2017 trade/draft thread

[southerneagles]

Carlton
Receive: Gaff
Lose: Pick 2

West Coast
Receive: Gov Jr, Pick 2
Lose: Gaff

Adelaide
Receive: Gibbs
Lose: McGov Jr

We win that trade, but it seems like Adelaide lose out.

Thinking only at this point, and it does seem like adelaide win but really struggling to balance it, think there may be a swap later on:
Carlton
Receive: Gaff, 18 (assume they finish top)
Lose: Pick 2, Gibbs

West Coast
Receive: Gov Jr, Pick 2
Lose: Gaff, 9

Adelaide
Receive: Gibbs, 9
Lose: McGov Jr, 18

 

[Falco]

2 and GovJu for Gaff? I dont think so.

Its speculation of course, but Gaff has the most currency of the three players referred to.

 

[Godfather32]

Cartlon
In: Gaff, Adelaide 1st, Masten
Out: Gibbs, Pick 2

WCE:
In: Pick 2, Gov Jnr
Out: Gaff, Lycett, Masten

Adelaide:
In: Gibbs, Lycett
Out: 1st rounder; Gov Jnr

In reality Carlton probably wants our second instead of Masten but I just want to dump Masten somewhere.

 

[Falco]

Cartlon
In: Gaff, Adelaide 1st, Masten
Out: Gibbs, Pick 2

WCE:
In: Pick 2, Gov Jnr
Out: Gaff, Lycett, Masten

Adelaide:
In: Gibbs, Lycett
Out: 1st rounder; Gov Jnr

In reality Carlton probably wants our second instead of Masten but I just want to dump Masten somewhere.

We're paying too much I reckon. Lycett probably doesnt need to be part of this deal - unless Carlton ponies up a second/third for Masten which comes back to us.

 

[Godfather32]

We're paying too much I reckon. Lycett probably doesnt need to be part of this deal - unless Carlton ponies up a second/third for Masten which comes back to us.

It's basically Lycett for Gov which is fair given Lycett's injuries and then Gaff + whatever for pick 2. I think they're both fair trades in their own right.

 

[Falco]

It's basically Lycett for Gov which is fair given Lycett's injuries and then Gaff + whatever for pick 2. I think they're both fair trades in their own right.

Agreed - but we get nothing for Masten. I know its chicken feed but he would get us something, considering out list turnover this year every pick will be valuable for us because of how deep we'll go in the draft. Add in to the fact that Charlie Cameron is going to be targeted heavily by the Lions then maybe Adelaide will change it up a bit.

 

[Godfather32]

Agreed - but we get nothing for Masten. I know its chicken feed but he would get us something, considering out list turnover this year every pick will be valuable for us because of how deep we'll go in the draft. Add in to the fact that Charlie Cameron is going to be targeted heavily by the Lions then maybe Adelaide will change it up a bit.

I think Gaff for 2 straight up is weighted in our favour, Masten (or Lamb or pick or whatever) was to balance it out a bit.

 

[the early bird]

WC In: MMcgovern, pick 2

Freo In:

 

[Dark Sharks]

I liked the part after the dungeon cave where we traded Marsden.

Would read another short story like that again, but only if the sky tower and bumblesnap wizard is in it

 

[the early bird]

Interesting thought:

The Rover:
There’s going to be a big clean out at West Coast come season’s end with veterans like Sam Butler, Mark LeCras, Matt Priddis, Sam Mitchell and Drew Petrie either already announcing their retirements or soon to do so.

Which is why I find it hard to believe a rumour I’ve heard over the past couple of weeks from three different sources.

Word is there’s a super-trade under consideration of Andrew Gaff going to Carlton, Bryce Gibbs to Adelaide and Mitch McGovern to the Eagles, with a couple of draft picks moving around too.

Gaff’s been a gun for the Eagles the past three years and it’s hard to see the logic in moving him on, other than that he’s a free agent at the end of 2018 and West Coast may want to trade him while they can get a fair price.

The other two components – Gibbs and McGovern moving home – are both likely to happen, so maybe Gaff could be worked in to the package, but personally I’d rate him the best player in this deal so any ‘steak knives’ thrown in would have to be pretty fancy ones.


http://www.sportingnews.com/au/afl/...coast-suns/1f2rl99d942ff1qw5y2uu4cd5d/slide/2

See the shitstorm you have created!!

 

[avishka5]

rumour seems to be gov jr re-signing for 2 more years.

 

[southerneagles]

See the shitstorm you have created!!

Is it truly a shitstorm if Masten is traded?

 

[Godfather32]

Is it truly a shitstorm if Masten is traded?

I think we make a new rule that from now until trade week every trade proposal posted on here must include a way to get rid of Masten.

 

[new breed]

No we give Carlton pick 9 and Gaff we get McGovern and pick 2 !!!!!

Nah thought about it no way in the world will Carlton trade there pick 2 , just wont happen ...end of dream deal thought back to reality now .

Gaffy staying , which is great .

 

[WCErevival]

Its speculation of course, but Gaff has the most currency of the three players referred to.

Not that much currency. He may not even get us pick 2 alone.

 

[Carbine Chaos]

Must be the time of year when crazy three team trades that will never happen get thrown around.

 

[the early bird]

Gibbs is the best player of the three he's just 3 years older than Gaff which makes them pretty much equal value imo, Carlton won't give up pick 2 - who would? To me Gaff is worth a 1st round pick or 2 second rounders which is I would be happy with in MMcgovern and a second rounder

 

[FKASC]

Must be the time of year when crazy three team trades that will never happen get thrown around.

Just came to post that.

One false rumour and four pages of hypotheticals ensue

Can't believe it's that time of the year already...

 

[ziad]

Thinking only at this point, and it does seem like adelaide win but really struggling to balance it, think there may be a swap later on:
Carlton
Receive: Gaff, 18 (assume they finish top)
Lose: Pick 2, Gibbs

West Coast
Receive: Gov Jr, Pick 2
Lose: Gaff, 9

Adelaide
Receive: Gibbs, 9
Lose: McGov Jr, 18

no way the players involved will see Pick 2 moving home

 

[Godfather32]

Must be the time of year when crazy three team trades that will never happen get thrown around.

To be fair there's not much else going on

 

[southerneagles]

To be fair there's not much else going on

This is what happens when Bond goes missing

 

[Carbine Chaos]

To be fair there's not much else going on

Cole to Freo, Dawson to Carlton, Palmer to WCE.

 

[Godfather32]

Cole to Freo, Dawson to Carlton, Palmer to WCE.

 

[Monocle]

Cole to Freo, Dawson to Carlton, Palmer to WCE.

Not quite Cole stays at WCE, but the WAFL arrange that both Dawson and Palmer are Perth's elite signings for the 2018 WAFL season, all part of their equalisation plan to help Perth improve.

 

[Godfather32]

Not quite Cole stays at WCE, but the WAFL arrange that both Dawson and Palmer are Perth's elite signings for the 2018 WAFL season, all part of their equalisation plan to help Perth improve.

And the funny thing is that they would actually improve them