2017 trade/draft thread

[BartBart]

Reallllllyyyy*.




* That was the admittedly bad joke.

Was just getting annoyed that many people are quoting point values as if it means anything.

 

[amazingjoshy]

I'd rather keep our 1st round pick, but whether or not we entertain accepting 25+30 for 13, may depend entirely on if we rate Colyer or not if he's offered up as part of the deal.

God I hope not.

 

[boondy]

Our drafting is poor. We have garbage outside our best 22 . Maybe drafting older age players will net better results hence the thought of swapping pick 13 and 50 For 25 28 30 added to our pick 31 .

 

[Woobla Stainz]

Freo supporters are delusional Muppets! Apparently Weller is the next Ablett and is worth pick 2 plus another 1st rounder because he is a marquee player and his looks will sell more tickets and that makes him worth more.

But Wilson who i and most others agree is better than Weller is worth a 2nd round and Gws should stop being pricks and hurry up and trade him.

IMO whatever Freo gets for Weller should go to GWS for Wilson.

 

[twce13]

Freo supporters are delusional Muppets! Apparently Weller is the next Ablett and is worth pick 2 plus another 1st rounder because he is a marquee player and his looks will sell more tickets and that makes him worth more.

But Wilson who i and most others agree is better than Weller is worth a 2nd round and Gws should stop being pricks and hurry up and trade him.

IMO whatever Freo gets for Weller should go to GWS for Wilson.

They're desperate. Being the most unsuccessful team in afl history will do that.

 

[boondy]

Starcevich oscar kelly ryan archie this may be something we end up with with 4 2nd round picks and pick 68

 

[Woobla Stainz]

Starcevich oscar kelly ryan archie this may be something we end up with with 4 2nd round picks and pick 68

Don't actually mind that.

 

[Dark Sharks]

IF we do stupidly trade up the order, something tells me Port will play hard ball even further knowing we have an abundance of picks before our pick 50.

They'll dig their heels in and stand by pick 50 for Ah Chee.

 

[Darren2507]

Get another project ruck/fwd from a state league.

There really isn't need to keep giving Mcinnes contracts over and over and over again. He's not going to suddenly become AFL quality.

Been consistently solid at EP and never had an extended chance. Who knows what he could be.

 

[new breed]

IF we do stupidly trade up the order, something tells me Port will play hard ball even further knowing we have an abundance of picks before our pick 50.

They'll dig their heels in and stand by pick 50 for Ah Chee.

Maybe that is why we might be considering this and use 50 on Ah Chee but I read this morning Eagles wont be doing the deal of trading pick 13 unless it is a compelling deal .

" In Brady I Trust "

 

[Chris_6678]

Why should we pay for WB's stupid trading decisions?

 

[Happy Mastenator]

I will burn down eagles hq if we trade 13 for essendons 25+30 combo. Would be an unmitigated disaster.

 

[Chris_6678]

One of you guys ring up trade radio then?

 

[Happy Mastenator]

Why should we pay for WB's stupid trading decisions?

I just get the feeling it's the eastern states media putting 2 and 2 together and getting 5. If anything we should be looking to move up, not down. We have plenty of vanilla, we need the find an a grader. You don't get those with picks in the late 20's

 

[06Premiers]

One of you guys ring up trade radio then?

How could you tell? Did they go too far the other way?

 

[new breed]

One of you guys ring up trade radio then?

Money is on Fivey summed it up pretty well too

 

[Obeanie1]

Starcevich oscar kelly ryan archie this may be something we end up with with 4 2nd round picks and pick 68

Starcavich is a reach in the early to mid second round as is Ryan and Kelly IMO. They are very late seconds to third round picks.

Spargo, OBrien, Worples are better second round options......Oscar Allen may still be around at 25.

 

[Coasters7]

Thankyou to whoever got on trade radio and voiced the opinion of every west coast supporter. Why should we help Essendon? **** them, we are trying to fix our midfield with top end midfielders, not more b graders

 

[The Gtrain]

We traded pick 5 to the pies for 11 which was used on sheed. I cant recall what the other pic we received from the pies.

If we give up 13 i would want 2 picks in the region of 18 to 25.

11,31,49 (2222 points) for 6 and 44 (2113)

 

[Avalor]

I will burn down eagles hq if we trade 13 for essendons 25+30 combo. Would be an unmitigated disaster.

What gets me is why any self-respecting footballer would want to go to Essendon after what they did.

 

[Chris_6678]

Daniel Cherny ‏Verified account @DanielCherny 2m2 minutes ago
Brendon Ah Chee deal done. Eagles gave Port their next year 3rd rounder and received one of Ports 2018 4th rounders. @agerealfooty @WAtoday

 

[pantskyle]

11,31,49 (2222 points) for 6 and 44 (2113)

What made that better for us is we got the player we wanted at 6 anyway.

 

[Miguel Sanchez]

Money is on Fivey summed it up pretty well too

Haha wasn't me, I thought it was one of you blokes too!

 

[pantskyle]

Daniel Cherny ‏Verified account @DanielCherny 2m2 minutes ago
Brendon Ah Chee deal done. Eagles gave Port their next year 3rd rounder and received one of Ports 2018 4th rounders. @agerealfooty @WAtoday

Eh, not bad, not great.

 

[Chris_6678]

That is a good deal actually.