2018 AFLCA Voting

[displacedaussie]

10 - Betts
7 - Seedsman
6 - Ellis-Yolmen
4 - Greenwood
2 - Laird
1 - Gibbs

Coach 1
Betts
Seedsman
Greenwood
Ellis-Yolmen
Gibbs

Coach 2
Betts
Ellis-Yolmen
Seedsman
Laird
Greenwood

http://www.aflca.com.au/fileadmin/u..._AFLCA_Champion_Player_Votes_-_Rd_9__2018.pdf

 

[StonesThrow]

10 for betts. Good game but didn't think it was that good.

 

[Vader]

Cumulative Scores:
Laird 34
Seedsman 25
Gibbs 14
Douglas 11
Betts 11
Atkins 10
Milera 10
Greenwood 9
McGovern 8
Jenkins 7
Lynch 7
CEY 7
Walker 6
Sloane 4
M Crouch 4
Talia 4
Doedee 3
Brown 2
Jacobs 2

 

[Vader]

10 for betts. Good game but didn't think it was that good.

He did kick 4 goals, in those conditions. He was the only mutiple goal scorer on the ground, kicking 4 of 11 goals for the night. He kicked twice as many goals as the Bulldogs' entire team.

 

[Thegibbsgamble]

34 of those votes never played on the weekend

9 rounds in

44 guys competing for 30 votes a round. Around 7 of those each round polls

Profound.

 

[Drugs Are Bad Mackay?]

10 for betts. Good game but didn't think it was that good.

It's not really a measure of his game though.

He was better and more influential than the 43 other players so he gets the 10

He would have played a heap of better games than that for us and got fewer votes or even no votes

 

[StonesThrow]

It's not really a measure of his game though.

He was better and more influential than the 43 other players so he gets the 10

He would have played a heap of better games than that for us and got fewer votes or even no votes

If that's what warrants it I guess. Lots of games haven't seen 10 though right?

I'm not saying he wasn't very good. But 10 votes is usually reserved for a dominant performance.

 

[radiojake]

If that's what warrants it I guess. Lots of games haven't seen 10 though right?

I'm not saying he wasn't very good. But 10 votes is usually reserved for a dominant performance.

I guess it's just the system of the voting

In many newspaper 'player of the year' awards, Betts may have been best on but only got a 7 or so, and those dominant performances by say a Fyfe get a 9 or 10

But with AFLCA there is 30 votes given out a game regardless - Both coaches thought Betts were best on and that's how it rolls

The reason why other games dont have a perfect 10 would be down to the two coaches having different perceptions on who was BOG

 

[displacedaussie]

Round 10 votes to Crows players:

 

[1970crow]

Can someone please update the cumulative scores.

 

[Next Gen Rookie]

Can someone please update the cumulative scores.

Cumulative Scores:
Laird 34
Seedsman 25
Gibbs 14
Douglas 11
Betts 11
Atkins 10
Milera 10
Greenwood 9
McGovern 8
Jenkins 7
Lynch 7
CEY 7
Walker 6
Sloane 4
M Crouch 4
Talia 4
Doedee 3
Brown 2
Jacobs 2

 

[Vader]

Votes are in for the R11 game vs GWS:
http://www.afl.com.au/news/2018-06-04/aflca-votes-round-11-tight-at-the-top-at-halfway

** For the record, no Adelaide player polled a single vote against Melbourne in R10. Shocker, I know - I expected us to totally dominate, after only losing by a mere 91pts. Actually, I thought Talia was an outside chance of picking up 1 or 2 votes, but apparently not.

Votes vs GWS (Round 11)
10 Dylan Shiel (GWS)
6 Ryan Griffen (GWS)
6 Stephen Coniglio (GWS)
4 Bryce Gibbs (Adel)
3 Richard Douglas (Adel)
1 Matt Crouch (Adel)

Cumulative Scores:
Laird 34
Seedsman 25
Gibbs 18
Douglas 14
Betts 11
Atkins 10
Milera 10
Greenwood 9
McGovern 8
Jenkins 7
Lynch 7
CEY 7
Walker 6
M Crouch 5
Sloane 4
Talia 4
Doedee 3
Brown 2
Jacobs 2

So... the players who finished 1st & 2nd in our B&F last year have a grand total of 9 AFLCA votes between them, half way through 2018 (having barely played 5 fully fit games between them). Is there any wonder why we're currently outside the top-8?

 

[Vader]

R12 vs Fremantle
FREMANTLE v ADELAIDE
10 Adam Cerra (Frem)
7 Lachie Neale (Frem)
7 Brennan Cox (Frem)
3 Eddie Betts (Adel)
2 Bryce Gibbs (Adel)
1 Nathan Wilson (Frem)

Cumulative Scores:
Laird 34
Seedsman 25
Gibbs 20
Douglas 14
Betts 14
Atkins 10
Milera 10
Greenwood 9
McGovern 8
Jenkins 7
Lynch 7
CEY 7
Walker 6
M Crouch 5
Sloane 4
Talia 4
Doedee 3
Brown 2
Jacobs 2

 

[Redleg Crow]

R12 vs Fremantle
FREMANTLE v ADELAIDE
10 Adam Cerra (Frem)
7 Lachie Neale (Frem)
7 Brennan Cox (Frem)
3 Eddie Betts (Adel)
2 Bryce Gibbs (Adel)
1 Nathan Wilson (Frem)

Cumulative Scores:
Laird 34
Seedsman 25
Gibbs 20
Douglas 14
Betts 14
Atkins 10
Milera 10
Greenwood 9
McGovern 8
Jenkins 7
Lynch 7
CEY 7
Walker 6
M Crouch 5
Sloane 4
Talia 4
Doedee 3
Brown 2
Jacobs 2

