2017 trade hypothetical thread

[kingKerna4]

Gibbs to crows for pick 10 lever pick and wigg
Pick 10 to lions for schache and Archie smith ,back up ruck

 

[HairyO]

At the moment all trades are hypothetical because the list managers are sitting around doing **** all.

The AFL should tell them its finishing 3 days early.

I cant imagine how shit trade radio must be. Day 9 and so far Tom Rockliff left Brisbane. Shocking everyone.

 

[saintscott]

Not sure which side of the fence I sit on this but just out of interest...

WC 2018 first rounder for Saints pick 7?

If it were 8 instead of 7 i would do it. Then again i am a horrid gambler!

 

[Mego Red]

Why do port get r*ped in your fantasy?

We can trade for watts easily enough on our own we don't need to get fisted by losing impey and getting pick 43 back in a poss weak draft

Don't just say "get r*ped in your fantasy".

It's ****ing gross just flippantly talking about rape, you ****ing idiot.

And Impey IS only worth 43.

 

[DangerSloane]

At the moment all trades are hypothetical because the list managers are sitting around doing **** all.

The AFL should tell them its finishing 3 days early.

I cant imagine how shit trade radio must be. Day 9 and so far Tom Rockliff left Brisbane. Shocking everyone.

You've got the problem the wrong way round.
The reason nothing is happening is because nobody is allowed to speak to players until all this starts.

Make it so you can speak to the players whenever you want and this doesnt happen. Deals get done earlier.

 

[1990crow]

Any chance of a single trade going through this week?

 

[HairyO]

You've got the problem the wrong way round.
The reason nothing is happening is because nobody is allowed to speak to players until all this starts.

Make it so you can speak to the players whenever you want and this doesnt happen. Deals get done earlier.

Not at all true. Players are paying their managers to manage their contracts. The managers can talk to anyone they want about anything they want. The only thing they are not allowed to do is contractually agree to a deal. They can do everything up to that point. Buddy knew exactly what Sydney were offering and had agreed in principle in February 2013. He then just waited until the end of the year to sign the actual contract.

 

[Russian Demon]

Don't just say "get r*ped in your fantasy".

It's ******* gross just flippantly talking about rape, you ******* idiot.

And Impey IS only worth 43.

Its a word. If it has greater or painful meaning to you then thats something youve got to deal with.

You take away words you shut down conversations. That is the pathway to ignorance and censorship.

 

[DangerSloane]

Not at all true. Players are paying their managers to manage their contracts. The managers can talk to anyone they want about anything they want. The only thing they are not allowed to do is contractually agree to a deal. They can do everything up to that point. Buddy knew exactly what Sydney were offering and had agreed in principle in February 2013. He then just waited until the end of the year to sign the actual contract.

The managers can talk, but players cant tour facilities or speak personally to coaches about what they can offer or even negotiate pay structure at all.

Some players can get it done through their manager alone, but a lot would want to speak to people personally before making such a huge career move.

 

[DangerSloane]

Its a word. If it has greater or painful meaning to you then thats something youve got to deal with.

You take away words you shut down conversations. That is the pathway to ignorance and censorship.

I could understand that if the discussion was rape statistics or something...but thats just crap.
Thats like saying if I wanted to drop the n-bomb here talking about a black player it would be fine because "its a word".

 

[Hawker55]

The managers can talk, but players cant tour facilities or speak personally to coaches about what they can offer or even negotiate pay structure at all.

Some players can get it done through their manager alone, but a lot would want to speak to people personally before making such a huge career move.

While those are the rules, surely you don't believe players haven't talked to clubs etc before Monday this week?

 

[philthy05]

Don't just say "get r*ped in your fantasy".

It's ******* gross just flippantly talking about rape, you ******* idiot.

And Impey IS only worth 43.

Gtfo with your false indignation

Hardly a ****ing triggering use in context. Go cry about lever you spud.

 

[Miguel Sanchez]

Difficulty with the Ablett trade is reportedly that the Suns want a best 22 player but no Cats want to move north. So it may need a third party. How about Anthony Miles who couldn't get a regular game with the premiers but would be best 22 at Gold Coast?

Geelong gain: Ablett
Geelong lose: pick 34

Gold Coast gain: Miles, pick 54
Gold Coast lose: Ablett

Richmond gain: Pick 34
Richmond lose: Miles, pick 54

Puts Miles' value at ~pick 47 which feels about right. 54 probably not much use to the Suns given their bunch of high picks but they could on trade it for another mature player.

 

[pupstar]

While those are the rules, surely you don't believe players haven't talked to clubs etc before Monday this week?

Dead right mate of cause they have.

 

[Shmiddy15]

Difficulty with the Ablett trade is reportedly that the Suns want a best 22 player but no Cats want to move north. So it may need a third party. How about Anthony Miles who couldn't get a regular game with the premiers but would be best 22 at Gold Coast?

Geelong gain: Ablett
Geelong lose: pick 34

Gold Coast gain: Miles, pick 54
Gold Coast lose: Ablett

Richmond gain: Pick 34
Richmond lose: Miles, pick 54

Puts Miles' value at ~pick 47 which feels about right. 54 probably not much use to the Suns given their bunch of high picks but they could on trade it for another mature player.

