2017 trade hypothetical thread

[Skipper_]

Kyle Langford + 2nd rounder for Todd Goldstein.

No way. North would've have to give us something back for Langford by himself. The only rucks we will look at our depth options <26.

 

[Daniltchenko You Beauty]

Probably worth more to the Dogs than on the trade table. Early 2nd or late first would be the sort of area I'd be prepared to offer though.

Has played a lot of vfl for someone they value...

 

[LukeParkerno1]

Has played a lot of vfl for someone they value...

Coming back from an ACL. It takes time. Will take him time to get confidence back, will have a full pre season this year.

 

[Prochard123]

Pick 5 for Pick 13 + Pick17

 

[LukeParkerno1]

Pick 5 for Pick 13 + Pick17

Wouldn't you rather keep pick 5? You guys need top end talent badly. The further you go down this draft the less likely your needs will be met. It depends on your sides needs though. Personally I wouldn't do it. Top 5 picks are worth keeping.

 

[Prochard123]

Wouldn't you rather keep pick 5? You guys need top end talent badly. The further you go down this draft the less likely your needs will be met. It depends on your sides needs though. Personally I wouldn't do it. Top 5 picks are worth keeping.

The top 5 players in contention are mostly midfielders, which I'm sure you know we don't need. Would much rather someone like Hopper if Hine decides to continue being dumb.

The only player that meets our needs and is top 5 worthy is brander, if the talk is that he will go even higher then we would be better off selling pick 5 in parts. Ballenden, Hayes, Coleman-Jones, Belta, Naughton are all key position players that could all be around the mid teens pick.

 

[LukeParkerno1]

The top 5 players in contention are mostly midfielders, which I'm sure you know we don't need. Would much rather someone like Hopper if Hine decides to continue being dumb.

The only player that meets our needs and is top 5 worthy is brander, if the talk is that he will go even higher then we would be better off selling pick 5 in parts. Ballenden, Hayes, Coleman-Jones, Belta, Naughton are all key position players that could all be around the mid teens pick.

Firmly believe you go best available. Whilst you may 'need' some KPP, you can't go wrong with an elite mid.

 

[Soups]

Firmly believe you go best available. Whilst you may 'need' some KPP, you can't go wrong with an elite mid.

Come on to our board when that happens. It will be delightful reading.

 

[LukeParkerno1]

Come on to our board when that happens. It will be delightful reading.

Not as if you don't have KPP. Moore is developing nicely. You'll still have pick 20 odd you could easily go tall then.

 

[Chaisa]

The top 5 players in contention are mostly midfielders, which I'm sure you know we don't need

Wouldn't #5 be around the mark for Brander?

 

[M Malice]

Pick 5 for Pick 13 + Pick17

As it stands now we have picks 15 and 18 and if Port fall a bit we could end up with a pick around 13. I would do that deal with no hesitation.

 

[newblueo]

Not as if you don't have KPP. Moore is developing nicely. You'll still have pick 20 odd you could easily go tall then.

20 is the star that is whe.

 

[Bic]

No way. North would've have to give us something back for Langford by himself. The only rucks we will look at our depth options <26.

You think Langford is worth more than Goldstein? Nah.

 

[Prochard123]

Firmly believe you go best available. Whilst you may 'need' some KPP, you can't go wrong with an elite mid.

LOL you've gotta be kidding. You can't just stick to a general rule with no consideration to the circumstances. It shows a severe lack of understanding of the rule.

 

[Soups]

Not as if you don't have KPP. Moore is developing nicely. You'll still have pick 20 odd you could easily go tall then.

I agree Moore is going along nicely but he's the only one we have. Getting Treloar means we have missed out on 2015 and 2016 to draft a young KPF. Hopefully we can use that pick this year to fix it along with a possible FA signing to help Moore out for the next couple of years while we groom a young bloke in the 2's.

Pick 20 was used on Will Hoskin-Elliott.

 

[Prochard123]

Wouldn't #5 be around the mark for Brander?

Why did you quote the first half of the post and leave out the second half? I didn't even edit my post.

 

[Topkent]

Firmly believe you go best available. Whilst you may 'need' some KPP, you can't go wrong with an elite mid.

Ray Charles can see the pies dont need another midfielder.

 

[Roadto2018]

Should our picks end up being 5-7 and 8-10, would Brisbane entertain a trade for pick 1? Not necessarily just those picks either


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[LukeParkerno1]

I agree Moore is going along nicely but he's the only one we have. Getting Treloar means we have missed out on 2015 and 2016 to draft a young KPF. Hopefully we can use that pick this year to fix it along with a possible FA signing to help Moore out for the next couple of years while we groom a young bloke in the 2's.

Pick 20 was used on Will Hoskin-Elliott.

Arrh forgot about the WHE one. Then again who knows after the tree period you have another 2nd rounder. I don't believe in reaching for talls early in drafts

 

[Soups]

Arrh forgot about the WHE one. Then again who knows after the tree period you have another 2nd rounder. I don't believe in reaching for talls early in drafts

We are terrible at finding talls later on the draft so it's either got to be through trade or a top 10 pick.

 

[LukeParkerno1]

We are terrible at finding talls later on the draft so it's either got to be through trade or a top 10 pick.

You did get Howe. Moore is good. You do need a few more, I don't see it being in dire straight though.

 

[bungalow_bill]

The top 5 players in contention are mostly midfielders, which I'm sure you know we don't need. Would much rather someone like Hopper if Hine decides to continue being dumb.

The only player that meets our needs and is top 5 worthy is brander, if the talk is that he will go even higher then we would be better off selling pick 5 in parts. Ballenden, Hayes, Coleman-Jones, Belta, Naughton are all key position players that could all be around the mid teens pick.

Ballenden is Lions academy

Should our picks end up being 5-7 and 8-10, would Brisbane entertain a trade for pick 1? Not necessarily just those picks either


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

I would think not, Lions need elite mids. Though if we could snag Dow with pick 5 it's possible.

 

[kreglze]

What's Libba's worth? Out of favour, not the player he was.

Goldstein + something for Libba?

Libba would be someone the Suns structure would benefit from, but I highly doubt him leaving the Dogs at the moment. However, the off field issues that circle probably mean we look elsewhere

 

[Prochard123]

Ray Charles can see the pies dont need another midfielder.

Well apparently he also doesn't believe in picking talls early...

Daniher
Moore
Lynch
Wright
Patton
Hogan
Riewoldt
Kennedy
Franklin

In which round were they drafted? Oh that's right

Apart from Adelaide, no team can consistently find elite talls from 2nd round onwards if at all.

 

[cotter101]

Pick 5 for Pick 13 + Pick17

Pick 5 for Pick 15, 18 and Michael Close(KPF)