2017 trade hypothetical thread

[WWSD]

Melbourne’s 2018 second round pick for Isaac Smith.

 

[newblueo]

Mate honeychurch is more of a midfielder and his forward pressure isn't near as good. N for the record how can he be well past when he is at his peak form

I'm all ears as to how he is at his peak. stats alone he is down? plus he missed games due to injury which he never has. all signs point he is over the hill.

 

[HeHateMe]

hahaha . sorry bahaha.

Sent from my SM-G930F using Tapatalk

 

[BPikkers]

I just dont see the great value in Lions having 1 and 3 in this particular draft. If the top 5 was say, 3 mids and 2 Key position prospects, I'd say it's still slight overs but go for it. But when you have recently drafted McCluggage and Berry last year, getting Raynor and Dow is overkill imo. Obviously it's still a great situation but I feel like there's better things to get with Schache and those picks 18,19.

They could use one for Fogarty.

 

[Draft mad]

I'm all ears as to how he is at his peak. stats alone he is down? plus he missed games due to injury which he never has. all signs point he is over the hill.

Mate you can't judge things on stats. Paul Puopolo is one of the best at 1%ers but he doesn't get a stat for it

 

[harro92]

Mate you can't judge things on stats. Paul Puopolo is one of the best at 1%ers but he doesn't get a stat for it

Poppy is no longer at peak performance


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[SterlingArcher]

Mate you can't judge things on stats. Paul Puopolo is one of the best at 1%ers but he doesn't get a stat for it

https://www.footywire.com/afl/footy/ft_player_rankings?year=2017&rt=LA&st=1P

 

[newblueo]

Mate you can't judge things on stats. Paul Puopolo is one of the best at 1%ers but he doesn't get a stat for it

not in the top 100 for that stat lol you mean pressure acts in which he is 6th at your club for behind howe. again he has no value at all only to the hawks

 

[Draft mad]

not in the top 100 for that stat lol you mean pressure acts in which he is 6th at your club for behind howe. again he has no value at all only to the hawks

Footywire is all bs try finding it on an afl offical website

 

[WWSD]

not in the top 100 for that stat lol you mean pressure acts in which he is 6th at your club for behind howe. again he has no value at all only to the hawks

He would be the number one small forward at the following clubs and that includes Carlton. The Blues small forward stocks is arguably the leagues worst.

Carlton
Geelong
Gold Coast
North Melbourne
Sydney
Western Bulldogs

 

[Bokonon_]

hahaha . sorry bahaha. gws said no to puopolo they want honeychurch. even so not happening he is well past itttt

Actually as far as I'm aware we've shown no interest in Honeychurch. Someone wrote an article with no reference named, or even implied to our club, that we were interested.
That and $4.50 is the going rate for a large flat white.

 

[newblueo]

He would be the number one small forward at the following clubs and that includes Carlton. The Blues small forward stocks is arguably the leagues worst.

Carlton
Geelong
Gold Coast
North Melbourne
Sydney
Western Bulldogs

yeh naaaaa. Wright is better. fisher.north have three goodies..suns martin. i could go on but it's pointless as saying puopolo is worth a 2nd round pick

good player in his day but

 

[PrinceCharles]

He would be the number one small forward at the following clubs and that includes Carlton. The Blues small forward stocks is arguably the leagues worst.

Carlton
Geelong
Gold Coast
North Melbourne
Sydney
Western Bulldogs

Yes, I think bringing in an over the hill small forward is definitely a priority at this stage of our rebuild.

 

[WWSD]

yeh naaaaa. Wright is better. fisher.north have three goodies..suns martin. i could go on but it's pointless as saying puopolo is worth a 2nd round pick

good player in his day but

Fisher kicked a whopping 4 goals in total from 17 games this year. Wright is a half forward/midfielder.

In what universe is Jack Martin a small forward? He’s a utility.

 

[Mego Red]

simple Adelaide don't meet Carlton's demands miss out on the premiership and watch port jump the crows

Carlton supporters will be much more disappointed than Crows supporters if Gibbs stays and they miss out on multiple kids.

 

[Mego Red]

Sloane is gone!!!! Just a matter of when

Yep. Probably will happen a year or two after he retires.

 

[Mitchell54]

Which teams would be interested in Hartung?

 

[BlueMaster1]

Carlton supporters will be much more disappointed than Crows supporters if Gibbs stays and they miss out on multiple kids.

No i won't be if he stays

 

[harro92]

Anyone interested in a game
https://www.bigfooty.com/forum/threads/afl-fantasy-draft.1179863/


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Foucault1989]

Mate you can't judge things on stats. Paul Puopolo is one of the best at 1%ers but he doesn't get a stat for it

What is with hawks fans desperately trying to spark interest on bloody Paul Puopolo? If he is that good you would keep him. Seriously he is a an average C grade AFL footballer who looked good in a great side. Put him in a bottom club and he would have been delisted years ago Staph!!!!!

 

[SexyBlueGirl]

Carlton supporters will be much more disappointed than Crows supporters if Gibbs stays and they miss out on multiple kids.

multiple kids don't mean much without experienced heads to teach them.

 

[SexyBlueGirl]

Agreed. I think a first and maybe a Harrison Wigg should get the job done.

Who? lol.

Not sure you quite get this trading game.

 

[Borough Blood]

He would be the number one small forward at the following clubs and that includes Carlton. The Blues small forward stocks is arguably the leagues worst.

Carlton
Geelong
Gold Coast
North Melbourne
Sydney
Western Bulldogs

Based on his age and performances this year, Papley > Poppy.

 

[Mitchell54]

Based on his age and performances this year, Papley > Poppy.

Agreed

 

[PrinceCharles]

Which teams would be interested in Hartung?

Possibly Williamstown.