2017 trade/draft thread

[Miguel Sanchez]

Daniel Cherny ‏Verified account @DanielCherny 2m2 minutes ago
Brendon Ah Chee deal done. Eagles gave Port their next year 3rd rounder and received one of Ports 2018 4th rounders. @agerealfooty @WAtoday

Happy with that deal.

 

[Happy Mastenator]

Daniel Cherny ‏Verified account @DanielCherny 2m2 minutes ago
Brendon Ah Chee deal done. Eagles gave Port their next year 3rd rounder and received one of Ports 2018 4th rounders. @agerealfooty @WAtoday

Nice. That's basically a 15 pick downgrade in the later rounds. If similar finishing spots to this year would be giving up pick 50 for pick 68. Can live with that.

 

[new breed]

Good deal Welcome Brendan

"In Brady I Trust "

 

[pantskyle]

Happy with that deal.

Really can't complain.

 

[AsterixTheGaul]

Daniel Cherny ‏Verified account @DanielCherny 2m2 minutes ago
Brendon Ah Chee deal done. Eagles gave Port their next year 3rd rounder and received one of Ports 2018 4th rounders. @agerealfooty @WAtoday

Happy enough with that one - feels like it would be a pick in the 50's as the net value.

 

[Chris_6678]

So we lose:

2018 third rounder

Gain:

Ar chee
2018 forth rounder.

Way better than us using a third rounder this year.

 

[Feeling Groovy]

I think Ah Chee will surprise many and be a really good addition to our midfield. A pretty good deal in my mind. We are now free to see if we can package this year's picks in any way to move up the order.

 

[bl4ke]

Now can the trading flood gates open?

 

[Biggie]

Good deal

 

[boondy]

Starcavich is a reach in the early to mid second round as is Ryan and Kelly IMO. They are very late seconds to third round picks.

Spargo, OBrien, Worples are better second round options......Oscar Allen may still be around at 25.

Good good. I have no idea but getting the names mentioned around picks 25 28 30 31 was my plan. Thanks for your input

 

[Eaglemaniac]

So we lose:

2018 third rounder

Gain:

Ar chee
2018 forth rounder.

Way better than us using a third rounder this year.

Isnt next years draft better though?

 

[Cuzz09]

We're happy with this. Port board are happy with this. What's going on!?! [emoji41][emoji28]

On SM-G925I using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[boondy]

Daniel Cherny ‏Verified account @DanielCherny 2m2 minutes ago
Brendon Ah Chee deal done. Eagles gave Port their next year 3rd rounder and received one of Ports 2018 4th rounders. @agerealfooty @WAtoday

Thanks for popping the Cherry post. We have been waiting to get it done

 

[Chris_6678]

Happy with that.

We can use first rounder on best available mid

2 rounder who knows

3 & 4th Kelly and Ryan.

 

[06Premiers]

Is it a good deal? I thought next year's draft is deep AF?

Also, says "one of Port's 4th rounders". Who else's do they have?

 

[The Gtrain]

WCE 2nd round selections for the last decade:

2007
Pick 20 - Tony Notte
Pick 22 - Scott Selwood

2008
Pick 20 - Tom Swift

2009
Pick 22 - Gerrick Weedon
Pick 23 - Koby Stevens

2010
Pick 29 - Scott Lycett

2011*
Picks 23 and 28 were first round and netted Newman and Mccines

2012*
Our first pick was start of the 3rd round at 45 Brant Collage

2013
Pick 31 - Malcolm Carpany

2014
Pick 32 - Tom Lamb

2015
Pick 28 - Luke Partington
Pick 36 - Tom Cole

2016
Pick 37 - Josh Rotham

Not a single blue chip player or even high level contributor on the list. That's not to say recent picks won't come good, but WC history with 2nd round selections is terrible.

EDIT: if you want, feel free to include 2010 pick 26 Jack Darling, who was a priority selection.

I thought about some other clubs 2nd rounders I picked Sydney first up looking through the last few years, i thought well we haven't done so bad by comparison, I then got to 2009, 2008 Luke Parker and Hannebery I couldn't be bothered looking at any more teams

 

[Chris_6678]

Isnt next years draft better though?

The top 20 or so are meant to be way better.

 

[JimmyBeerCans]

Good luck to Arch

 

[ziad]

I think Ah Chee will surprise many and be a really good addition to our midfield. A pretty good deal in my mind. We are now free to see if we can package this year's picks in any way to move up the order.

I already see him as the next Judd

 

[Suma Magic]

I was hoping for a better deal.

Oh well.

Welcome Sneeze!

 

[boondy]

That is a good deal actually.

If we win the flag and port get the spoon it is like we give pick 54 and they give us pick 55 . Good deal.
But we gonna be talking about archie until final round next year as to what he cost us

 

[Feeling Groovy]

Isnt next years draft better though?

By all accounts, but we may have more to play with next year in terms of trading players, free agency etc. We desperately need some input in the right age brackets in this draft, not to mention getting some experience in young players. Trading future picks is always a risk but we haven't lost much on this for a potentially best 22 player that offers a lot of what we don't have (assuming he puts it all together).

 

[JohnW]

The same could be said of any pick just before the second round. Words no longer seem to have meaning.

Ok, include pick 26. The earliest 2nd round pick within that period was pick 19.

If we broaden the scope to from pick 19 over a 10 year period we can include: Darling, Newman and Mccinnes.

Oh and I forgot Stevens in 2009 at 23. Makes it even worse.

No it can't. Darling had fallen outside of the 1st round. That's the point. Any other late first round pick still had the chance of being picked up in the first round. Darling didn't. The 1st round had ended when he got picked.

The poster who said your original post was good was spot on. Just not 100% correct.

Sent from my SM-G930F using Tapatalk

 

[Bleedblueandgold]

Don't really get why it was next year's picks instead of this year's since next year's draft is supposed to be better... Kind of an odd decision, isn't it?

 

[ziad]

So we lose:

2018 third rounder

Gain:

Ar chee
2018 forth rounder.

Way better than us using a third rounder this year.

effectively about 3.5 rounder next year depending on who finishes where - very good.