2017 trade/draft thread

[Yamumluvsbigcox]

Can't see why any club would want Masten. Poor skills, not particularly quick & poor decision maker under pressure. If he wasn't a number 3 draft pick he would have been delisted years ago.

Lamb has talent but hasn't developed in his 2 years at the club. Fasolo would be a good acquisition, an upgrade on Cripps for sure.

Ah Chee is an interesting one, can really play & dominated in the SANFL Finals but clearly isn't in Hinkleys best 22 which surprises me. Would be a handy player to get for a late pick.

Mastens kicking skills are quite good can send some absolute bullets given time and space but the rest is spot on he is pretty soft and outside. He does elite endurance and can find the ball .

I don't know where you get the fasolo is an upgrade on cripps from .
Cripps 2015 was far better than anything fasolo has ever produced in his career . The rest is pretty even

 

[avishka5]

Can't see why any club would want Masten. Poor skills, not particularly quick & poor decision maker under pressure. If he wasn't a number 3 draft pick he would have been delisted years ago.

Lamb has talent but hasn't developed in his 2 years at the club. Fasolo would be a good acquisition, an upgrade on Cripps for sure.

Ah Chee is an interesting one, can really play & dominated in the SANFL Finals but clearly isn't in Hinkleys best 22 which surprises me. Would be a handy player to get for a late pick.

Masten is a bit of a crab, however, he's actually got great footskills. Guys like JK,JD and lecca on a few times have come out and said they love leading to him.
His issue is that he cannot handle pressure and that with his poor decision making and you get a poor footballer. if he has space and going into 50, he'd hit up a forward on the tit. Which is sad cause he would have been decent player if his decision making or ability under pressure was good.

 

[kranky al]

Masten is a bit of a crab, however, he's actually got great footskills. Guys like JK,JD and lecca on a few times have come out and said they love leading to him.
His issue is that he cannot handle pressure and that with his poor decision making and you get a poor footballer. if he has space and going into 50, he'd hit up a forward on the tit. Which is sad cause he would have been decent player if his decision making or ability under pressure was good.

Or if he had pace - he knows hes going to be caught all the time

 

[eagles rule]

heard that Trengrove is in Perth checking out WA..

 

[ronpingwins]

heard that Trengrove is in Perth checking out WA..

You'll need to be more specific

 

[Boohemian]

heard that Trengrove is in Perth checking out WA..

Would only be to chat to little brother down the road.

 

[avishka5]

just saw dusty martin at noodle palace.

 

[Yamumluvsbigcox]

w

heard that Trengrove is in Perth checking out WA..

Which trengrove?

 

[Shmiddy15]

As long as we get Tim Kelly and AhChee I will be happy, would love a Hunter Clark or Andrew Brayshaw for our first pick

This'd be so great. I'd be genuinely excited to see how our new midfield would function with additions like these. These guys may not be the calibre of Mitchell or Priddis, but hopefully our midfield might function a little better with the extra run and pressure they can put on. That and the return of Nic.

 

[AsterixTheGaul]

heard that Trengrove is in Perth checking out WA..

He and half the uncontracted players in the AFL are looking at joining Freo. Seems a natural destination.

 

[Chris_6678]

Some guy on 6pr mentioned trengrove being hear.

 

[eagles rule]

You'll need to be more specific

A very vague source haha some caller into 6PR and he didn`t even specify which club or if Jackson or Jack ...

Probably b/s but he sounded happy that he had some info to share ..

 

[Abed]

Please God no to Watts. Surely that rumour is a troll.

 

[Nev57]

Natanui made our mids look so much better than they are

Nic nat was really worth an extra mid really his second efforts were very good , I just hope he comes back well from this injury


On iPad using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Yamumluvsbigcox]

Nic nat was really worth an extra mid really his second efforts were very good , I just hope he comes back well from this injury


On iPad using BigFooty.com mobile app

nic on one leg is a better ruck than vardy/Petrie

 

[Nev57]

Or if he had pace - he knows hes going to be caught all the time

he was in the top 3 players 2016 caught holding the ball


On iPad using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Nev57]

nic on one leg is a better ruck than vardy/Petrie

Or Lycett


On iPad using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Bleedblueandgold]

Agree with Masto being a good kick, but only if he's in free space with zero pressure.

