2017 trade hypothetical thread

[sexyhunk]

G.Ablett
J.Grant
M.Hallahan
T.Mckenzie
A.Sexton
S.Lemmens
M.Rosa
B.Matera
T.Nicholls
A.Hall
R.Thompson
M.Shaw
J.Lonergan

13 players that I would happily consider letting go for the right price or just a straight delist.

Obviously we won't turn over 13 players in one year, but I am just about over these guys and just the disappointment after disappointment.

Usually I am pretty measured about my comments about the Suns, but after today I am just overly tilted.

So have at it, Lads and Ladies, who wants them?

what happned to Mckenzie? he had a booming kick when he started just seem to be of the radar last few years.

 

[bungalow_bill]

what happned to Mckenzie? he had a booming kick when he started just seem to be of the radar last few years.

During the Lions game he kicked a bullet straight to the chest of a team mate. If I were GC I'd keep him.

 

[CasuallyDressed]

what happned to Mckenzie? he had a booming kick when he started just seem to be of the radar last few years.

McKenzie is the type of player a team in premiership contention should target.

If he's just in the side to use that weapon of a boot, he'll be handy, but he can't do much else.

 

[adammania9]

what happned to Mckenzie? he had a booming kick when he started just seem to be of the radar last few years.

Teams discovered that's the only skill he truly possesses. Terrible player.

 

[Yamumluvsbigcox]

G.Ablett
J.Grant
M.Hallahan
T.Mckenzie
A.Sexton
S.Lemmens
M.Rosa
B.Matera
T.Nicholls
A.Hall
R.Thompson
M.Shaw
J.Lonergan

13 players that I would happily consider letting go for the right price or just a straight delist.

Obviously we won't turn over 13 players in one year, but I am just about over these guys and just the disappointment after disappointment.

Usually I am pretty measured about my comments about the Suns, but after today I am just overly tilted.

So have at it, Lads and Ladies, who wants them?

What is hall worth ?

 

[ArdentEagle]

What is hall worth ?

18-25 for mine.
Ironically GC will hold a fair few of those picks anyway.

 

[kreglze]

What is hall worth ?

I would say 18-20 imo.

 

[F_therest]

Late 2nd? Early 3rd?

Wouldn't mind Matera for a third rounder.
Hall is another who would be nice to have.

But gee just googled them and found out they were 25 and 26 respectively...they just seem younger than that in my mind.
Still see Matera as a young kid with potential but really he's been in the AFL system a long time now and hasn't really improved much since he was a kid. Not sure how much of that is due to playing for Gold Coast.

 

[F_therest]

Pick 1 for Kelly straight swap?

 

[Mr MysteryGuest]

G.Ablett
J.Grant
M.Hallahan
T.Mckenzie
A.Sexton
S.Lemmens
M.Rosa
B.Matera
T.Nicholls
A.Hall
R.Thompson
M.Shaw
J.Lonergan

13 players that I would happily consider letting go for the right price or just a straight delist.

Obviously we won't turn over 13 players in one year, but I am just about over these guys and just the disappointment after disappointment.

Usually I am pretty measured about my comments about the Suns, but after today I am just overly tilted.

So have at it, Lads and Ladies, who wants them?

How much for Thompson?
and
Package deal on Thompson and Lonergan?

 

[blueiris]

Pick 1 for Kelly straight swap?

I don't want Kelly at the Lions

 

[F_therest]

I don't want Kelly at the Lions

Dont stress mate at this rate we'll have the 'honour' of having the no.1 pick...can't see us winning another game and can't see you NOT beating North and maybe even Melbourne who are flaky.

 

[Lazza16]

Williams and pick 9 for Lever

Trade Crameri to Melb pick 31

Trade Roberts to Carlton for pick 38

Trade Clay Smith to Brisbane pick 39-31 for pick 18

Go to the draft with Lever

Lever
18
25
37
39
79

Love it....

Sorry u can keep clay Smith

 

[Lazza16]

Given Reid is RFA Sydney can always force the trade. The question is whether the deal is going to be high enough to put together the currency to drag Martin off the Tigers who we are assuming will match almost any deal unless a trade is pre-arranged.

I think the Zak Jones element is linked in the sense of the first round pick - if it can pry loose the top 5 pick at Collingwood to send to Richmond they'll certainly offer it up.

I agree on the Tippett thing though, that's about cap room clearance.

