Remove this Banner Ad

2017 trade hypothetical thread

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Out of curiosity what would opposition supporters be willing to give up for Tim Broomhead in terms of either picks or a player?

He seems to be ridiculously highly rated by some on our board and just curious whether its just me that goes 'meh' or do other less one eyed supporters see something in him?
I don't think you would get anything. Would be best just to keep him and hope he comes good
 
Lions can keep Schache for what they're seemingly valuing him at. He's a borderline plodder so far, two 1sts is a farce, let alone one being Top 5. We'll take an FA CHF and our 2 1sts + F/S to the draft thanks.
 
Lions can keep Schache for what they're seemingly valuing him at. He's a borderline plodder so far, two 1sts is a farce, let alone one being Top 5. We'll take an FA CHF and our 2 1sts + F/S to the draft thanks.

He is a second year key forward. How well were guys like Jonathon Brown, Barry Hall, Tom Boyd, Tom Hawkins, Travis Cloke, Taylor Walker and other brute key forwards doing in their second year?
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

I think we need to offload a quality mid to get currency for a decent KPF, Sidebottom would be the one i'd look at trading, I'd like to think we'd get a mid (ish) first rounder for him.

Was talking to a mate aboit this last night. Would you consider Majak Daw + North's 2nd rounder (20-25) for Steele?

Reckon that would suit both teams and make both teams much stronger.
 
Was talking to a mate aboit this last night. Would you consider Majak Daw + North's 2nd rounder (20-25) for Steele?

Reckon that would suit both teams and make both teams much stronger.

:drunk: I just don't even know where to start on this one.....

Daw isn't a player type we need, Steele is, and is a big part of our improved midfield, we currently have two first round picks and are tight for spots, so likely take two active picks (assuming no big trades) and upgrade someone like Marshall with a pick in the 80's.
 
:drunk: I just don't even know where to start on this one.....

Daw isn't a player type we need, Steele is, and is a big part of our improved midfield, we currently have two first round picks and are tight for spots, so likely take two active picks (assuming no big trades) and upgrade someone like Marshall with a pick in the 80's.
Might want to read what he said again.
 
Well if last night showed us anything it is that we need another relatively good key forward to help out Jack.

Pies fans, would you be happy with our cats first rounder for Sidebottom?
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Well if last night showed us anything it is that we need another relatively good key forward to help out Jack.

Pies fans, would you be happy with our cats first rounder for Sidebottom?
If Geelong is top 4, no. Pick in the 8-12 range we will be happy with.

Although that's not we will be telling you during negotiations, but then again our drafting/trading department is stupid.
 
If Geelong is top 4, no. Pick in the 8-12 range we will be happy with.

Although that's not we will be telling you during negotiations, but then again our drafting/trading department is stupid.

Fair enough, we will probably have something like picks 12 and 16, wouldn't give up 12 only because Hayes might hopefully be there then.

Pick 16 and a fourth rounder?
 
Fair enough, we will probably have something like picks 12 and 16, wouldn't give up 12 only because Hayes might hopefully be there then.

Pick 16 and a fourth rounder?
Is a 4th rounder even worth offering?

How does that make a difference?

Pick 16+4th rounder

for

Sidebottom+Buckley on the other hand......


Pretty good we get to have Buckley upgraded.
 
Is a 4th rounder even worth offering?

How does that make a difference?

Pick 16+4th rounder

for

Sidebottom+Buckley on the other hand......


Pretty good we get to have Buckley upgraded.

We will take him, promise him a contract... then not offer him one.

Everyone wins?
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Demons fans, what would you lot ask for Neal - Bullen?
 
Lions can keep Schache for what they're seemingly valuing him at. He's a borderline plodder so far, two 1sts is a farce, let alone one being Top 5. We'll take an FA CHF and our 2 1sts + F/S to the draft thanks.

A second year key forward who was taken pick 2 2 years ago hasn't quite come on yet? Cmon now.
 
Could Matt Taberner be available at the end of the year?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Is he playing at the moment?

They had big wraps on him but he hasn't come on much, wouldn't give up much for him.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top