 

[WereFlyingHigh4]

Why is Lycett so underrated amongst Eagles fans? His form before getting injured last season had him in the top 5-10 rucks in the comp imo. He is a much better player than Vardy and he should not be traded unless the offer is very very good.

 

[eagle dtrain]

What do you guys think of Lycett for AhChee ?
Both kind of good players with possible /probable upside but not getting a good run at their clubs

You sir have no idea

 

[liam123]

Got a mate at the club who basically has filled me in on a couple things. Apparently we are quite happy with our list progression and hope that a few decent top ups will get us over the line in 2018. Pick 13 is definitely on the table and we could be trading it for two second rounders. This would give us the ability to get fasolo, conca and watts with our three second rounders. Gaff is as good as gone to the hawks apparently for hartung/Strating and a pick/picks in 2018 draft. We are also hoping to get ahchee with our third and fourth rounder.

As far as the rookie list goes we are quite keen on Ben Kennedy (former demon), Jansen (former lion), and josh Cowan from geelong. They are all experienced and fill a need.

Going by his info our best 22 next year could be:

Hurn, eMac, welling ham
Yeo, gov , duggan
Masten redden hartung
Vardy shuey shred
Watts darling B Kennedy
Fasolo JJK cripps

Inter: conca Cowan Jansen barrass

Quite an exciting team I think. The bonus is that we haven't gone too far the other way. Our focus next year will be the players intent and putting in s four quarter effort.

I asked my mate about Tim Kelly and he said the club could rookie him if he's still available but the club are aware that the gap between afl and wafl is big so his game might not translate. Same pretty much goes for liam Ryan

If we do keep pick 13 we are heavily into naughton Balta or Stephenson if they are available. The club rates balta in particular very highly

So yeah some super exciting times coming up for our club

 

[Happy Mastenator]

Got a mate at the club who basically has filled me in on a couple things. Apparently we are quite happy with our list progression and hope that a few decent top ups will get us over the line in 2018. Pick 13 is definitely on the table and we could be trading it for two second rounders. This would give us the ability to get fasolo, conca and watts with our three second rounders. Gaff is as good as gone to the hawks apparently for hartung/Strating and a pick/picks in 2018 draft. We are also hoping to get ahchee with our third and fourth rounder.

As far as the rookie list goes we are quite keen on Ben Kennedy (former demon), Jansen (former lion), and josh Cowan from geelong. They are all experienced and fill a need.

Going by his info our best 22 next year could be:

Hurn, eMac, welling ham
Yeo, gov , duggan
Masten redden hartung
Vardy shuey shred
Watts darling B Kennedy
Fasolo JJK cripps

Inter: conca Cowan Jansen barrass

Quite an exciting team I think. The bonus is that we haven't gone too far the other way. Our focus next year will be the players intent and putting in s four quarter effort.

I asked my mate about Tim Kelly and he said the club could rookie him if he's still available but the club are aware that the gap between afl and wafl is big so his game might not translate. Same pretty much goes for liam Ryan

If we do keep pick 13 we are heavily into naughton Balta or Stephenson if they are available

So yeah some super exciting times coming up for our club

Nah. That's a terrible return for gaff. Better of getting composite him leaving as a free agent next year.

Hawks can't trade 2018 first rounder since traded 16 and 17 for JOM.

 

[ClayB]

Got a mate at the club who basically has filled me in on a couple things. Apparently we are quite happy with our list progression and hope that a few decent top ups will get us over the line in 2018. Pick 13 is definitely on the table and we could be trading it for two second rounders. This would give us the ability to get fasolo, conca and watts with our three second rounders. Gaff is as good as gone to the hawks apparently for hartung/Strating and a pick/picks in 2018 draft. We are also hoping to get ahchee with our third and fourth rounder.