So then:

Western Bulldogs receive Kurt Tippett
Sydney receive WB 2nd round pick

Melbourne receive Zak Jones
Sydney receive MFC 1st round pick

Collingwood receive Sam Reid, MFC 1st round pick
Sydney receive CFC 1st & 2nd round picks

Richmond receive CFC 1st, Sydney 1st round picks
Sydney receive Dustin Martin

Sam Reid signed new contract with swans

 

[Lazza16]

Jackson Merrett trade value?

Swap with Jarrod grant

 

[Lazza16]

G.Ablett
J.Grant
M.Hallahan
T.Mckenzie
A.Sexton
S.Lemmens
M.Rosa
B.Matera
T.Nicholls
A.Hall
R.Thompson
M.Shaw
J.Lonergan

13 players that I would happily consider letting go for the right price or just a straight delist.

Obviously we won't turn over 13 players in one year, but I am just about over these guys and just the disappointment after disappointment.

Usually I am pretty measured about my comments about the Suns, but after today I am just overly tilted.

So have at it, Lads and Ladies, who wants them?

Lions will have hall thanks for Josh Clayton n pick 89

 

[Prem17]

West Coast
Receive
Mitch McGovern, Cam Ellis-Yolmen
Give
Jack Darling, Pick 8-14, 2018 3rd Rd Pick

Adelaide
Receive
Bryce Gibbs, Pick 8-14
Give
Mitch McGovern, Cam Ellis-Yolmen, Harrison Wigg

Carlton
Receive
Jack Darling, Harrison Wigg, WC 2018 3rd Rd Pick
Give
Bryce Gibbs

Why would Carlton agree to that?
You are basically saying that Darling is the equal of Gibbs. He is far from it.
Carlton are also in need of both midfielders and 2nd round picks.
Darling, Wigg and a future 3rd rounder will get shouted down quicker than any of Adelaide's 2016 offers.

 

[Topkent]

Why would Carlton agree to that?
You are basically saying that Darling is the equal of Gibbs. He is far from it.
Carlton are also in need of both midfielders and 2nd round picks.
Darling, Wigg and a future 3rd rounder will get shouted down quicker than any of Adelaide's 2016 offers.

Darling is a strong bodied young KPP whilst as good as Gibbs is he is 29 going on 30. Might have 2 Years left at his best.

 

[Falco]

Lukas Webb to Eagles for a third rounder?

 

[Jeremias]

Darling is a strong bodied young KPP whilst as good as Gibbs is he is 29 going on 30. Might have 2 Years left at his best.

The answer you were looking for is "we wouldn't".

 

[Yamumluvsbigcox]

Why would Carlton agree to that?
You are basically saying that Darling is the equal of Gibbs. He is far from it.
Carlton are also in need of both midfielders and 2nd round picks.
Darling, Wigg and a future 3rd rounder will get shouted down quicker than any of Adelaide's 2016 offers.

west coast get boned in that too .
darling + our first + future 3rd
for mcgovern and CEY .

Darling is worth more than mcgovern for starters so we are then paying

1st + future 3rd for CEY crazy

 

[ronpingwins]

West Coast
Receive
Mitch McGovern, Cam Ellis-Yolmen
Give
Jack Darling, Pick 8-14, 2018 3rd Rd Pick

Adelaide
Receive
Bryce Gibbs, Pick 8-14
Give
Mitch McGovern, Cam Ellis-Yolmen, Harrison Wigg

Carlton
Receive
Jack Darling, Harrison Wigg, WC 2018 3rd Rd Pick
Give
Bryce Gibbs

Dark Sharks

 

[Danger Zone]

Hall and Lonergan would be be ones from GC I'd look at. Reckon Hall is somewhere 18-28, not sure on Lonergan.

 

[Pea Nut]

west coast get boned in that too .
darling + our first + future 3rd
for mcgovern and CEY .

Darling is worth more than mcgovern for starters so we are then paying

1st + future 3rd for CEY crazy

If Darling is worth more than McGovern, why do so many West Coast fans want to delist him on the spot every week ?? He has copped a huge amount of flack this year, and if he was really any good, he would be 'untouchable' from a trade point of view. Yet those same West Coast fans seem to have a huge amount of interest in trying to bring in McGovern ??? Doesn't make much sense ??

 

[Mitchell54]

Birchall + Hawthorn 2017 3rd for GWS 2018 1st