Remove this Banner Ad

2017 trade hypothetical thread

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Charlie Cameron is better than what you'll get at pick 14, unless you freak a Nat Fyfe style pick up

Fair trade for both parties imo

Going back to 2010 pick 14 has been Perryman, Hipwood, Lever, McCarthy, Corr, Devon Smith, Brodie Smith. I'd take Cameron over Corr and thats it.
 
Going back to 2010 pick 14 has been Perryman, Hipwood, Lever, McCarthy, Corr, Devon Smith, Brodie Smith. I'd take Cameron over Corr and thats it.

I'd take him over McCarthy, Corr and Devon Smith (injury affected). Hipwood was an academy player, but yes ahead. Lever and Brodie Smith definitely ahead.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Trade 1:
Hawks: Poppy, 2017 2nd rounder, 2017 5th rounder
GWS: Hopper/Kennedy and 2017 4th rounder

Trade 2: (don't know if WhiteX can be traded)
Hawks: WhiteX and GWS 2017 4th rounder
Lions: 2017 3rd rounder

Trade 3:
Hawks: 2017 4th rounder
Freo: Balic

thoughts?
 
Trade 1:
Hawks: Poppy, 2017 2nd rounder, 2017 5th rounder
GWS: Hopper/Kennedy and 2017 4th rounder

Trade 2: (don't know if WhiteX can be traded)
Hawks: WhiteX and GWS 2017 4th rounder
Lions: 2017 3rd rounder

Trade 3:
Hawks: 2017 4th rounder
Freo: Balic

thoughts?

Pick 60 is pretty much nothing. Other clubs will offer a little bit more and Balic's manager will tell him to pick a club who can get the deal done.
 
Trade 1:
Hawks: Poppy, 2017 2nd rounder, 2017 5th rounder
GWS: Hopper/Kennedy and 2017 4th rounder

Trade 2: (don't know if WhiteX can be traded)
Hawks: WhiteX and GWS 2017 4th rounder
Lions: 2017 3rd rounder

Trade 3:
Hawks: 2017 4th rounder
Freo: Balic

thoughts?
I'm over whiteX he's had he's chance of coming to the Lions no longer a required player for us we already have players better than him on our list looks finished
 
Trade 1:
Hawks: Poppy, 2017 2nd rounder, 2017 5th rounder
GWS: Hopper/Kennedy and 2017 4th rounder

Trade 2: (don't know if WhiteX can be traded)
Hawks: WhiteX and GWS 2017 4th rounder
Lions: 2017 3rd rounder

Trade 3:
Hawks: 2017 4th rounder
Freo: Balic

thoughts?
Bwahahahahaha

Seriously 4th and 5th round picks have no value what so ever in this years draft. Unless a team is using them purely for points to match an academy bid.

As for the proposed trades. All your doing is trying to do is screw teams over.
 
Trade 1:
Hawks: Poppy, 2017 2nd rounder, 2017 5th rounder
GWS: Hopper/Kennedy and 2017 4th rounder

Trade 2: (don't know if WhiteX can be traded)
Hawks: WhiteX and GWS 2017 4th rounder
Lions: 2017 3rd rounder

Trade 3:
Hawks: 2017 4th rounder
Freo: Balic

thoughts?

No to all


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Pick 15+Martin for pick 2, if they dont accept we match the offer. North can give 2018 1st rounder+pick 15 for Kelly. But we're getting pick 2.
 
Trade 1:
Hawks: Poppy, 2017 2nd rounder, 2017 5th rounder
GWS: Hopper/Kennedy and 2017 4th rounder

Trade 2: (don't know if WhiteX can be traded)
Hawks: WhiteX and GWS 2017 4th rounder
Lions: 2017 3rd rounder

Trade 3:
Hawks: 2017 4th rounder
Freo: Balic

thoughts?
Puopolo is a spud who doesn't equate to Jacob Hopper or Matthew Kennedy ffs
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Trade 1:
Hawks: Poppy, 2017 2nd rounder, 2017 5th rounder
GWS: Hopper/Kennedy and 2017 4th rounder

Trade 2: (don't know if WhiteX can be traded)
Hawks: WhiteX and GWS 2017 4th rounder
Lions: 2017 3rd rounder

Trade 3:
Hawks: 2017 4th rounder
Freo: Balic

thoughts?

That first trade could be the dumbest thing I've seen on bigfooty


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Saints fans seem to not be in love with Gaff, so want him cheap.

Eagles would ask for two firsts, but I think a first and second would probably be around the value
 
Saints fans seem to not be in love with Gaff, so want him cheap.

Eagles would ask for two firsts, but I think a first and second would probably be around the value

Depends one the value of the picks reckon a top 10 and early 20 pick his is value, Eagles will want more


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Pick 15+Martin for pick 2, if they dont accept we match the offer. North can give 2018 1st rounder+pick 15 for Kelly. But we're getting pick 2.
That seems to be a really complicated demand.

North need to trade with gc in order to get pick 2 in order to give it to you instead of using the other approach of... offer dusty money rich cant match and keep pick 4.

I know which option i would go for
 
No way I'd be swapping Watts for Casboult. Considering we re-signed Pedersen and have Weideman coming through we don't have a huge need for Casboult.

The only clubs who should consider Casboult are Carlton (keeping him on a mid-range salary), Richmond (depends on Griffiths future) and Collingwood (Cox future up in the air, White gone, they can play Reid up there to protect Moore but how long will Dunn go around for before Reid moves back?).

Melbourne wouldn't even think about him. Especially if Tom McDonald looks to be a more permanent forward option (if you get Lever).can't cause too many goal-causing turnovers in the forward line...
 
Pick 15+Martin for pick 2, if they dont accept we match the offer. North can give 2018 1st rounder+pick 15 for Kelly. But we're getting pick 2.

North don't have pick 2. Also awful logic. Why would North accept that trade BEFORE you've matched the offer - if you match the offer then they will have to trade with you, but it'd be wise for North to call your bluff, offer Martin the contract and see if you don't match the offer. If you don't, they just kick pick 4 and 2018 first rounder onto GWS for Kelly, getting Kelly & Martin essentially for a first rounder each...
 

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top