2017 trade hypothetical thread

[kane249]

And people say trading for players is difficult.

This was sorted clean and painless

Negotiations are still on going

A Big Mac plus a Medium Coke and you've got yourself a deal

Ok a Big Mac and Medium Coke

BUT

We get to keep the Happy Meal toy

Deal?

 

[magpienato]

Negotiations are still on going



Ok a Big Mac and Medium Coke

BUT

We get to keep the Happy Meal toy

Deal?

Hmm... alright deal. Good doing business with you.

1x Underachieving Fasolo:

 

[bungalow_bill]

Starts okay then rapidly devolves into fantasy football. Why would Brisbane do their leg? They'll have no trouble getting offers from Schache a damn sight better than upgrading 18 to 10. 3 and 10 for 1 and 18 alone isn't far off an even swap. Meanwhile, what incentive do GWS have to offload Kelly and Kennedy on the cheap? A salary dump won't do it - trying to re-sign Kelly is the primary source of their squeeze, so him moving on solves it alone - and given Brisbane's lack of attachment to pick 1, on which this trade rests, there are a range of ways for them to get hold of it.

Bris are keen on Dow so for them to trade pick 1 it would need to be a godfather offer. And most likely staying but a contracted Schache is a top 10 pick min

 

[Betty_Blue76]

Bris are keen on Dow so for them to trade pick 1 it would need to be a godfather offer. And most likely staying but a contracted Schache is a top 10 pick min

As the person that posted it (and realise as a newb zero credibility) I suggest people read it closely.

For the Lions - you also get your free agency compo for Rockliff effectively upgraded from pick 18 to pick 2.

You still get Dow (as I noted you are keen on) at pick 2 because GWS take Rayner with your pick 1. GWS believe Rayner is that classy forward/mid hybrid their list is missing and if they have to lose Kelly - he is their price.

Is this a done deal? - absolutely not. But each component has been discussed with the individual clubs and nobody has said "hell no". Break it down and analyse it closely - works well for all involved.

 

[boncer34]

As the person that posted it (and realise as a newb zero credibility) I suggest people read it closely.

For the Lions - you also get your free agency compo for Rockliff effectively upgraded from pick 18 to pick 2.

You still get Dow (as I noted you are keen on) at pick 2 because GWS take Rayner with your pick 1. GWS believe Rayner is that classy forward/mid hybrid their list is missing and if they have to lose Kelly - he is their price.

Is this a done deal? - absolutely not. But each component has been discussed with the individual clubs and nobody has said "hell no". Break it down and analyse it closely - works well for all involved.

Or they keep pick 1 and have pick 1 AND 2 based on the Rockliff compensation

 

[Rich01]

Lennon is just a sh1tter Tyrone Vickery..

No.
He's kicked a truckload of goals this year in the VFL.
Is talented with the ball and when he has it inside 50, you'd back him in to kick the goal.

Problem is with our game style he just doesn't do what is required from a forward. His pressure when the opposition has the ball is minimal and he's not quick.

 

[Groin guru]

We will give Alex Fasolo away to anyone for two Free Big Mac coupons

View attachment 415128

What is the expiry date on those? Also, i prefer mcchickens. If you have 1 of those and a 30 cent cone w/ flake you got a deal. Will give you Swallow in return.

 

[citizen-erased]

We will give Alex Fasolo away to anyone for two Free Big Mac coupons

View attachment 415128

Has the talent. Just doesn't string consistent games together.
Mightn't be a bad one for gws to consider to play out and out FP.

 

[markm106]

No.
He's kicked a truckload of goals this year in the VFL.
Is talented with the ball and when he has it inside 50, you'd back him in to kick the goal.

Problem is with our game style he just doesn't do what is required from a forward. His pressure when the opposition has the ball is minimal and he's not quick.

The lack of pace and pressure may cost him being wanted by anyone. But agree he is very talented.

 

[jakefooty23]

What would a team have to to trade to get both Libba & Stringer?

