2017 trade hypothetical thread

[HairyO]

that JOM deal looks like its really going to bite hard

We will know in the next 2 or 3 years for sure.

 

[JG22]

Would St Kilda offer their 1st round and give us our 1st round back for Gunston? Or Breust? Or Mitchell? Or Burton?

Deals all seem unlikely.

 

[eth-dog]

Darling is absolutely worth a first round pick

 

[HairyO]

Darling is absolutely worth a first round pick

Except he falls apart under pressure. So maybe if the goal was finishing 9th.

 

[UpTheTigs]

If he's injury free, he's a 55 goal a year small forward, you think pick 16 will get it done then?

If he managed to play an entire season injury free and produce those sorts of numbers then he'd probably be worth a little bit more than #16. I don't think any club would give up a 1st for him right now though.

 

[UpTheTigs]

Except he falls apart under pressure. So maybe if the goal was finishing 9th.

9th hey? Nth Melbourne would be a good fit I suppose.

 

[Buzzasto DaSilva]

Would St Kilda offer their 1st round and give us our 1st round back for Gunston? Or Breust? Or Mitchell? Or Burton?

Are you suggesting St Kilda part with two first rounders (both of which are top 10 at this stag) for one of those four players?

 

[HairyO]

Are you suggesting St Kilda part with two first rounders (both of which are top 10 at this stag) for one of those four players?

They seem to screw up enough on and off the field, so its only reasonable to sound them out.

 

[foj1]

McGovern to west coast
Francis to Adelaide
Kelly to Essendon
West coast and Essendon' s first round picks to gws

The likelihood of Kelly choosing the bombers is remote but hey he would fit in well and you could argue that we are as close to success as the saints or the Roos and we play in front of bigger crowds and have established blockbusters in Anzac Day and dreamtime at the g.

 

[foj1]

They seem to screw up enough on and off the field, so its only reasonable to sound them out.

They ain't the ones who screwed up last year champ

 

[HairyO]

They ain't the ones who screwed up last year champ

Really? They were finals bound this year. Should have played a bunch of burned out hasbeens and gone for the 1st pick.

 

[kane249]

McGovern to west coast
Francis to Adelaide
Kelly to Essendon
West coast and Essendon' s first round picks to gws

The likelihood of Kelly choosing the bombers is remote but hey he would fit in well and you could argue that we are as close to success as the saints or the Roos and we play in front of bigger crowds and have established blockbusters in Anzac Day and dreamtime at the g.

We aren't paying a first rounder for
McGovern.

Have the Bombers got the salary cap space for Kelly as well given what North are offering?

 

[ArdentEagle]

We aren't paying a first rounder for
McGovern.

Have the Bombers got the salary cap space for Kelly as well given what North are offering?

We could really do with Kelly though

 

[kane249]

We could really do with Kelly though

Who needs Kelly when you can give Priddis another year!

 

[Yoda_]

Have the Bombers got the salary cap space for Kelly as well given what North are offering?

Stanton, Hocking, Watson, Howlett, Goddard (re signed for less), Kelly.

We were to make a play for O'Meara last year. Not as much as the Hawks but enough. With the aforementioned guys retiring, frees up a significant amount of room in the cap on top of the 20% increase via the CBA.

We've got money to play with

 

[Topkent]

Pick 15 for Darling
Pick 16 for Jamie Elliot
600k x 4 for Reid

HF: Caddy-Reid-Rioli
FF: Darling-Riewoldt-Elliot

No chance for either Elliot or Darling
Those clubs have no reason to trade those blokes so the deal wouldn't get done.

It's like me saying pick 16 for Astbury and pick 15 for Edwards. Why would you want to trade them.

 

[Topkent]

Would St Kilda offer their 1st round and give us our 1st round back for Gunston? Or Breust? Or Mitchell? Or Burton?

None of those are worth a top 10 pick let alone 2. Maybe Gunston at a stretch could be worth a pick between 6-15

 

[Thetrader15]

Except he falls apart under pressure. So maybe if the goal was finishing 9th.

So Richmond then?

 

[Thetrader15]

We aren't paying a first rounder for
McGovern.

I'd have thought your first (12ish) is about right for gov. Maybe a 3rd rd swap (assuming crows finish ahead of wc....maybe) - naturally I am biased though

He would be very good as 3rd tall for your fwd line

 

[Foucault1989]

They seem to screw up enough on and off the field, so its only reasonable to sound them out.

Can Hawthorn supporters just disappear? No one will want to trade with you, especially first round picks for those kind of players. Stars of the comp won't nominate you. You have no picks in the draft....just fall and let others have a turn

 

[HairyO]

Can Hawthorn supporters just disappear? No one will want to trade with you, especially first round picks for those kind of players. Stars of the comp won't nominate you. You have no picks in the draft....just fall and let others have a turn

Maybe if you didn't think of it as an Under 10s competition....

 

[Tedeski]

Wow!
Carlton is back in town!

 

[saintscott]

Really? They were finals bound this year. Should have played a bunch of burned out hasbeens and gone for the 1st pick.

Salty.

 

[Bonkers000]

We aren't paying a first rounder for
McGovern.

Have the Bombers got the salary cap space for Kelly as well given what North are offering?

Then the Eagles will have some work to do because your second will be not even close.

 

[Snake_Baker]

I wonder what Josh Kennedy is earning at Sydney?