2017 trade hypothetical thread

[Smalls0304]

yes he is - but he is has been injury free for two years now and starting to play good football...he will play to 32 and in good form like mummy i am sure..mummy has had big injuries as well

There is ZERO chance that we trade Gibbs and Kreuzer to GC. Gibbs because of the obvious reasons and Kreuzer is more important to us than whatever we would get for him. We have very little currency this year. If Kreuzer kept his form up all year he might be able to fetch a band 1 on a tiny chance that someone did a Vickery/Hawks deal for us. Gibbs & Buckley only chances of getting anything back that i think we would trade. We just dont have anything to get their first

 

[Young_Guns]

Well if I want GCS first two picks how do I get them?

Why GCs first 2 picks specifically? You would get a better return if you trade Gibbs to Adelaide and sent Kreuzer to another VIC team looking for a ruckmen, as the Suns don't want/need Kreuzer, and Gibbs has been pretty hell bent on going home hasn't he? Get picks from those 2 + your own picks and thats not a bad haul to help the rebuild.

 

[thetradesman]

There is ZERO chance that we trade Gibbs and Kreuzer to GC. Gibbs because of the obvious reasons and Kreuzer is more important to us than whatever we would get for him. We have very little currency this year. If Kreuzer kept his form up all year he might be able to fetch a band 1 on a tiny chance that someone did a Vickery/Hawks deal for us. Gibbs & Buckley only chances of getting anything back that i think we would trade. We just dont have anything to get their first

Buckley? What do you think you're getting for him?

 

[Sinjin Smith]

Buckley? What do you think you're getting for him?

We wouldn't get anything for him, can't see clubs queuing up to secure his services.

 

[Shaneprice97]

So saints fans, is Bruce a possibility to be traded at seasons end? And if so, whats his value? pick 12-15?

 

[citizen-erased]

Would love to see Essendon go bold with some early pick trading if we finish in the bottom 6.

2017 1st & 2018 2nd for Grundy
or
2017 & 2018 1st for Hopper & Setterfield

Keen on looking at Wigg from Adelaide and giving him a chance to play AFL footy off our HBF.
Luke Brown too.
Not sure what price would be.

 

[Smalls0304]

Buckley? What do you think you're getting for him?

Late pick, think a few sides would consider taking him if we just delisted him so maybe a pick in the 50/60's

 

[NeutralFan]

2017 & 2018 1st for Hopper & Setterfield

 

[jakefooty23]

Buckley? What do you think you're getting for him?

I'd trade a future first rounder for Dylan Buckley

 

[Pea Nut]

Keen on looking at Wigg from Adelaide and giving him a chance to play AFL footy off our HBF.
Luke Brown too.
Not sure what price would be.

Wigg is gettable for sure, and would probably be pretty cheap. Dont think he would serve you much good off a half back flank though to be honest. Luke Brown wouldn't be cheap and he is one we will want to lock away. He is our best lock down small defender and a gun.

 

[M Malice]

Looks almost certain we will have pick 1 this year along with Ports 1st rounder (between 9-16?), what would teams be willing to give for one or both those picks. Similar to the deal we did last year with GWS ie. IIRC our pick 2 for picks 3 and 17. Deal may have to involve multiple clubs as the only other club with 2 first round picks is St.Kilda (on current ladder position picks 3 and 11).

 

[briztoon]

Looks almost certain we will have pick 1 this year along with Ports 1st rounder (between 9-16?), what would teams be willing to give for one or both those picks. Similar to the deal we did last year with GWS ie. IIRC our pick 2 for picks 3 and 17. Deal may have to involve multiple clubs as the only other club with 2 first round picks is St.Kilda (on current ladder position picks 3 and 11).

Doesn't Richmond have two firsts? Admittedly not attractive ones.

 

[M Malice]

Doesn't Richmond have two firsts? Admittedly not attractive ones.

You're right briztoon, as it stands now the tigers have picks 13 and 16, thanks. With no clear standout number 1 ATM I would give up our number 1 for the saints picks 3 and 11 in a heartbeat.

 

[briztoon]

You're right briztoon, as it stands now the tigers have picks 13 and 16, thanks. With no clear standout number 1 ATM I would give up our number 1 for the saints picks 3 and 11 in a heartbeat.

I guess the two obvious questions are, would St Kilda be willing to trade both picks? And do Hawthorn and St Kilda both finish there abouts?

From Brisbane's perspective it's a no brainier trade at the moment.

 

[Hicksey]

With hrovat playing well so far for North. I think some other Bulldog depth players could be and should be targets for other clubs.

Hrovat playing well at North
Koby Stevens for the saints

Just interested to see if anyone would be interested in Honeychurch, Webb, Bailey Dale, Redpath and players like that

 

[Jeremias]

With hrovat playing well so far for North. I think some other Bulldog depth players could be and should be targets for other clubs.

Hrovat playing well at North
Koby Stevens for the saints

Just interested to see if anyone would be interested in Honeychurch, Webb, Bailey Dale, Redpath and players like that

Yep.

I was really keen on Hrovat last year and also mentioned Honeychurch, Webb & Dale as players I'd look into.

If any of them want to move elsewhere at the end of the year I would imagine we'd be keen.

 

[Hicksey]

Yep.

I was really keen on Hrovat last year and also mentioned Honeychurch, Webb & Dale as players I'd look into.

If any of them want to move elsewhere at the end of the year I would imagine we'd be keen.

Yeah i wanted to keep hrovat but knew he just needed to play senior footy i really think some of our other kids would play good footy elsewhere

 

[CasuallyDressed]

With hrovat playing well so far for North. I think some other Bulldog depth players could be and should be targets for other clubs.

Hrovat playing well at North
Koby Stevens for the saints

Just interested to see if anyone would be interested in Honeychurch, Webb, Bailey Dale, Redpath and players like that

Redpath would be playing if not for his injury, right?

If not, Collingwood would take him.

 

[Hicksey]

Redpath would be playing if not for his injury, right?

If not, Collingwood would take him.

Thats what i mean i dont think he would and surley a team like collingwood could use him

 

[Hicksey]

W

Redpath would be playing if not for his injury, right?

If not, Collingwood would take him.

What would you give up for Redpath you think?

 

[thetradesman]

I think this would be somewhat of a fair deal.

Bombers pick this year is probably around 5 - 10? and I can't really see them improving greatly next year either, if anything they are over paying.

 

[Soups]

W

What would you give up for Redpath you think?

We have a couple of third rounders this year so probably one of those.

 

[Flags_In_The_Bag]

How's Jayden Laverde tracking everyone? How's he dealing with the delisting last year? Heard he's playing for South Adelaide in the SANFL and St Kilda are pretty keen on him.

John Mac- you can not be serious

 

[Flags_In_The_Bag]

JJ and the dogs first for Fyfe :0-)

 

[Dogsman16]

Would be an idiotic move for the dogs to get rid of Redpath. He's one of the few natural forwards we have.

He's better than Cloke currently IMO!