 

[DaveLister]

What would a team have to to trade to get both Libba & Stringer?

a bag full of pingas

 

[Russian Demon]

What would a team have to to trade to get both Libba & Stringer?

Scarface levels of Charlie.

 

[Daniel McL]

Giveaway!

We are giving away Steven Motlop for free to any club that wants him!

Terms and Conditions apply.

T&C: He's s**t.

^ This was a joke btw ^

#TheGOAT

 

[WWSD]

Hypothetical trade

Fremantle receive
Ben Stratton + Hawthorn's 2017 pick 32

Hawthorn receive
Matthew Taberner + Harley Balic

Is that a fair deal?

 

[Since 2001]

Hypothetical trade

Fremantle receive
Ben Stratton + Hawthorn's 2017 pick 32

Hawthorn receive
Matthew Taberner + Harley Balic

Is that a fair deal?

makes me sick.
Stratton equals the trade and more

 

[cotter101]

Hypothetical trade

Fremantle receive
Ben Stratton + Hawthorn's 2017 pick 32

Hawthorn receive
Matthew Taberner + Harley Balic

Is that a fair deal?

Given where both clubs are at with their list development and demographics rather than face value , I think it's pretty good for both parties.

 

[Mego Red]

As the person that posted it (and realise as a newb zero credibility) I suggest people read it closely.

For the Lions - you also get your free agency compo for Rockliff effectively upgraded from pick 18 to pick 2.

You still get Dow (as I noted you are keen on) at pick 2 because GWS take Rayner with your pick 1. GWS believe Rayner is that classy forward/mid hybrid their list is missing and if they have to lose Kelly - he is their price.

Is this a done deal? - absolutely not. But each component has been discussed with the individual clubs and nobody has said "hell no". Break it down and analyse it closely - works well for all involved.

Hell no from Adelaide.

If we get that pick, we keep it for Fogerty.

We will offer our first, second and third for Gibbs and your third.

 

[Rob R]

Hypothetical trade

Fremantle receive
Ben Stratton + Hawthorn's 2017 pick 32

Hawthorn receive
Matthew Taberner + Harley Balic

Is that a fair deal?

Stratton for balic plus a pick maybe. Why would we want taberner and even if we did Stratton equals both of them on his own

On SM-G570F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[meima]

Stratton for balic plus a pick maybe. Why would we want taberner and even if we did Stratton equals both of them on his own

On SM-G570F using BigFooty.com mobile app

You can Keep Stratton, knee injuries at 28 years is hard to fixed . He can sit in rehab and collect his salary from hawthorn .

 

[HawkNation]

Stratton is an elite defender. No way we want Matty Tab.

Balic for a pick above 50 is my aim

 

[adammania9]

Hypothetical trade

Fremantle receive
Ben Stratton + Hawthorn's 2017 pick 32

Hawthorn receive
Matthew Taberner + Harley Balic

Is that a fair deal?

This is one of those rare times where the poster's hypothetical sees his own team get robbed.

 

[citizen-erased]

Bris are keen on Dow so for them to trade pick 1 it would need to be a godfather offer. And most likely staying but a contracted Schache is a top 10 pick min

We have 11 and I'd have no issue offering that up.
Hooker is going on 30.
Schache at FF, Daniher at CHF, Stewart as third tall. Tippa, Fanta and green at their feet

 

[Mitchell54]

Hypothetical trade

Fremantle receive
Ben Stratton + Hawthorn's 2017 pick 32

Hawthorn receive
Matthew Taberner + Harley Balic

Is that a fair deal?

We're getting robbed. Wouldn't even do it for Stratton alone.

 

[DanA]

Hypothetical three way trade:
Geelong: Jake Stringer
Richmond: Rhys Stanley + pick 20
Bulldogs: Pick 15

What are people's thoughts...maybe some late picks to balance things a bit better?

 

[DaveLister]

Freo wouldn't touch Stratton