2017 trade hypothetical thread

[DangerSloane]

Wright is more a half forward/midfielder. My point still stands, Puopolo would be in Carlton’s best 22. This is a team who has the worst forward-line in the competition.

Wright plays genuine small forward for Carlton, not up the ground. Often closest player to goal.

 

[DangerSloane]

ADELAIDE trade LEVER & #71 to MELBOURNE
MELBOURNE trade #10 & #27 to ADELAIDE

ADELAIDE on trade #10 & #27 to CARLTON
CARLTON trade GIBBS & #38 to ADELAIDE.

CARLTON trade #27 & 2018 # 2ndRd Pick to GWS
GWS trade SMITH & KENNEDY to CARLTON

Summary:
Adelaide
Gain; B.Gibbs
Lose; J.Lever & #71

Melbourne:
Gain; J.Lever & #71
Lose; #10 & #27

Carlton:
Gain; #10, D.Smith & M.Kennedy
Lose; B.Gibbs, #38

GWS:
Gain; #27 & Carlton's 2018 # 2ndRd Pick.
Lose; D.Smith & M.Kennedy

How is Gibbs worth more than Lever...?
What are you smoking?

 

[DangerSloane]

Closer deal would be:
MFC give up 10 & 27 for Lever
AFC give up 16 for Gibbs
CFC give up 16 & 2018 2nd for Kennedy and Smith
GWS send 2018 2nd back to Carlton

Very realistic.
Would be surprised if something like this didnt happen.

 

[citizen-erased]

Very realistic.
Would be surprised if something like this didnt happen.

You'd be keen to keep 10 with Fogarty a good chance to be there for that pick.
I wouldn't be using it on Gibbs. Not with a decent midfield already.

 

[Fitzroy bears]

How is Gibbs worth more than Lever...?
What are you smoking?

Looks like he forgot to put pick 38 in adelaide gains

 

[Mego Red]

Melbourne In: Lever Out: 10 + 27
Essendon IN: 10 Out Francis
Adelaide In: Francis + 27 Out: Lever

Then
Essendon In: Saad + 19 Out :11
Gold Coast In: 11 Out Saad + 19

Then
Essendon In Stringer Out:19
Dogs In 19: Out Stringer

Get Stringer and Saad and a top 10 pick.
lose Francis and pick 11.

10 for Fatty Francis!!

Dreaming.

 

[Mego Red]

ADELAIDE trade LEVER & #71 to MELBOURNE
MELBOURNE trade #10 & #27 to ADELAIDE

ADELAIDE on trade #10 & #27 to CARLTON
CARLTON trade GIBBS & #38 to ADELAIDE.

CARLTON trade #27 & 2018 # 2ndRd Pick to GWS
GWS trade SMITH & KENNEDY to CARLTON

Summary:
Adelaide
Gain; B.Gibbs
Lose; J.Lever & #71

Melbourne:
Gain; J.Lever & #71
Lose; #10 & #27

Carlton:
Gain; #10, D.Smith & M.Kennedy
Lose; B.Gibbs, #38

GWS:
Gain; #27 & Carlton's 2018 # 2ndRd Pick.
Lose; D.Smith & M.Kennedy

If Adelaide do that, we will burn down Rundle Mall. That's ****ing terrible.

10 is FAR too much for Gibbs.

16 and a third is more than fair for two good years of Bryce Gibbs.

 

[Mego Red]

Carlton lose their best midfielder. Adelaide keep their 1st rd pick and Gibbs effectively replaces Lever.
The fact of the matter is, unlike Lever, Gibbs is contracted and the Crows will have to pay overs if they genuinely want him. Who knows if they do or don't.

Gibbs is 29 and the fourth or fifth best player at a 16th ranked club. And, at best, their third best midfielder.

Lever is AA squad 22 year old, and ranked by Champion Data as the best young tall defender in the game.

Lever is worth MILES more than Gibbs.

 

[Mego Red]

Closer deal would be:
MFC give up 10 & 27 for Lever
AFC give up 16 for Gibbs
CFC give up 16 & 2018 2nd for Kennedy and Smith
GWS send 2018 2nd back to Carlton

Adelaide would want a bit of a bump. Let's call it a pick swap in 2018.

 

[citizen-erased]

Adelaide would want a bit of a bump. Let's call it a pick swap in 2018.

Fair call.
Though I wouldn't expect the dees pick to be that much lower than yours
They had some terrible luck this year. Adding lever is a good pickup for them too

 

[foj1]

Wow 19 for Stringer? I hope you offer only that, will get shot down really quick

No 19 is probably more than what you'll get.

 

[foj1]

Essendon 18 and 19
Brisbane 11 and 2018 second rounder

 

[Mitchell54]

Close. Let me try ...

