Remove this Banner Ad

2017 trade hypothetical thread

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

WWSD said:
What would Matthew Taberner cost?
Click to expand...
Hard to imagine freo wanting to trade 1 of there 3 players taller than 5 ft.

Probably a mid 2nd rounder at a guess
 
foj1 said:
Jacob hopper for Essendon first round pick.
Click to expand...
If you can get him to nominate you then that deal will likely go through without any hassle

Edit unless you make the gf. Pick 17-18 wont be enough on its own
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

BLERN said:
If you can get him to nominate you then that deal will likely go through without any hassle

Edit unless you make the gf. Pick 17-18 wont be enough on its own
Click to expand...
Damn, guess we'll have to package a third rounder with our pick 18.
 
_Swoon said:
Damn, guess we'll have to package a third rounder with our pick 18.
Click to expand...

Im sure you would be devastated if that was the result ;)
 
Burtman said:
Got Sydney in Sydney, fair chance it'll be pick 10
Click to expand...
Ultimately we would prefer that. But really comes down to who he nominates as to what sort of pick/s we accept
 
Meh depends on what the giants are like this year they can be extremely lenient but also very tough look at not giving up McCarthy but then Paul Ahern (a top 10 pick) goes for pick in the 60s
 
BLERN said:
Ultimately we would prefer that. But really comes down to who he nominates as to what sort of pick/s we accept
Click to expand...
I know he's had a few injuries and stuff but have u been a little disappointed with his output? Or is he performing below expectation just through lack of opportunity/played out of position?
 
Burtman said:
I know he's had a few injuries and stuff but have u been a little disappointed with his output? Or is he performing below expectation just through lack of opportunity/played out of position?
Click to expand...
Mostly played out of position due to others in front of him. That hasnt really allowed him the chance to show his skills as much as possible.

I also think he hasnt met expectations. Not mine at least.
 
BLERN said:
Mostly played out of position due to others in front of him. That hasnt really allowed him the chance to show his skills as much as possible.

I also think he hasnt met expectations. Not mine at least.
Click to expand...
I was pretty excited about him after his debut, and a lot of the talk that he was arguably the best mid from his draft, would love him at hawks just don't think we have the trade currency. Could walk into our starting midfield and be a top 2/3 mid. Haven't heard much about us chasing him though
 
WWSD said:
What would Matthew Taberner cost?
Click to expand...
The most divisive player on our list.

I wouldn't trade him because he's the best we have. I don't think Ross is partically keen on him though and would probably take a 2nd-3rd rounder quite easily. A few on our board would trade him for a packet of chips.

He's improved so much though from a few years ago, he's only 24yrs old. Leads the comp in average contested marks. Elite tank, decent speed. Not the best agility though when the ball hits the ground. He's a fairly accurate kick for goal.

In the WAFL he's kicked 33.12 in 13 games.
In the AFL he's kicked 11.6 in 8 games. (1.4 goals per game)

I think he's capable of a 35-40 goal season. I've always said I'd love to see how he would go in a high scoring team like Adelaide or Hawthorn of yesteryear.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Burtman said:
I was pretty excited about him after his debut, and a lot of the talk that he was arguably the best mid from his draft, would love him at hawks just don't think we have the trade currency. Could walk into our starting midfield and be a top 2/3 mid. Haven't heard much about us chasing him though
Click to expand...
I think he will be fantastic in a team that really needs him. Similar to titch. Titch was already good but the change allowed him to shine.

If you guys could find a 1st. Or a player that we actually want rather than just someone you just want to get rid of due to age, then it could happen. But its more on the unlikely stage atm.
 
Collingwood pick 6 and 2018 2nd rnd pick to Adelaide for Lever.
Adelaide pick 6 to Carlton for Gibbs.
Carlton pick 3 and 6 to GWS for Kelly.
The blues do like the GWS boys, that is for sure, why not get a good one?
Just putting it out there!
 
LOZWILDA said:
Collingwood pick 6 and 2018 2nd rnd pick to Adelaide for Lever.
Adelaide pick 6 to Carlton for Gibbs.
Carlton pick 3 and 6 to GWS for Kelly.
The blues do like the GWS boys, that is for sure, why not get a good one?
Just putting it out there!
Click to expand...

What did hawthorn give for tom Mitchell and you want Adelaide to hand over pick 6 for a 29 year old Gibbs. Absolutely no chance
 
GWS are in the market for Small Fwd's, but they are after players with a certain skill set. Im worried they might be after Cyril.
Groin guru said:
Pick 4, 21, and LT
Click to expand...
I don't think they will entertain LT, he would struggle to get a game and list spots are incredibly tight at GWS. But stranger things have happened.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

If GWS want small forwards they should come past Tigerland.
Id be willing to give them Castagna or Butler for Hoppper or Kennedy.
We'd probably have to chuck something else in.

We have Bolton and Stengle in the 2's. They will both be good AFL players imo as well.
 
rainwizard39 said:
Meh depends on what the giants are like this year they can be extremely lenient but also very tough look at not giving up McCarthy but then Paul Ahern (a top 10 pick) goes for pick in the 60s
Click to expand...
Ahern hadn't played a game and was already set to miss 2017, they couldn't get anything for him so they just had to cut their losses. Not the best comparison. I posted earlier that the Magpies were going to send pick 10 to GWS for Adams before Shaw agreed to go there, he and Hopper have had pretty similar first two seasons so somewhere around that mark is far. The lowest the Bombers can end up with is Pick 11 which would be a fair swap.
 
So pick 6 for pick 15(Or is it 14?)+pick 18?

Hate pick 6 all the good mids are early but we dont need them.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top