2017 Trade Hypotheticals (opposition supporters post here)

[Squizz89]

We get slaughtered in that deal. Weller is worth pick 12 so it is essentially doing pick 1 for 5.

Hmmm I'd have thought Weller goes top 10 in this draft but maybe not. Fair enough mate.

 

[cotter101]

I'd do pick 1 for Weller and 5 in this years crop.

 

[jackess]

Hmmm I'd have thought Weller goes top 10 in this draft but maybe not. Fair enough mate.

Didn't finish top 10 in their B&F. Kersten got more votes and he only managed one kick against us.

He's quality but he's no certainty to push on and be an A grader.

 

[Daniels Riches]

Must admit I haven't seen much of Weller. Does he play a similar role to Matt Kennedy?

 

[cotter101]

Must admit I haven't seen much of Weller. Does he play a similar role to Matt Kennedy?

Played more a HBF type role for Fremantle from what I've seen. But have seen him play in the midfield and look good. I'd love him, but would seem very unlikely he comes to us.

 

[Dom PC]

Pick 9 and 25>> Brisbane
Schache, Pick 12 and 30>> Bulldogs
Stringer >> Essendon

Bris lose: Schache, 12
Bris gain: pick 9, 25
Values Schache at pick 19

Dogs lose: Stringer and pick 9
Dogs gain: Schache, pick 12 and 30
Values Stringer at Schache + pick 41

Essendon lose: 25, 30
Essendon gain: Stringer


That was an effort... even then I am not sure it's a great deal for us...

 

[Mitchell54]

Pick 9 and 25>> Brisbane
Schache, Pick 12 and 30>> Bulldogs
Stringer >> Essendon

Bris lose: Schache, 12
Bris gain: pick 9, 25
Values Schache at pick 19

Dogs lose: Stringer and pick 9
Dogs gain: Schache, pick 12 and 30
Values Stringer at Schache + pick 41

Essendon lose: 25, 30
Essendon gain: Stringer

That was an effort... even then I am not sure it's a great deal for us...

Think Brisbane could do a bit better here. Pick 30 now goes to Brisbane but Brisbane give Pick 43 to the Bulldogs

Bris lose: Schache, 12 & 43
Bris gain: pick 9, 25 & 30
Values Schache at pick 13

Dogs lose: Stringer and pick 9
Dogs gain: Schache, pick 12 and 43
Values Stringer at Schache + pick 41

Essendon lose: 25, 30
Essendon gain: Stringer

EDIT: Values Schache at Pick 13-ish(didn't do the exact math)

 

[M Malice]

Pick 9 and 25>> Brisbane
Schache, Pick 12 and 30>> Bulldogs
Stringer >> Essendon

Bris lose: Schache, 12
Bris gain: pick 9, 25
Values Schache at pick 19

Dogs lose: Stringer and pick 9
Dogs gain: Schache, pick 12 and 30
Values Stringer at Schache + pick 41

Essendon lose: 25, 30
Essendon gain: Stringer


That was an effort... even then I am not sure it's a great deal for us...

Give up pick 18 instead of 12 and it values Schache at around pick 14, while still not enough IMO at least it would guarantee us 3 selections before Ballenden is bid on.

 

[SizeMatters]

top 10 pick for Scache. He's contracted....... not going to give him up for some late first rounder.

 

[WA Lion]

top 10 pick for Scache. He's contracted....... not going to give him up for some late first rounder.

I've been preparing to be underwhelmed but if he is genuinely willing to come back and give it a crack then I see no reason why we would take under