Melbourne
Out: Pick 10, Pick 27 and 2018 Second Round Pick
In: Lever, 2018 third round pick

Adelaide
Out: Lever, Cameron, pick 16, pick 35, pick 51, 2018 third round pick
In: Pick 10, Pick 12, pick 38, 2018 Second Round Pick and Gibbs

Carlton
Out: Gibbs, pick 38,
In: Pick 16, Pick 27, pick 51

Brisbane
Out: Pick 12
In: Cameron, pick 35

This makes my head hurt... I like it!

 

[Wally Walpamur]

Gaff for pick 7
Lever drafted with pick 8

St Kilda get the icing on their cake.

 

[briztoon]

Essendon 18 and 19
Brisbane 11 and 2018 second rounder

In a heartbeat.

 

[foj1]

In a heartbeat.

i think if smith chooses essendon this will get done.
18 for stringer
19 for smith
brisbane move up in the draft

 

[HairyO]

Weird thread. Puopolo would be perfect for GWS, they need a forward who can apply some defensive pressure. And yes he'd be best 22 at Carlton too

Its both weird and exactly what youd expect from BF.

If Poppy goes it will not be for pick 50.

 

[HavUEvaSeenTheRain]

Gibbs is 29 and the fourth or fifth best player at a 16th ranked club. And, at best, their third best midfielder.

Lever is AA squad 22 year old, and ranked by Champion Data as the best young tall defender in the game.

Lever is worth MILES more than Gibbs.

i think he's our second best but if he is behind only Cripps (who I would easily prefer over anybody on your list) and Murphy (who has a résumé equal if not better then anyone In your midfield) then you're really not proving much.
Yes he is worth more and you'll rightfully get more but the difference is you have to trade we don't

 

[ItsAllAboutMe]

Pick 16 + Jack Watts to Adelaide, with Melbourne paying the bulk of his salary for Jake Lever
Adelaide trade Pick 16 + Josh Jenkins to Carlton for Bryce Gibbs.

 

[LukeParkerno1]

Pick 16 + Jack Watts to Adelaide, with Melbourne paying the bulk of his salary for Jake Lever
Adelaide trade Pick 16 + Josh Jenkins to Carlton for Bryce Gibbs.

You'd be doing well to get a Jenkins for Gibbs straight swap let alone Adelaide throwing in a first as well. Doubt the Crows would agree to losing one of their key talls for that price.

 

[ItsAllAboutMe]

You'd be doing well to get a Jenkins for Gibbs straight swap let alone Adelaide throwing in a first as well. Doubt the Crows would agree to losing one of their key talls for that price.

Fair enough, i didnt realise Jenkins was rated that highly. I dont particularly want JJ i was just thinking of a way the Lever, Watts & Gibbs thing could all work together.. Mostly Melbourne want to get rid of Watts and would be prepared to pay his salary which might be appealing to Adelaide, and Watts is a slight upgrade on Jenkins.

 

[LukeParkerno1]

Fair enough, i didnt realise Jenkins was rated that highly. I dont particularly want JJ i was just thinking of a way the Lever, Watts & Gibbs thing could all work together.. Mostly Melbourne want to get rid of Watts and would be prepared to pay his salary which might be appealing to Adelaide, and Watts is a slight upgrade on Jenkins.

Sorry but how on goodness earth is Watts an upgrade on Jenkins? Watts hasn't had 1 season like Jenkins had last year. I'm not a massive fan of Jenkins and wouldn't want my club chasing him but he'd be worth a bit as a 2nd tall.

Adelaide will just take the two firsts from Melbourne (giving the Dees back a 2nd) and be done with it. Gives them two firsts and Melbourne have an extra 2nd rounder.

Gibbs for pick 17 is more than fair. No real need to complicate that one. Will be done after the Lever deal if Adelaide even want Gibbs and I'm not sure they even do- it's more a "we will see". They won't want a repeat of last year's prices.

 

[CFC_#17]

Gibbs is 29 and the fourth or fifth best player at a 16th ranked club. And, at best, their third best midfielder.

Lever is AA squad 22 year old, and ranked by Champion Data as the best young tall defender in the game.

Lever is worth MILES more than Gibbs.

Lever plays loose in defence, if your club actually rated him you would of offered him more to start with instead of trying to re-sign him cheap.

Gibbs is contracted and blues hold the keys to a trade, Crows don't have any power with the Lever Trade.

 

[Mitchell54]

Fair enough, i didnt realise Jenkins was rated that highly. I dont particularly want JJ i was just thinking of a way the Lever, Watts & Gibbs thing could all work together.. Mostly Melbourne want to get rid of Watts and would be prepared to pay his salary which might be appealing to Adelaide, and Watts is a slight upgrade on Jenkins.

Jenkins is much better than Watts. Adelaide probably wouldn't let go of him unless it was something very, very good.
Pick 16 & 34 will get the job done for Gibbs

 

[DangerSloane]

Lever plays loose in defence, if your club actually rated him you would of offered him more to start with instead of trying to re-sign him cheap.

Gibbs is contracted and blues hold the keys to a trade, Crows don't have any power with the Lever Trade.

No power maybe, but Lever is worth twice what Gibbs is.