? Or should I trade?

 

[Blue__Balls]

Any chance of seeing Polson and Fisher again? Or should I trade?

Fisher had a minor hammy strain - was touch and go for this week but we opted to give him time. Reckon he'll be straight back in as soon as he's fit (one week, maybe two if we're ultra-cautious) as he does all the right team things (tackling, chasing, positioning etc.) and uses the ball well when he gets it.

Polson I think will be a while off yet. He'll probably get another run at some point, but not sure he'll get the run of 5-6 games minimum that you need for him to generate some cash. That being said, I'd only trade him out if there's an absolute must-have cash cow that you need to jump on, as you're not making any money at all on trading him out.

 

[Yellow Feathers]

Fisher had a minor hammy strain - was touch and go for this week but we opted to give him time. Reckon he'll be straight back in as soon as he's fit (one week, maybe two if we're ultra-cautious) as he does all the right team things (tackling, chasing, positioning etc.) and uses the ball well when he gets it.

Polson I think will be a while off yet. He'll probably get another run at some point, but not sure he'll get the run of 5-6 games minimum that you need for him to generate some cash. That being said, I'd only trade him out if there's an absolute must-have cash cow that you need to jump on, as you're not making any money at all on trading him out.

Thanks mate! Will hold Fisher, then May have to look at moving Polson on, as I hate having a dead spot on the bench.

 

[thetank]

Speedy Jarrod Pickett: any chance of breaking back into the team, and getting more than 10 disposals? Exciting player to watch.

 

[BrownYouGun]

Is Macraedie playing VFL, if so any chance of a recall soon?

 

[SkyhorseTamer]

Is Macraedie playing VFL, if so any chance of a recall soon?

Is playing VFL, had a nightmare this round. Looks like he may be in the VFL developing for a little while now

 

[amazingjoshy]

How/will Gibbs's scoring be affected by Cripps injury?