So who hasn't got a vote?
Kelly, Mackay, Gallucci, Poholke, Fogarty, Murphy, Gibson, Hartigan, Otten and Hampton

 

[marty36]

R12 vs Fremantle
FREMANTLE v ADELAIDE
10 Adam Cerra (Frem)
7 Lachie Neale (Frem)
7 Brennan Cox (Frem)
3 Eddie Betts (Adel)
2 Bryce Gibbs (Adel)
1 Nathan Wilson (Frem)

Cumulative Scores:
Laird 34
Seedsman 25
Gibbs 20
Douglas 14
Betts 14
Atkins 10
Milera 10
Greenwood 9
McGovern 8
Jenkins 7
Lynch 7
CEY 7
Walker 6
M Crouch 5
Sloane 4
Talia 4
Doedee 3
Brown 2
Jacobs 2

Atkins is having a solid year


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Bicks]

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2018-06-18/aflca-votes-round-13-eagles-surprise-perfect-10



HAWTHORN v ADELAIDE
10 James Sicily (HAW)
8 Tom Mitchell (HAW)
5 Jaeger O'Meara (HAW)
4 Jack Gunston (HAW)
2 Ben Stratton (HAW)
1 Luke Breust (HAW)

 

[radiojake]

Far out that Sicily is an even bigger flog at the footy than on tv

 

[Vader]

R14 vs West Coast
First time in a while that Adelaide players have featured in the AFLCA votes.
ADELAIDE v WEST COAST
9 Taylor Walker (ADEL)
9 Sam Jacobs (ADEL)
6 Andrew Gaff (WCE)
3 Rory Laird (ADEL)
2 Matt Crouch (ADEL)
1 Mark Hutchings (WCE)

Cumulative Scores:
Laird 37
Seedsman 25
Gibbs 20
Walker 15
Douglas 14
Betts 14
Jacobs 11
Atkins 10
Milera 10
Greenwood 9
McGovern 8
Jenkins 7
Lynch 7
CEY 7
M Crouch 7
Sloane 4
Talia 4
Doedee 3
Brown 2

 

[Vader]

I'm guessing the votes were:
Coach 1
5 - Jacobs
4 - Walker
3 - Gaff
2 - Laird
1 - Hutchings

Coach 2
5 - Walker
4 - Jacobs
3 - Gaff
2 - Matt Crouch
1 - Laird

 

[Drugs Are Bad Mackay?]

The Dude does not abide these votes

 

[Redleg Crow]

Hutchings FFS. Doedee’s game was much more valuable

 

[CrowinNT]

I'm thinking Coach 2 might be Pyke.
Gaff correct
Jacobs v Walker can be up for debate.
Maybe Simpson recognised Jacobs v Nik Nat as more
Hard to say.
Hutchings baffles me

 

[Vader]

R17 - RICHMOND v ADELAIDE
9 Shane Edwards (RICH)
9 Kane Lambert (RICH)
5 Dion Prestia (RICH)
5 Dustin Martin (RICH)
1 Tom Doedee (ADEL)
1 Jack Riewoldt (RICH)

Yes, you read that right. Doedee got 1 vote - presumably from Pyke.

R18 - ADELAIDE v GEELONG
9 Rory Laird (ADEL)
5 Rory Sloane (ADEL)
5 Tom Lynch (ADEL)
5 Wayne Milera (ADEL)
3 Joel Selwood (GEEL)
2 Patrick Dangerfield (GEEL)
1 Tom Hawkins (GEEL)

Cumulative Scores:
Laird 46
Seedsman 25
Gibbs 20
Walker 15
Milera 15
Douglas 14
Betts 14
Jacobs 11
Lynch 12
Atkins 10
Greenwood 9
Sloane 9
McGovern 8
Jenkins 7
CEY 7
M Crouch 7
Talia 4
Doedee 4
Brown 2

Milera jumps into Adelaide's top-5. No points for consistency, but when he does poll he polls well.

 

[Redleg Crow]

R17 - RICHMOND v ADELAIDE
9 Shane Edwards (RICH)
9 Kane Lambert (RICH)
5 Dion Prestia (RICH)
5 Dustin Martin (RICH)
1 Tom Doedee (ADEL)
1 Jack Riewoldt (RICH)

Yes, you read that right. Doedee got 1 vote - presumably from Pyke.

R18 - ADELAIDE v GEELONG
9 Rory Laird (ADEL)
5 Rory Sloane (ADEL)
5 Tom Lynch (ADEL)
5 Wayne Milera (ADEL)
3 Joel Selwood (GEEL)
2 Patrick Dangerfield (GEEL)
1 Tom Hawkins (GEEL)

Cumulative Scores:
Laird 46
Seedsman 25
Gibbs 20
Walker 15
Milera 15
Douglas 14
Betts 14
Jacobs 11
Lynch 12
Atkins 10
Greenwood 9
Sloane 9
McGovern 8
Jenkins 7
CEY 7
M Crouch 7
Talia 4
Doedee 4
Brown 2

Milera jumps into Adelaide's top-5. No points for consistency, but when he does poll he polls well.

Lynch above Laird for me. Danger above Selwood as well

 

[Vader]

My guess...

Coach 1
5. Laird
4. Milera
3. Lynch
2. Dangerfield
1. Hawkins

Coach 2
5. Sloane
4. Laird
3. Selwood
2. Lynch
1. Milera

Obviously Sloane, Lynch & Milera could all be changed around - but they definitely got their votes as 5-0, 4-1, and 3-2. Selwood definitely got his votes from a different coach to Dangerfield & Hawkins.