2017 trade hypothetical thread

[Crowstar]

Could we use him?

Depends if Gazza goes. He's a solid inside mid but nothing really special about him. He'd be behind Swallow and Lyons but might be good for depth and experience

 

[Scotty_222]

Depends if Gazza goes. He's a solid inside mid but nothing really special about him. He'd be behind Swallow and Lyons but might be good for depth and experience

We lack inside mids..

 

[Crowstar]

We lack inside mids..

Then send on your 3rd rounder

 

[Scotty_222]

Then send on your 3rd rounder

No worries lol.. that's been our downfall though, lack of decent inside mids

 

[Crowstar]

No worries lol.. that's been our downfall though, lack of decent inside mids

Your boys will come good. You've got some real top end talent and plenty of young stars rising. Hopefully you can keep them and play finals next year.
I honestly think the AFL have made GWS what they are today and hung you out to dry

 

[Scotty_222]

Your boys will come good. You've got some real top end talent and plenty of young stars rising. Hopefully you can keep them and play finals next year.
I honestly think the AFL have made GWS what they are today and hung you out to dry

We fall down in that 25 - 28 bracket.. need a little bit of experience

 

[Joao]

We fall down in that 25 - 28 bracket.. need a little bit of experience

Suban -> 27yo inside mid. Yours for free too (UFA). Just remember to give him at least 400k per year over 4.

 

[Soups]

No worries lol.. that's been our downfall though, lack of decent inside mids

Greenwood can come your way then

 

[anotherletdown]

Let's presume Reid (we match bid) and Jones join their brothers down south.

Swans would aim for

Reid and pick 28 for pick 4 from Collingwood - equivalent of pick 11

Jones for pick 14 from Melbourne

Both favour Sydney but how far off the mark do you think they are?

 

[Chaisa]

Let's presume Reid (we match bid) and Jones join their brothers down south.

Swans would aim for

Reid and pick 28 for pick 4 from Collingwood - equivalent of pick 11

Jones for pick 14 from Melbourne

Both favour Sydney but how far off the mark do you think they are?

Wouldn't Collingwood just pick up Reid as a FA?

Jones sounds about right to me though.

 

[Roadto2018]

Let's presume Reid (we match bid) and Jones join their brothers down south.

Swans would aim for

Reid and pick 28 for pick 4 from Collingwood - equivalent of pick 11

Jones for pick 14 from Melbourne

Both favour Sydney but how far off the mark do you think they are?

Jones right but no way does anyone give up pick 4 for Ben Reid, getting 28 back might make it the equivalent of 11 on points but they have no meaning to Collingwood at all, 28 in this draft is useless.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Brufen]

Let's presume Reid (we match bid) and Jones join their brothers down south.

Swans would aim for

Reid and pick 28 for pick 4 from Collingwood - equivalent of pick 11

Jones for pick 14 from Melbourne

Both favour Sydney but how far off the mark do you think they are?

Reid is a FA, so there is NO WAY Collingwood will remotely consider trading for him let alone surrendering pick 4. It will be FA compensation to Sydney full stop. I suspect that will be an end of second round pick (28 - 32 ish).

Jones would be worth around 12-18 give or take a minor switch of later/ late future pick or two. I suspect Jones will recommit and stay in Sydney.

 

[Soups]

Let's presume Reid (we match bid) and Jones join their brothers down south.

Swans would aim for

Reid and pick 28 for pick 4 from Collingwood - equivalent of pick 11

Jones for pick 14 from Melbourne

Both favour Sydney but how far off the mark do you think they are?

It's nice to dream.

 

[Chaisa]

I suspect that will be an end of second round pick (28 - 32 ish).

I'll be very disappointed if we get Band 3 compo for Reid.

 

[harro92]

Reid is a FA, so there is NO WAY Collingwood will remotely consider trading for him let alone surrendering pick 4. It will be FA compensation to Sydney full stop. I suspect that will be an end of second round pick (28 - 32 ish).

Jones would be worth around 12-18 give or take a minor switch of later/ late future pick or two. I suspect Jones will recommit and stay in Sydney.

Swan will match if all they get is 28-32ish pick


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Guy Threepwood]

Jones for pick 14 from Melbourne

I wouldn't have thought that favoured Sydney. I'd happily pay a top 10 pick for him on this years form.

 

[Apex36]

Let's presume Reid (we match bid) and Jones join their brothers down south.

Swans would aim for

Reid and pick 28 for pick 4 from Collingwood - equivalent of pick 11

Rofl, stop taking the piss.

 

[anotherletdown]

I wouldn't have thought that favoured Sydney. I'd happily pay a top 10 pick for him on this years form.

and we'd happily accept more.... but we just don't do haggling and/or overly complicated trades.

 

[anotherletdown]

Jones right but no way does anyone give up pick 4 for Ben Reid, getting 28 back might make it the equivalent of 11 on points but they have no meaning to Collingwood at all, 28 in this draft is useless.
On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

Very few options for Collingwood if we match then.... that's their only currency. They'd have to make it a huge offer to guarantee we get 1st round compo

It's nice to dream.

OK. But the question was really aimed at what is his value to Collingwood if we match?

Swan will match if all they get is 28-32ish pick

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Totally agree. For the band to be that low I'd guess the offer is well within our wage structure

Rofl, stop taking the piss.

See above. The question was really aimed at what is his value to Collingwood if we match? What else do they have that is of value to Sydney? Their next pick is in the 3rd round.

 

[foj1]

He is a free agent
Pick 4 with 28 back not fair to the pies
Jones is worth a mid to late fist rounder especially in this draft

 

[blueiris]

Reid isn't worth a first round compo pick wouldn't be in the top 6 forwards in the AFL no one is paying $1 million a season not even Collingwood are going to be paying that

 

[Apex36]

Very few options for Collingwood if we match then.... that's their only currency. They'd have to make it a huge offer to guarantee we get 1st round compo



OK. But the question was really aimed at what is his value to Collingwood if we match?



Totally agree. For the band to be that low I'd guess the offer is well within our wage structure



See above. The question was really aimed at what is his value to Collingwood if we match? What else do they have that is of value to Sydney? Their next pick is in the 3rd round.

If you match you can keep him. He's not worth anywhere near a first rounder.

 

[Soups]

Very few options for Collingwood if we match then.... that's their only currency. They'd have to make it a huge offer to guarantee we get 1st round compo



OK. But the question was really aimed at what is his value to Collingwood if we match?



Totally agree. For the band to be that low I'd guess the offer is well within our wage structure



See above. The question was really aimed at what is his value to Collingwood if we match? What else do they have that is of value to Sydney? Their next pick is in the 3rd round.

I don't think you will match. We don't have a second round pick so you may as well not match and get a compo pick somewhere in the second round I would imagine. No way you are getting pick 4. That's just not going to happen.

 

[anotherletdown]

I don't think you will match. We don't have a second round pick so you may as well not match and get a compo pick somewhere in the second round I would imagine. No way you are getting pick 4. That's just not going to happen.

I think that's the problem for us. He's definitely worth far more than a second to us, structure wise he's almost essential to us. We have no one else in our squad like him so we'd have to go FA hunting ourselves of draft for it. If we can't get end of 1st (which is where I think this draft drops right off) then I'd pay up rather than going to the draft/dart board in the second round

 

[buttermuffs]

How shit would pick one for Hopper, 2017 third and 2018 first be? Maybe another player like Kennedy instead of the third.