2017 trade hypothetical thread

[Bonkers000]

2018 first rounder for Mitch McGovern?

Why not this years?

 

[SterlingArcher]

2018 first rounder for Mitch McGovern?

Considering your likely trajectory, Adelaide would be silly to do this. Little chance of it being a top 10 pick, unlikely to be as good as this year picks.

 

[Jeremias]

Carlton should take that, you should have taken Adelaides deal last year.

No, and no.

 

[Moist Biscuit]

No, and no.

Won't find many neutrals that agree with you there. You could have Powell Pepper or Hayward right now instead of Gibbs.

 

[Jeremias]

Won't find many neutrals that agree with you there. You could have Powell Pepper or Hayward right now instead of Gibbs.

I know we could have, but I honestly believe most neutrals just don't have the same appreciation for how important Gibbs is to us at this stage.

Hayward looks to be a really good young footballer, but I dare say he'd look next to useless in our forward line this year without Gibbs further afield. We have the fewest inside 50s in the competition, and Gibbs is leading the way for us on that front this year.

 

[pinot]

Won't find many neutrals that agree with you there. You could have Powell Pepper or Hayward right now instead of Gibbs.

Prefer Gibbs.

 

[saintscott]

Prefer Gibbs.

Today yes, but given you are unlikely to contend for a few years spp would be handy

 

[Tomnat Tigers]

2018 first rounder for Mitch McGovern?

You don't trade future picks for anything less than a top 30 player in the competition. Imagine potentially trading a top 5 pick for Mitch McGovern.

 

[Tbonefreo]

You don't trade future picks for anything less than a top 30 player in the competition. Imagine potentially trading a top 5 pick for Mitch McGovern.

You don't? I have seen plenty of futures traded

 

[Stevi_Tigers]

apparently richmond have approached gunston's management team

 

[rfc4eva]

if Martin wants to leave he will.

How did Adelaide trying to match Danger's deal turnout?

Worked out well,they got more than if they just let him walk.But i guess you know that seems you're asking the question

 

[LukeParkerno1]

apparently richmond have approached gunston's management team

Makes sense for the right price. Would be very good as the 2nd tall.

 

[JG22]

apparently richmond have approached gunston's management team

Can't see a deal happening there

 

[Mitchell54]

apparently richmond have approached gunston's management team

Reading this almost gave me a heart attack.
Wouldn't be surprised as the commentators where saying how the Richmond 2nd forward has been useless all year. Gunston is a quality player and i know that every club would love to have him in their team.
What do you think Richmond would trade for him?

 

[Stevi_Tigers]

Reading this almost gave me a heart attack.
Wouldn't be surprised as the commentators where saying how the Richmond 2nd forward has been useless all year. Gunston is a quality player and i know that every club would love to have him in their team.
What do you think Richmond would trade for him?

no clue but we have 2 first round picks and need a forward so will be approaching a few and see what happens

 

[saintscott]

no clue but we have 2 first round picks and need a forward so will be approaching a few and see what happens

Tigers take back vickery and i would call that fair

 

[Stevi_Tigers]

Tigers take back vickery and i would call that fair

would take back vickery if they take todd elton

 

[Mitchell54]

no clue but we have 2 first round picks and need a forward so will be approaching a few and see what happens

Can't see us trading Gunston unless he wants to leave.

 

[Stevi_Tigers]

Can't see us trading Gunston unless he wants to leave.

yeah same but you guys need a first rounder we have 2 so stupid not to ask the question at least

 

[UpTheTigs]

Hawks fans, what's Gunston like as the 2nd tall up forward? Predominately playing the CHF role? Always thought he was more the 3rd tall guy.

 

[pinot]

Today yes, but given you are unlikely to contend for a few years spp would be handy

Today and the next five years

 

[JG22]

Shane Savage for Harley Balic

 

[jakefooty23]

You don't trade future picks for anything less than a top 30 player in the competition. Imagine potentially trading a top 5 pick for Mitch McGovern.

By how highly Adelaide rate him, a top 5 pick would be unders..

 

[jakefooty23]

Shane Savage for Harley Balic

No thanks

 

[go_the_dockers]

Shane Savage for Harley Balic

That trade is like us trading Suban for Stevens.