As far as the rookie list goes we are quite keen on Ben Kennedy (former demon), Jansen (former lion), and josh Cowan from geelong. They are all experienced and fill a need.

Going by his info our best 22 next year could be:

Hurn, eMac, welling ham
Yeo, gov , duggan
Masten redden hartung
Vardy shuey shred
Watts darling B Kennedy
Fasolo JJK cripps

Inter: conca Cowan Jansen barrass

Quite an exciting team I think. The bonus is that we haven't gone too far the other way. Our focus next year will be the players intent and putting in s four quarter effort.

I asked my mate about Tim Kelly and he said the club could rookie him if he's still available but the club are aware that the gap between afl and wafl is big so his game might not translate. Same pretty much goes for liam Ryan

If we do keep pick 13 we are heavily into naughton Balta or Stephenson if they are available. The club rates balta in particular very highly

So yeah some super exciting times coming up for our club

I really hope he's winding you up. I think the only place a team with Conca, Masten, Hartung, Jansen & Ben Kennedy is going is into my nightmares.

 

[Eaglespur]

Got a mate at the club who basically has filled me in on a couple things. Apparently we are quite happy with our list progression and hope that a few decent top ups will get us over the line in 2018. Pick 13 is definitely on the table and we could be trading it for two second rounders. This would give us the ability to get fasolo, conca and watts with our three second rounders. Gaff is as good as gone to the hawks apparently for hartung/Strating and a pick/picks in 2018 draft. We are also hoping to get ahchee with our third and fourth rounder.

As far as the rookie list goes we are quite keen on Ben Kennedy (former demon), Jansen (former lion), and josh Cowan from geelong. They are all experienced and fill a need.

Going by his info our best 22 next year could be:

Hurn, eMac, welling ham
Yeo, gov , duggan
Masten redden hartung
Vardy shuey shred
Watts darling B Kennedy
Fasolo JJK cripps

Inter: conca Cowan Jansen barrass

Quite an exciting team I think. The bonus is that we haven't gone too far the other way. Our focus next year will be the players intent and putting in s four quarter effort.

I asked my mate about Tim Kelly and he said the club could rookie him if he's still available but the club are aware that the gap between afl and wafl is big so his game might not translate. Same pretty much goes for liam Ryan

If we do keep pick 13 we are heavily into naughton Balta or Stephenson if they are available. The club rates balta in particular very highly

So yeah some super exciting times coming up for our club

What the **** did I just read.

No Sheppard? How dare you. Did Nic Nat get traded in this fantasy?

 

[Biggie]

Got a mate at the club who basically has filled me in on a couple things. Apparently we are quite happy with our list progression and hope that a few decent top ups will get us over the line in 2018. Pick 13 is definitely on the table and we could be trading it for two second rounders. This would give us the ability to get fasolo, conca and watts with our three second rounders. Gaff is as good as gone to the hawks apparently for hartung/Strating and a pick/picks in 2018 draft. We are also hoping to get ahchee with our third and fourth rounder.

As far as the rookie list goes we are quite keen on Ben Kennedy (former demon), Jansen (former lion), and josh Cowan from geelong. They are all experienced and fill a need.

Going by his info our best 22 next year could be:

Hurn, eMac, welling ham
Yeo, gov , duggan
Masten redden hartung
Vardy shuey shred
Watts darling B Kennedy
Fasolo JJK cripps

Inter: conca Cowan Jansen barrass

Quite an exciting team I think. The bonus is that we haven't gone too far the other way. Our focus next year will be the players intent and putting in s four quarter effort.

I asked my mate about Tim Kelly and he said the club could rookie him if he's still available but the club are aware that the gap between afl and wafl is big so his game might not translate. Same pretty much goes for liam Ryan

If we do keep pick 13 we are heavily into naughton Balta or Stephenson if they are available. The club rates balta in particular very highly

So yeah some super exciting times coming up for our club

Thankyou for the laugh.

Fantastic stuff