2017 trade hypothetical thread

[Foucault1989]

Ok I want to propose a potential trade that could be viewed as fair. I'm conscious that I will be biased towards carlton so feel free to propose an alternative or adjustment

Gibbs and Carlton's third rounder (38-41) to Adelaide.

Charlie Cameron to Brisbane

Adelaide's first (15-18) and Brisbane's second (20-21) to Carlton.

Thoughts?

 

[Wild Bill]

If they offered pick 1 you would definitely have a good hard think about it, I know I would

Really? Your banking on Forgerty, Raynor or Davis U being better? I would def stay with the player that has shown he is good early at afl level.

 

[citizen-erased]

If they offered pick 1 you would definitely have a good hard think about it, I know I would

pass.
Parish is a known quantity and building into a quality running mid.
Not keen to trade that for an unknown.

if they wanna play together so much, we'll send a 2nd up for Mathieson.

 

[Brufen]

Ok I want to propose a potential trade that could be viewed as fair. I'm conscious that I will be biased towards carlton so feel free to propose an alternative or adjustment

Gibbs and Carlton's third rounder (38-41) to Adelaide.

Charlie Cameron to Brisbane

Adelaide's first (15-18) and Brisbane's second (20-21) to Carlton.

Thoughts?

NO CHANCE!!! You're clearly a bagger!

Assuming Adelaide's pick is 17 and Brisbane's pick is 21, that's a point value equivalent to approx. pick 4.

I ask you the question, do you think Gibbs is worth Pick 4???


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[citizen-erased]

NO CHANCE!!! You're clearly a bagger!

Assuming Adelaide's pick is 17 and Brisbane's pick is 21, that's a point value equivalent to approx. pick 4.

I ask you the question, do you think Gibbs is worth Pick 4???


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

that really only works if you have a kid being bid on (not sure Carlton have a F/S coming through this year) or you get a bottom side to trade with you. Maybe the hawks would to get a 2 for 1 in, but they don't hold that pick anymore.

Is Gibbs worth a couple of late 1st round kids during your premiership window?
probably.

 

[Brufen]

NO CHANCE!!! You're clearly a bagger!

Assuming Adelaide's pick is 17 and Brisbane's pick is 21, that's a point value equivalent to approx. pick 4.

I ask you the question, do you think Gibbs is worth Pick 4???


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

To be fair I haven't fairly considered the additional pick (3rd rounder) you offered from Carlton. Which does make it a fairer trade proposition.

Forgetting all the ducks and drakes, I guess it's fair that Gibbs is worth a pick 13-18


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Stevi_Tigers]

Pick 1 + what equals Parish and Francis.

francis is a fat prick who cant run out a game why bother

 

[Stevi_Tigers]

what would matt kennedy cost

 

[citizen-erased]

Not when the PSD option looms in any breakdown in trade talks.
Ports pick would be the offer
I doubt he leaves Essendon but if he wants to Essendon won't get full value for him. It sux but that's the system

not always
Beams, Treloar, JOM, Prestia, Carlisle. Plenty of examples of clubs achieving the right value.

PSD isn't an option. Players don't do it.
Pick 1 for Parish isn't a bad give up, esp if he indicates he'd go to Brisbane. You get an AFL proven kid with around 30 games experience before he is 21 and significantly reduced risk of him wanting to leave given he opted to join.

Ports pick (12-16) for a pick 4 who has developed into a starting 22 player isn't going to cut it.

 

[kreglze]

Pick 1 for Parish and a 2nd/3rd Rounder could be handy tbh.

 

[Carlos Danger]

not always
Beams, Treloar, JOM, Prestia, Carlisle. Plenty of examples of clubs achieving the right value.

PSD isn't an option. Players don't do it.
Pick 1 for Parish isn't a bad give up, esp if he indicates he'd go to Brisbane. You get an AFL proven kid with around 30 games experience before he is 21 and significantly reduced risk of him wanting to leave given he opted to join.

Ports pick (12-16) for a pick 4 who has developed into a starting 22 player isn't going to cut it.

Pretty sure none of those players you listed held went to clubs holding pick 1. There's always the uncertainty.

Not in this situation if a trade doesn't get done he goes to brisbane or he stays at Essen. Only 2 options & if he said he wants out

Trust me we lions supporters are very experienced at high draft picks wanting out. They don't go up in value. Pick 1 won't be on the table. Hasn't been traded in 16 years- it's not happening for Parish 2nd yr player.

Again despite this is be highly surprised if he nominates brisbane

 

[Orange Agent]

What would it take to get Hopper across to the bombers? Would our first be enough (anywhere from 5th to 15th)

That would probably do it, everything seems to suggest he wants to be in Melb/Geelong.

 

[Orange Agent]

what would matt kennedy cost

A lot, he's staying.

 

[Freoforever86]

Pick 1 for Parish and a 2nd/3rd Rounder could be handy tbh.

Yeah, but only for the team that gets pick 1. What a shocking trade

 

[bungalow_bill]

Yeah, but only for the team that gets pick 1. What a shocking trade

No way is pick 1 traded for Parish. To trade 1 it would have to be someone like Kelly or we go to the draft.

 

[bootsmalicious]

Billy Smedts For Josh Kelly sounds fair, we'll even be generous and throw in Daniel Gorringe as steak knives

 

[Joao]

Heard one on SEN the other day:

Fremantle get: Towers AND Tippett
Sydney get: Fyfe

2-for-1 bargain.

There was another one that I think went something like this but I forget the details

Gold Coast get: some spud and a 4th rounder.
Collingwood get: Tom Lynch

 

[Tedeski]

Heard one on SEN the other day:

Fremantle get: Towers AND Tippett
Sydney get: Fyfe

2-for-1 bargain.

There was another one that I think went something like this but I forget the details

Gold Coast get: some spud and a 4th rounder.
Collingwood get: Tom Lynch

I heard that one.
Oh dear!

 

[TheGrizz]

Heard one on SEN the other day:

Fremantle get: Towers AND Tippett
Sydney get: Fyfe

2-for-1 bargain.

There was another one that I think went something like this but I forget the details

Gold Coast get: some spud and a 4th rounder.
Collingwood get: Tom Lynch

Surely you are trolling

 

[Joao]

Surely you are trolling

I don't know what I am doing but I legitimately cracked up when I heard the callers ring in with those suggestions. Real people made those actual suggestions on live radio. Classic.

 

[Skipper_]

Heard one on SEN the other day:

Fremantle get: Towers AND Tippett
Sydney get: Fyfe

2-for-1 bargain.

There was another one that I think went something like this but I forget the details

Gold Coast get: some spud and a 4th rounder.
Collingwood get: Tom Lynch

Surely not.

 

[markm106]

Heard one on SEN the other day:

Fremantle get: Towers AND Tippett
Sydney get: Fyfe

2-for-1 bargain.

There was another one that I think went something like this but I forget the details

Gold Coast get: some spud and a 4th rounder.
Collingwood get: Tom Lynch

Yep I heard the Fyfe one as well. Some people are very one eyed.

 

[juss]

Parish isn't worth pick 1. Essendon would take that deal and run if the Lions were dumb enough to offer it.

 

[Checkered]

1 and our 3rd for Parish and Essendons first (pick 8-11ish maybe) would probably be a lot closer to the mark than a straight swap.

 

[WWSD]

How about this...

GWS receive

Hawthorn's 2017 second round pick + Hawthorn's 2018 first round pick (likely to be in the top 5) + Luke Breust

Hawthorn receive

Lachie Whitfield and Matthew Kennedy