2017 trade hypothetical thread

[LukeParkerno1]

I love it how Carlton and their fans think Gibbs is worth the same as Lever lol

Or that the asking price last year is the same as this year when Gibbs is a year older. He'd get a first but that would be about it, maybe a late swap in Carlton's favour but any more and they are pushing it. Crows will be happy to take 10, 17, 19 (the probable Cameron trade pick) to the draft. 3 picks inside 20 for a contender, you are laughing.

 

[DangerSloane]

Or that the asking price last year is the same as this year when Gibbs is a year older. He'd get a first but that would be about it, maybe a late swap in Carlton's favour but any more and they are pushing it. Crows will be happy to take 10, 17, 19 (the probable Cameron trade pick) to the draft. 3 picks inside 20 for a contender, you are laughing.

Agreed. I think a first and maybe a Harrison Wigg should get the job done.
Would be sad to see Wigg go, but given he didnt get a game this yr, im worried the club doesnt rate him.

Then we take say 10 and 19 to the draft. Hopefully grab Motlop and end up with Gibbs+Motlop+extra 1st rounder for Lever, Cameron and Wigg.

After all the media hyperbole, we'd be a better side after that. Lots of water under the bridge there but thats what I'm hoping for.

 

[LukeParkerno1]

Agreed. I think a first and maybe a Harrison Wigg might get the job done.
Would be sad to see Wigg go, but given he didnt get a game this yr, im worried the club doesnt rate him.

Then we take say 10 and 19 to the draft. Hopefully grab Motlop and end up with Gibbs+Motlop+extra 1st rounder for Lever, Cameron and Wigg.

After all the media hyperbole, we'd be a better side after that. Lots of water under the bridge there but thats what I'm hoping for.

Where is pick 17 going?

Won't completely shock me for the Crows to bundle 2 of those 3 for a top 5-8 pick as well. The point is you have options. Keep the picks, you add some high quality talent. Bundle them together you get into the top echelon in the draft in a premiership year.

 

[Tyler Hodges]

Hypothetical for Freo to get their two guys.

Freo out. Pick 5, Pick 41
In: Pick 11, N.Wilson
Out: Balic
In: Melb pick 35
Out: crozier/Pick 35
In: Dogs pick 27
Swap: Pick 27 for B.Matera
Total out: Pick 5, 41, Crozier, Balic
In: Pick 11, Wilson, Matera

Thoughts?

 

[DangerSloane]

Where is pick 17 going?

Won't completely shock me for the Crows to bundle 2 of those 3 for a top 5-8 pick as well. The point is you have options. Keep the picks, you add some high quality talent. Bundle them together you get into the top echelon in the draft in a premiership year.

I would think that 17 and Wigg for Gibbs would be about right...I dont know I'm biased and think we shouldnt overpay for him.
We might have to bundle them to get a good SA lad (so he doesnt leave), seeing as a couple of the best guys this year are from SA apparently.

I notice Sydney are very quiet...anything in the works you think?

 

[brutus76]

Cameron to Lions for 19
Francis to Crows for 19
19 for Stringer take it or leave it

 

[DanT7]

Adelaide: Gibbs
Brisbane: 3, Cameron
Carlton: 1, Schache or 19

 

[DangerSloane]

Adelaide: Gibbs
Brisbane: 3, Cameron
Carlton: 1, Schache or 19

Carlton get robbed blind there.
Give up Gibbs and get 19/Schache and a 2 pick upgrade.

 

[DangerSloane]

Cameron to Lions for 19
Francis to Crows for 19
19 for Stringer take it or leave it

Yuk.
How is Francis worth the same as Cameron.

 

[Miguel Sanchez]

Given Brisbane's apparently offered pick 19 for Cameron already, presumably 18 will be next on the table, Plan C should be:

Cameron and 16 to Brisbane for 12 and 19.

Puts his value at about pick 15.

 

[DangerSloane]

Given Brisbane's apparently offered pick 19 for Cameron already, presumably 18 will be next on the table, Plan C should be:

Cameron and 16 to Brisbane for 12 and 19.

Puts his value at about pick 15.

Surprised we havent accepted 19.
Will it depend on whether we can lure Motlop?

 

[Dom PC]

Pick 3 & 38 >> Brisbane

Schache, pick 12 and pick 19 >> Carlton

Allows Carlton to use 19 on Kennedy too.

