2017 trade/draft thread

[DivideandMultiply]

For me, Charlie Cameron is worth a mid-second round pick at best. 12? Insanity.

Its a crazy deal.

Amazing what 1 final can do.

 

[Byron_Clanger]

Any last minute heroics or are the WC team sitting back smoking cigars already?

We got Masten and Hutchings. We don't need anybody. Pop the corks, boys. Another successful trade period!

#BackTheBoysIn

 

[Jimmy_the_Gent]

Yeah pick 12 for Cameron is crazy. He's a good player but he stepped up for a historically attacking team. Doubt he'll have the same opportunity at Brisbane.

 

[DivideandMultiply]

Dodoro super pleased with himself.

 

[Jimmy_the_Gent]

Doesn't he have an offer from GC?

I'm going off what I heard on trade radio maybe 45 minutes ago.

I also thought the Suns wanted to get rid of him no matter what.

 

[getgaff]

Don't rate Lang at all.

Just needs a good run at it injury wise.

If he keeps fit he should be an outside midfield regular at Carlton. Lots of run and carry

 

[Happy Mastenator]

List turn over
Mitchell 35 - ah Che 23
Petrie 35 - pick 13 (18 years old)
Priddis 32yr 6m - pick 21 (18)
Butler 31yr 9m - pick 26 (18)
Giles 29yr 9m - pick 32 (18)
Hill 28yr 8m - pick 37 (23 Kelly?)
Tunbridge 24yr 6m - rookie list (20)
Brophy 23yr 7m - rookie list (20)

Also potentially
Wellers 29yr 3m - pick 69 (18)

That's about 93 years younger across 9 players.

 

[Monocle]

Pick 19 for Weller maybe ...running out of time .

Nope Ross is such a stubborn, smug, arrogant prick he would rather miss out on a good deal from GC than lose face on not getting what "he demanded" ; that being a top 4 pick.

This is the same guy who isn't in a rebuild rather its : a re stump, re wire, re plumb ......... FFS ....... thats smell awfully like a rebuild to me , he is to bombastic to admit his own shortcomings as a good , but not great coach.

His ego is a massive obstacle ............ always has been.

 

[Always Ballin]

That's an overpay for Cameron. Athletic small FWDs are all the rage right now, but I'm not sure he's worth a pick that high. Maybe he might kick more goals not playing with 3 quality goal-kicking talls and Eddie Betts?

 

[Happy Mastenator]

Just needs a good run at it injury wise.

If he keeps fit he should be an outside midfield regular at Carlton. Lots of run and carry

Looked him up the other day. 44 games, only 6 with 20 touches or more.

 

[DivideandMultiply]

Is it just me or is Devon Smith is way overrated?

Hoskin-Elliot was the gun HFF that was being under utilised, before being traded to Collingwood. But Devon Smith is super low production. Great skills, but gets so little ball.

 

[getgaff]

Looked him up the other day. 44 games, only 6 with 20 touches or more.

He needs a continued run at it.

Will improve with that, Geelong board seem to think so to.

 

[WCErevival]

5 more minutes and I can get back to my assignments

 

[Happy Mastenator]

Is it just me or is Devon Smith is way overrated?

Hoskin-Elliot was the gun HFF that was being under utilised, before being traded to Collingwood. But Devon Smith is super low production. Great skills, but gets so little ball.

Averages 18-20 touches and a goal a game while getting limited midfield time. He's a gun. His knee is an issue.

 

[Feeling Groovy]

Looked him up the other day. 44 games, only 6 with 20 touches or more.

At a guess, it would be similar for Duggan wouldn't it? Young guys take time and Lang has had injury issues impacting his numbers.

 

[new breed]

Weller and Wilson at Fremantle next year is a very good combination probably the reason no deal !!

 

[Feeling Groovy]

Reports Freo may get 2 for Weller

 

[Dark Sharks]

Who are we looking to draft?

Explosive footballers, brah. Get with the program.

It's true, we want players that can do this

Preferably off the half back flank.

 

[Altum Volantes]

List turn over
Mitchell 35 - ah Che 23
Petrie 35 - pick 13 (18 years old)
Priddis 32yr 6m - pick 21 (18)
Butler 31yr 9m - pick 26 (18)
Giles 29yr 9m - pick 32 (18)
Hill 28yr 8m - pick 37 (23 Kelly?)
Tunbridge 24yr 6m - rookie list (20)
Brophy 23yr 7m - rookie list (20)

Also potentially
Wellers 29yr 3m - pick 69 (18)

That's about 93 years younger across 9 players.

Should have used the cap space and made up those years as quickly as possible I reckon.



Excellent durability.

 

[Feeling Groovy]

Dockers get Pick 2 and Matera

 

[Chris_6678]

Far out that is a good result for Fremantle pick 2!!!

So they have pick 2 and 5... Very handy for their rebuild

 

[DivideandMultiply]

Averages 18-20 touches and a goal a game while getting limited midfield time. He's a gun. His knee is an issue.

Yeah I dunno. Always seems to have less general influence than expected.

Has some nice quarters, and great skills, so an impact player, however he just doesn't have the kind of output to justify the trade deal.

 

[mad_eagle]

Reports Freo may get 2 for Weller

Surely not...

If so, bloody well done to Freo & Gold Coast should just fold right this very minute and move down to Tassy.

 

[new breed]

Huge .....

 

[Jimmy_the_Gent]

Jeez, pick 2 and Matera for Weller.

Gold Coast can't trade at all.