2017 trade hypothetical thread

[SterlingArcher]

What would you realistically give up for the following:

James Aish
Jack Crisp
Josh Smith
Tim Broomhead

3rd rounder
2nd
3rd
2nd

Probably harsh on Aish but think we could go after players we need more with 2nd rounder/s

 

[Baird]

3rd rounder
2nd
3rd
2nd

Probably harsh on Aish but think we could go after players we need more with 2nd rounder/s

I'd do all of those trades in a heartbeat. I don't think any of those players are worth a 2nd. Maybe Crisp is worth a late 2nd

 

[saintscott]

I'd do all of those trades in a heartbeat. I don't think any of those players are worth a 2nd. Maybe Crisp is worth a late 2nd

Aish is the only one i would take a punt on. Even then it is an area we have depth and not sure who he would get a game ahead of either now or post montagna retiring.

Broomhead seems to get a lot of love from pies fams. Surprised to see his name there. I'm not a fan but most pies supporters i know talk about him like we used to talk up spencer white

 

[Carefree]

Any substance on this move
Kade Kolodjashnij to the Cats
Link up with his bro

 

[JG22]

Any substance on this move
Kade Kolodjashnij to the Cats
Link up with his bro

Done deal

 

[saintscott]

Any substance on this move
Kade Kolodjashnij to the Cats
Link up with his bro

With what do you have to trade? More likely your brother goes to gc isn't it?

 

[Moist Biscuit]

Any substance on this move
Kade Kolodjashnij to the Cats
Link up with his bro

Lol With what? Trading away first rounders for Dangerfield, Henderson and Tuohy pretty much rules you out of trading for any of the young guns unless you're looking to trade a Duncan or Motlop. Better chance Jake heads north imo.

 

[saintscott]

Balic for savage. Can take our 3rd for your 4th if it helps

 

[Moist Biscuit]

Balic for savage. Can take our 3rd for your 4th if it helps

Think we'd prefer the 3rd tbh.

 

[BigFrizz36]

What would you realistically give up for the following:

James Aish
Jack Crisp
Josh Smith
Tim Broomhead

Think that you might have to perservere with them. They all have flaws Crisp in particular can burn the footy. Some of them seem the sort of steak knife players that you might be able to send to Brisbane should you do a Schache deal (would be funny if you tried to ship Crisp & Aish up there though)

 

[F_therest]

3rd rounder
2nd
3rd
2nd

Probably harsh on Aish but think we could go after players we need more with 2nd rounder/s

That's generous.

Crisp is average...not worth a second rounder.
Smith is worth no more than a fourth if that.
Broomhead a third at most...can't even get a run in the seniors when Collingwood are struggling.

 

[F_therest]

Carlton 2017 1st pick & 2018 2nd pick for Hopper & Kennedy.

I acknowledge that's a bit unders, but this is assuming they nominate us which usually gets the nominated club a slight discount.

 

[briztoon]

Think that you might have to perservere with them. They all have flaws Crisp in particular can burn the footy. Some of them seem the sort of steak knife players that you might be able to send to Brisbane should you do a Schache deal (would be funny if you tried to ship Crisp & Aish up there though)

Brisbane has no interest in steak knives anymore. We have so many clogging our list at the moment, it's going to take three years to delist them all.

Best 22 or draft picks, that's all we're interested in.

 

[M Malice]

Brisbane has no interest in steak knives anymore. We have so many clogging our list at the moment, it's going to take three years to delist them all.

Best 22 or draft picks, that's all we're interested in.

Bravo!

 

[BLERN]

Brisbane has no interest in steak knives anymore. We have so many clogging our list at the moment, it's going to take three years to delist them all.

Best 22 or draft picks, that's all we're interested in.

This.

Will mean little despite the fact that you nailed it. Vic clubs want cheap and quick solutions for their failures. Not realistic views...

Get it together.

 

[JRyan23]

GC: Brendon Ah Chee and pick 69
Port: Pick 43

 

[Stevi_Tigers]

What would you realistically give up for the following:

James Aish
Jack Crisp
Josh Smith
Tim Broomhead

im sure blair hartley has a hard on over them

 

[philthy05]

GC: Brendon Ah Chee and pick 69
Port: Pick 43

As far as trades go this is pretty reasonable. If ah chee gets a run of games I would be loathe to trade him as his upside is huge and this draft apperentlt isn't stacked around that mark.

 

[vozzon]

As far as trades go this is pretty reasonable. If ah chee gets a run of games I would be loathe to trade him as his upside is huge and this draft apperentlt isn't stacked around that mark.

As much as i like that trade to get us another pick i just think someone like Achee is a FA/ delist and PSD type. Especially after last year, so many players will be worth nothing.

 

[eth-dog]

What's a realistic trade to get Brodie Grundy to Essendon? I'd be offering either this years or next year's first and probably Leuenberger (of the three rucks we have I assume he's the one they'd want) with hopefully something coming back?

 

[jakefooty23]

What's a realistic trade to get Brodie Grundy to Essendon? I'd be offering either this years or next year's first and probably Leuenberger (of the three rucks we have I assume he's the one they'd want) with hopefully something coming back?

Geez, you'll need about 5 first rounders to get THE Brodie Grundy

 

[philthy05]

What's a realistic trade to get Brodie Grundy to Essendon? I'd be offering either this years or next year's first and probably Leuenberger (of the three rucks we have I assume he's the one they'd want) with hopefully something coming back?

So what you are offering is a first round pick and a free agent ruck you just signed? Just leave the offer at the pick and no, it's not enough

 

[eth-dog]

So what you are offering is a first round pick and a free agent ruck you just signed? Just leave the offer at the pick and no, it's not enough

2 years of service is hardly "just signed". If Grundy left they'd be after a ruck in the short term at the very least, would they get anyone better than Leuenberger? Kreuzer maybe, although I doubt he'd leave Carlton for another struggling side.

 

[philthy05]

2 years of service is hardly "just signed". If Grundy left they'd be after a ruck in the short term at the very least, would they get anyone better than Leuenberger? Kreuzer maybe, although I doubt he'd leave Carlton for another struggling side.

If they wanted a stop gap ruck they would trade cheaply for one , sign a 2nd or third string ruck or a free agent. They wouldn't trade their 23 ? Year old star ruck for a stop gap plus a pick between 8-13

 

[adsla69k]

Cant see Grundy going anywhere unless the deal is too good to refuse.

Just wondering the value for each of the following and if you agree.
Parish = 1st rounder + something?
Zaharakis = 2nd rounder?

Also what would it take to get pick 1 from Brisbane in this years draft? I really want Fogarty.