2017 Trade Hypotheticals (opposition supporters post here)

[Vhaluus]

That is gold with amount in f young players on our list all we do have is time so let's go to the draft which I would prefer

They won't stay on your list if you can't sell them hope, thought Brisbane fans would realize that given recent events.

 

[Berrygood]

So you believe that losing Rockliff, keeping Schache and bringing in 0 new talent you'll be better than bottom 4 next year?

No, we will definately be bottom 4 next year what ever happens, still a lot of deadwood to clear out of the list. 2019 will see our march up the table. Hows next year looking for you guys, after such a dismal display in the finals, player unrest, and the biggest sook in the comp as captain. All roses at the crows is it?

 

[Vhaluus]

No, we will definately be bottom 4 next year what ever happens, still a lot of deadwood to clear out of the list. 2019 will see our march up the table. Hows next year looking for you guys, after such a dismal display in the finals, player unrest, and the biggest sook in the comp as captain. All roses at the crows is it?

Dismal performance in finals that got us to a grand final?

We've been losing players for a decade, unlike the Lions it doesn't cripple us.

Our captain is the 2x AFLPA captain of the year too.

 

[Scubaveg]

They won't stay on your list if you can't sell them hope, thought Brisbane fans would realize that given recent events.

Remind me again who Davis, Vine, Tippett, Dangerfield, Lever and formally Bock play for?


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Scubaveg]

Dismal performance in finals that got us to a grand final?

We've been losing players for a decade, unlike the Lions it doesn't cripple us.

Our captain is the 2x AFLPA captain of the year too.

I was very impressed with his performance on GF day!


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Vhaluus]

Remind me again who Davis, Vine, Tippett, Dangerfield, Lever and formally Bock play for?


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

Yep we have lost more talent than exists on your entire team... yet look where we are.

Also Vince is probably a poor example, we pushed him out the door to get the pick we used on Matt Crouch, we won that trade pretty hard.

 

[dave73]

I was just here to discuss what i saw as the disparity between what it seemed Brisbane fans though as the worth of Schache and Cameron. It's Brisbane fans that started slinging shit and now you're acting all indignant that there's shit everywhere.

You've gotta remember he's very inconsistent but has played out of his skin through the finals series. Is this the new standard for him or again just dominating a few games in a row then you look at his age wher plays and where he was drafted to suggest he is worth more than schache is just not right key forwards take years to come one and whoever gets will benefit from two years in our system whether he played seniors or not he is a pick two in a handy draft

 

[Vhaluus]

I was very impressed with his performance on GF day!


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

Yep he had a stinker.. in fact all his finals were terrible, played with injury and struggled.

What was the last award your captain got? 2012 when he was All Australian?

 

[Vhaluus]

You've gotta remember he's very inconsistent but has played out of his skin through the finals series. Is this the new standard for him or again just dominating a few games in a row then you look at his age wher plays and where he was drafted to suggest he is worth more than schache is just not right key forwards take years to come one and whoever gets will benefit from two years in our system whether he played seniors or not he is a pick two in a handy draft

Where a player is drafted means 0 the day after the draft. After that it's all about what they show from then on.

Richard tambling was taken high in the draft, didn't make him any less of a spud.

 

[Berrygood]

600k a year offer tells me otherwise.

As does your coach coming out while the season is still going and declaring interest, breaching common AFL etiquette.

Not that old chestnut, did you actually see the interview or are you just parroting the misinformation sprouted by an ignorant coach n media.

 

[dave73]

O

Well who knows. I'm sure the Lions will come up with some sort of trade strategy to secure an out of contract Cameron if that happens to occur. At the moment they can afford to sit back and wait if they need to.

Or can he walk to psd seeing some though the club didn't listen to his request just waved it away

 

[jackess]

 

[bungalow_bill]

Dismal performance in finals that got us to a grand final?

We've been losing players for a decade, unlike the Lions it doesn't cripple us.

Our captain is the 2x AFLPA captain of the year too.

I'd say it stalled our progress at worst. Got some very good players from the GH5 and Aish trades that are aiding our inevitable rise to premiership glory

 

[dave73]

Where a player is drafted means 0 the day after the draft. After that it's all about what they show from then on.

Richard tambling was taken high in the draft, didn't make him any less of a spud.

Tambling was a Cameron clone not a kpf

 

[dave73]

Dismal performance in finals that got us to a grand final?

We've been losing players for a decade, unlike the Lions it doesn't cripple us.

Our captain is the 2x AFLPA captain of the year too.

Shit two years in a row lucky he's on good coin that's a fair few cartons to hand around and the country and you are spot on he handled the grand final loss and he fact a couple of players want to leave like a true champion here here tex you simply are a great and ver approachable understanding captain if I play four years and leave may we have a beer together boss

 

[SDG72]

600k a year offer tells me otherwise.

As does your coach coming out while the season is still going and declaring interest, breaching common AFL etiquette.

So Adelaide did not approach Gibbs last year who had two years on his contract?

Short Memory? Thanks

 

[ZoBlitz]

No need to reply to Vhaluus in this thread anymore, by the way.

 

[Lazza16]

Dismal performance in finals that got us to a grand final?

We've been losing players for a decade, unlike the Lions it doesn't cripple us.

Our captain is the 2x AFLPA captain of the year too.

Always good to have a joker in the team for morale but a choker.....

 

[Fitzroy bears]

Yep we have lost more talent than exists on your entire team... yet look where we are.

Also Vince is probably a poor example, we pushed him out the door to get the pick we used on Matt Crouch, we won that trade pretty hard.

Yep, look where you are same as us without a premiership, no silver medals in afl buddy, but hey there is always next year LMAO.

You know you would think that crows would have won one by now, hell we have only played finals once in 13 years and we still have won more premierships then adelaide.

Bit of advice, wouldn't keep bringing up a grand final where your team got bent over and spanked to the tune of 50 points, it's just sad.

 

[Fitzroy bears]

No need to reply to Vhaluus in this thread anymore, by the way.

Ooops sorry already replied before I saw your post

 

[M Malice]

I am a little disappointed, not because of Schache per se, but because I was looking forward to 2 weeks of banter on the trades board with BRAB

Alright you two enough with the elaborate extended foreplay, please take it off line. You're turning me off my weet bix.

 

[Jivlain]

Just wondering what a fair deal is on schache from a lion point of view? Does pick 17 get it done?

Replying in a more appropriate thread, but no, not even close. Not for a talented pick 2 KPF who's kicked 25 AFL goals before his 20th birthday, is contracted for two years yet, and who is also open to staying.

 

[Tigersman]

Replying in a more appropriate thread, but no, not even close. Not for a talented pick 2 KPF who's kicked 25 AFL goals before his 20th birthday, is contracted for two years yet, and who is also open to staying.

Cheers. I reckon his form of last year deserves more, yes. Little bit of risk involved with him though.

 

[jackess]

12, 18 and 19 to North for picks 4, 22 and 44?

Guarantee us getting 2 gun mids

 

[Hollow Knight]

21 and Corey Wagner for the runaway?

How about Corey Wagner for nothing as a delisted free agent?