So for pick 3 and 38 Carlton get Schache, Kennedy and pick 12.

Thoughts?

 

[Tyler Hodges]

Cameron to Lions for 19
Francis to Crows for 19
19 for Stringer take it or leave it

Crows show zero interest in Francis. Then just throw out pick 19?


... tell him he's dreamin

 

[Tyler Hodges]

Pick 3 & 38 >> Brisbane

Schache, pick 12 and pick 19 >> Carlton

Allows Carlton to use 19 on Kennedy too.

So for pick 3 and 38 Carlton get Schache, Kennedy and pick 12.

Thoughts?

Lions lose that trade imo

 

[BlueMaster1]

I love it how Carlton and their fans think Gibbs is worth the same as Lever lol

simple Adelaide don't meet Carlton's demands miss out on the premiership and watch port jump the crows

 

[Dom PC]

Lions lose that trade imo

I was trying not to be bias haha. Values Schache in the mid 30s pick i think. Probably need a bit more coming Brisbane's way.


Pick 3, 38 and 56 >> Brisbane
Schache, 18 and 19 >> Carlton

Values Schache at pick 19.

 

[Tyler Hodges]

I was trying not to be bias haha. Values Schache in the mid 30s pick i think. Probably need a bit more coming Brisbane's way.


Pick 3, 38 and 56 >> Brisbane
Schache, 18 and 19 >> Carlton

Values Schache at pick 19.

I just dont see the great value in Lions having 1 and 3 in this particular draft. If the top 5 was say, 3 mids and 2 Key position prospects, I'd say it's still slight overs but go for it. But when you have recently drafted McCluggage and Berry last year, getting Raynor and Dow is overkill imo. Obviously it's still a great situation but I feel like there's better things to get with Schache and those picks 18,19.

 

[Draft mad]

Talk around Paul Puopolo being traded. Especially after Jarman Impey signing, the reliance on Puopolo would be way less. So I think he would be a great fit for GWS. With Devon Smith and Steve Johnson going out there is definitely a gap for him. GWS also need a high pressure player in the forward line which has been highlighted is footy shows like AFL 360. Hawks also want to improve there draft position. So my hyperthetical trade is

GWS get: Paul Puopolo and pick 44
Hawks get: pick 26 and pick 65

Thoughts?

 

[MUFASA12]

Sloane is gone!!!! Just a matter of when

 

[harro92]

Talk around Paul Puopolo being traded. Especially after Jarman Impey signing, the reliance on Puopolo would be way less. So I think he would be a great fit for GWS. With Devon Smith and Steve Johnson going out there is definitely a gap for him. GWS also need a high pressure player in the forward line which has been highlighted is footy shows like AFL 360. Hawks also want to improve there draft position. So my hyperthetical trade is

GWS get: Paul Puopolo and pick 44
Hawks get: pick 26 and pick 65

Thoughts?

GWS won’t do that


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[PowerForGood]

simple Adelaide don't meet Carlton's demands miss out on the premiership and watch port jump the crows

Crows still ahead of Port... we ain't done nothing yet.
Like your thinking tho

 

[sr36]

Cameron to Lions for 19
Francis to Crows for 19
19 for Stringer take it or leave it

Looksv pretty good for Essendon, Lions and Dogs, but I think the Crows need a sweetener.

 

[PowerForGood]

Surprised we havent accepted 19.
Will it depend on whether we can lure Motlop?

Thinking Cameron deal NOT to go ahead now.

 

[newblueo]

Talk around Paul Puopolo being traded. Especially after Jarman Impey signing, the reliance on Puopolo would be way less. So I think he would be a great fit for GWS. With Devon Smith and Steve Johnson going out there is definitely a gap for him. GWS also need a high pressure player in the forward line which has been highlighted is footy shows like AFL 360. Hawks also want to improve there draft position. So my hyperthetical trade is

GWS get: Paul Puopolo and pick 44
Hawks get: pick 26 and pick 65

Thoughts?

hahaha . sorry bahaha. gws said no to puopolo they want honeychurch. even so not happening he is well past itttt

 

[Draft mad]

hahaha . sorry bahaha. gws said no to puopolo they want honeychurch. even so not happening he is well past itttt

Mate honeychurch is more of a midfielder and his forward pressure isn't near as good. N for the record how can he be well past when he is at his peak form