Not bad, but I don't know if the cats would want to part with their second rounder for a season or 2 from Ablett.

 

[BLERN]

- Pick 3 to Dogs for Stringer and Pick 9

- Gibbs to Adel pick 16 & 18.

- Pick 16 to Bris for Schache

- Pick 38 to GWS for Kennedy

- seems possible

- not likely at all

- very unlikely

- no chance

 

[M Malice]

- Pick 3 to Dogs for Stringer and Pick 9

- Gibbs to Adel pick 16 & 18.

- Pick 16 to Bris for Schache

- Pick 38 to GWS for Kennedy

No Thanks, try this one on for size from a well respected poster on the Lions board, he's usually pretty spot on with his intel.

Carlton get- Josh Schache and Matt Kennedy.
Lions get- Pick 3, from Carlton.
Giants get- Pick 18, from Lions.


BTW no way you're getting Kennedy for pick 38, I would be happy to give up our pick 18 for him straight up.

 

[TENACIOUS]

No Thanks, try this one on for size from a well respected poster on the Lions board, he's usually pretty spot on with his intel.

Carlton get- Josh Schache and Matt Kennedy.
Lions get- Pick 3, from Carlton.
Giants get- Pick 18, from Lions.


BTW no way you're getting Kennedy for pick 38, I would be happy to give up our pick 18 for him straight up.

Pass SOS wouldn't do that

We would just do

- 2018 second round for Kennedy
- take Gibbs picks to draft

 

[Miguel Sanchez]

- Pick 3 to Dogs for Stringer and Pick 9

- Gibbs to Adel pick 16 & 18.

- Pick 16 to Bris for Schache

- Pick 38 to GWS for Kennedy

- Puts Stringer's value at about 25 according to the points, seems well under

- Reasonable

- Big overs

- Big unders

 

[Moist Biscuit]

3 way trade
Fremantle In: Travis Coyler
Essendon in: Jake Stringer pick 26
Bulldogs in: Hayden Crozier & pick 11

Pick 26 and pick 28 for Devin Smith

Future 2nd for Adam Saad

Or

Pick 11 for Adam Saad and pick 22

3 way trade
Fremantle in: Travis Coyler
Essendon in: Jake Stringer
Bulldogs in: pick 22 and Hayden Crozier

Pick 28 and future 2nd for Devon Smith





Fire away


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Don't want Colyer AT ALL

 

[Inzy7]

Okay now i know most will shoot me down but here goes!!
I want Carlton to go back to being Carlton!!

CARLTON OUT: PICK 3 & 2018 FIRST ROUND
CARLTON IN: Tom Lynch & Gold Coast 2018 3rd round

Carlton out : Bryce Gibbs
Carlton in: PICK 16 & ADEL 2018 2ND ROUND

Carlton in: Matty Kennedy & GWS 2018 3RD ROUND
Carlton out : ADEL 2018 2ND ROUND & GC 2018 3rd round

So all up:
CARLTON IN: Tom Lynch-Matty Kennedy-GWS 2018 3RD ROUND-pick 16
CARLTON OUT : Bryce Gibbs-pick3-2018 1st round

 

[Suma Magic]

Okay now i know most will shoot me down but here goes!!
I want Carlton to go back to being Carlton!!

CARLTON OUT: PICK 3 & 2018 FIRST ROUND
CARLTON IN: Tom Lynch & Gold Coast 2018 3rd round

Carlton out : Bryce Gibbs
Carlton in: PICK 16 & ADEL 2018 2ND ROUND

Carlton in: Matty Kennedy & GWS 2018 3RD ROUND
Carlton out : ADEL 2018 2ND ROUND & GC 2018 3rd round

So all up:
CARLTON IN: Tom Lynch-Matty Kennedy-GWS 2018 3RD ROUND-pick 16
CARLTON OUT : Bryce Gibbs-pick3-2018 1st round

Trade 1: reasonable but they would still say no

Trade 2: Change second rounder to third rounder and it's more reasonable

Trade 3: not enough as crows second round likely mid 30s

 

[LukeParkerno1]

- Pick 3 to Dogs for Stringer and Pick 9

- Gibbs to Adel pick 16 & 18.

- Pick 16 to Bris for Schache

- Pick 38 to GWS for Kennedy

You aren't getting two firsts for Gibbs. That may have been your asking price last season but you won't get it this year.

You'd need more than 16 for Schache- your 2018 first has to be involved.

Pick 38 is way unders for Kennedy, your 2nd and be done with it.

 

[DangerSloane]

While those are the rules, surely you don't believe players haven't talked to clubs etc before Monday this week?

I understand fully that they probably have.
But this is the point, get rid of the rule so they dont have to hideaway and have secret phone calls etc.

I dont see why a player cant be approached personally in season...it makes no difference to their final decision whether they get to speak directly or through a manager.

 

[DangerSloane]

You aren't getting two firsts for Gibbs. That may have been your asking price last season but you won't get it this year.

You'd need more than 16 for Schache- your 2018 first has to be involved.

Pick 38 is way unders for Kennedy, your 2nd and be done with it.

I love it how Carlton and their fans think Gibbs is worth the same as Lever lol