2017 trade/draft thread

[bigmikles089]

 

[archiemoses]

I would say he has similar worth to vardy. So a fourth rounder should be more than reasonable

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

View attachment 426300

My God the pair of them look like "The Science Department" at High School.

Dull , colourless and boring.........., pure coincidentally I am sure ........ just a little bit like their draft selections.

Yeah but the Science departments safety record is elite.

 

[Godfather32]

Yeah but the Science departments safety record is elite.

Well hey, they did make the right decision to not give Butler a new contract so they can't be all bad....

 

[Monocle]

Well hey, they did make the right decision to not give Butler a new contract so they can't be all bad....

lol .......Nasty .... poor BUTTMAN

 

[bombard]

Why is Ah Chee being recruited? We don't want anymore spuds. Ah Chee will come in and Wellingham will be de-listed the day after. The current recruitment team don't have a good track record when it comes to trading.

"Shane Warne is shit. Can't bowl the wrongun for quids." -Pat_Cricket

"This Pele bloke is rubbish." -Pat_Soccer

"Ali has no bloody stamina. Terrible track record." -Pat_Boxing

"Won't win. Winx is a place chance at best." -Pat_Punting

"Kasprov lacks a killer instinct. Hack." -Pat_Chess

 

[Monocle]

Yeah but the Science departments safety record is elite.

Thats all good and well but it's like the virgin boasting that he has never had a STD.

Me I would take the possible pain for the sheer bliss.

 

[Godfather32]

lol .......Nasty .... poor BUTTMAN

Just some good natured sponsorship banter

 

[AsterixTheGaul]

So do we trust our List Management team not to blink? The Sneezer looks a good pick up but not for a 3rd.

How about we trade Schofield to add depth in talls?

 

[Altum Volantes]

Brandon Ah Chee is a big bodied inside mid / forward flanker

Willow Rioli is a big bodied small forward

EFA.

 

[WCErevival]

We shouldn't give up more than a 4th unless we want to trade off one of our duds too which is a win/win. Regardless of what Port think his potential is, 23 games in 6 seasons with only 5 this year is delist material. It would be like us asking a 3rd for Karpany or someone like that.

 

[new breed]

So do we trust our List Management team not to blink? The Sneezer looks a good pick up but not for a 3rd.

How about we trade Schofield to add depth in talls?

Not confident in our recruiters they have probably told AhChee we will get him to WCE , thereby big chance to be screwed over . We will probably miss Kelly and Liam Ryan if we give our third pick , would be unlikely we would take both Kelly and AhChee with our second and third picks ...very unlikely .

 

[Nev57]

Nathan Wilson being let go by GWS for a second rounder in the mid twenties but AhChee Port want pick 47 ...just doesn't equate . Fremantle getting a great deal or we are being screwed over for a player who hasn't proven himself .

I take it Nathan Wilson has ties at Freo otherwise we'd be having a good crack at him ??

 

[new breed]

I take it Nathan Wilson has ties at Freo otherwise we'd be having a good crack at him ??

Mandurah junior played with Bennell etc ....Wilson is contracted and Ah Chee is uncontracted another factor in the trade that should be in our favour .

 

[Nev57]

I would say he has similar worth to vardy. So a fourth rounder should be more than reasonable

If we can get as good a first year from Ah chee that weve had from Vardy I'd be happy

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

Well hey, they did make the right decision to not give Butler a new contract so they can't be all bad....

One would have said "so a no to Butler??" and the other one would have put down the peanut butter jar and stared into space.

 

[Cuzz09]

So should we get Bartel?

On SM-G925I using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Yamumluvsbigcox]

So should we get Bartel?

On SM-G925I using BigFooty.com mobile app

Bit young for our list

 

[archiemoses]

If we can get as good a first year from Ah chee that weve had from Vardy I'd be happy

Could have similar upside but I think value very similar as Vardy's last year. Slightly different circumstances but similar value imo.

 

[Westend]

Next year we will have a fit Nicnat best tap ruckmen in the comp.... a fit lycett .. Nicnat helped pridda get a brownlow

A midfield genius who is becoming a coach in mitchell

You would think midfielders around the league would jump at a chance to come ???? what better service are you going to get if you are a midfielder ??

Ah Chee ...maybe thats what he is thinking ??

 

[kane249]

I think Ah Chee wants a better shot at getting a game, too far down the pecking order at Port.

 

[Westend]

I think Ah Chee wants a better shot at getting a game, too far down the pecking order at Port.

Look at the service a mid is going to get....its not going to get better than Nicnat And mitchell.......f**k all upcoming mids in the country should be jumping at the opportunity

I hope our recruiting staff use these factors as incentives for bringing in more talent

 

[Obeanie1]

Next year we will have a fit Nicnat best tap ruckmen in the comp.... a fit lycett .. Nicnat helped pridda get a brownlow

A midfield genius who is becoming a coach in mitchell

You would think midfielders around the league would jump at a chance to come ???? what better service are you going to get if you are a midfielder ??

Ah Chee ...maybe thats what he is thinking ??

I think that had a lot to do with winning him over. That plus a 3 year deal Im guessing.

Compared to the Suns we do have a fair few advantages. New stadium, big crowds, good kp forwards and backs and a weak inside midfield.

 

[footballfreak]

Not excited at all about the possibility of Ah Chee. Looks like a fringe player at best with a lazy attitude.

 

[ep2018]

Brendan Foster suggests we offer Kennedy up for Hogan. Loony or nah?