2017 trade hypothetical thread

[BloodySwan]

Id take that, would hope to maybe push into a low second rounder for McKenzie if possible but a 3rd is about right

Yeah McKenzie would be worth more is he didn't have injury problems

 

[Supersuns]

Yeah McKenzie would be worth more is he didn't have injury problems

Has been stuck on 99 games for a while now, i dont think he is going to make it this year with us, combantion of form and that he keeps getting injured every 3rd week

 

[Scotty_222]

Could Rockliff be a realistic chance to move down the road? Would have the cap space for him?

 

[Prochard123]

James Aish, Jack Crisp for Dayne Beams, Jack Frost, Jackson Paine

We had fun, let's swap em back for the lols

 

[Yippy Yi Yeo]

We get an immediate upgrade on Hooker, who can move to defence and play that intercept role and save Daniher from rucking. I'd also say that I believe McGovern is achievable.

M Gov wants to move back to Perth, highly doubt he'd be gettable by any other clubs besides west coast or freo unless you gave him a godfather offer, which you'd be stupid to do for a 3rd tall.

 

[eth-dog]

M Gov wants to move back to Perth, highly doubt he'd be gettable by any other clubs besides west coast or freo unless you gave him a godfather offer, which you'd be stupid to do for a 3rd tall.

Hm. I've heard differently, but okay.

 

[Heaps of fun]

Could Rockliff be a realistic chance to move down the road? Would have the cap space for him?

The last thing your club needs is culture poison like Rockliff.

 

[SCRAY72]

Kelly to North
Dusty to Bombres
Fyfe to St.Kilda
JJ to Freo
Gibbs to Crows
Ablett to Geelong

Or they can just stay at their current clubs.

 

[Yippy Yi Yeo]

Hm. I've heard differently, but okay.

what have you heard

 

[eth-dog]

what have you heard

That he isn't opposed to a move to Melbourne. He's more likely to go to Perth but Melbourne is an option.

 

[Yippy Yi Yeo]

That he isn't opposed to a move to Melbourne. He's more likely to go to Perth but Melbourne is an option.

It's always an option if the money is right, won't happen though.

 

[JG22]

Pick 5 + next years first for Josh Kelly

 

[Prochard123]

Is Gunston FA?

happy to offer 700k a year x4

If not, idk maybe our first rounder (Lets say pick 7) for Gunston+Sicily.

 

[adammania9]

Is Gunston FA?

happy to offer 700k a year x4

If not, idk maybe our first rounder (Lets say pick 7) for Gunston+Sicily.

Not worth it on either part imo - Sicily would be surplus and Gunston doesn't really answer our problems. On the contrary, the value of those two, especially Gunston outweighs a speculative pick but that's just my view anyway. I'd trade Gunston for De Goey, but I don't know what people would think of that.

 

[Prochard123]

Hahaha this kid haha

Hahahahahahhahaha you're so funny, wanna explain what's so funny?

 

[newblueo]

Not worth it on either part imo - Sicily would be surplus and Gunston doesn't really answer our problems. On the contrary, the value of those two, especially Gunston outweighs a speculative pick but that's just my view anyway. I'd trade Gunston for De Goey, but I don't know what people would think of that.

sure while at it sidebottom for pick 32 hawks first pick seems fair yehhh..
gunners is only the best foward hawks have an top 3 in the league 55 goals last year. de goey a guy barely best 22 in a bottom team yeh na

 

[adammania9]

sure while at it sidebottom for pick 32 hawks first pick seems fair yehhh..
gunners is only the best foward hawks have an top 3 in the league 55 goals last year. de goey a guy barely best 22 in a bottom team yeh na

The same Gunston that is on pace for an elite 22 goals this season?

 

[newblueo]

The same Gunston that is on pace for an elite 22 goals this season?

and? moore be lucky to have 22 goals in 3 years rather take gunners. 10 inside 50s tonight by the way. he is elite pick 5 would do it not a c grade slow de goey..

 

[Books]

Is Gunston FA?

happy to offer 700k a year x4

If not, idk maybe our first rounder (Lets say pick 7) for Gunston+Sicily.

Gunston is not a FA, and I suspect Hawthorn would politely decline your offer.

Or maybe not so polite.

 

[Prochard123]

Gunston is not a FA, and I suspect Hawthorn would politely decline your offer.

Or maybe not so polite.

Idk man i posted on the hawthorn board like 15 minutes ago and most if not all of hawks supporters seem pretty keen

The only way this deal can be to our favour is if u argue Sicily is worth close to a 1st rounder cause Mr Gunston is averaging 1 goal a game, less than Darcy Moore and alex fasolo lol.

EVEN travis cloke is averaging more goals per game than gunston

 

[adammania9]

and? moore be lucky to have 22 goals in 3 years rather take gunners. 10 inside 50s tonight by the way. he is elite pick 5 would do it not a c grade slow de goey..

Hahaha you absolute clown. Point me to where I mentioned Darcy Moore.

 

[Books]

Idk man i posted on the hawthorn board like 15 minutes ago and most if not all of hawks supporters seem pretty keen

The only way this deal can be to our favour is if u argue Sicily is worth close to a 1st rounder cause Mr Gunston is averaging 1 goal a game, less than Darcy Moore and alex fasolo lol.

EVEN travis cloke is averaging more goals per game than gunston

Gunston is playing a different role this year, spending much more time up the ground and in defence.

He ia still a quality player.

 

[newblueo]

Hahaha you absolute clown. Point me to where I mentioned Darcy Moore.

deary me did i say you did? i was merely comparing your bullet proof statement that if a player hadn't kick loads of goals this year he aint worth much trade wise.

so moore for pick 32 as he is only kicking a goal a game yeh haha

 

[adammania9]

deary me did i say you did? i was merely comparing your bullet proof statement that if a player hadn't kick loads of goals this year he aint worth much trade wise.

so moore for pick 32 as he is only kicking a goal a game yeh haha

Your anti-Collingwood parade is pretty pathetic. You obviously rate us a lot higher than you like to admit. Moore is also averaging more than 1 goal a game fwiw

 

[Flags_In_The_Bag]

L

Gunston is playing a different role this year, spending much more time up the ground and in defence.

He ia still a quality player.

lol that didn't wash when the Dogs people where saying Boyds not kicking more goals because he is more ruck or Stringer is less goals because more mid time.