List Mgmt. 2018 Draft thread.

[MagpieBat]

Sam Collins on the radar of Melbourne, Hawthorn and GWS, Marty Hore also of interest to the Dees:

https://www.theage.com.au/sport/afl/free-agent-target-collins-sent-to-the-draft-20180813-p4zx9t.html

 

[TradeDraft]

Sam Collins on the radar of Melbourne, Hawthorn and GWS, Marty Hore also of interest to the Dees:

https://www.theage.com.au/sport/afl/free-agent-target-collins-sent-to-the-draft-20180813-p4zx9t.html

Agree Hore would played AFL IF he was on our AFL list

 

[whiskeytown]

Agree Hore would played AFL IF he was on our AFL list

If Hore ends up anywhere but Collingwood, I'll be filthy. Plays our system already and excels in it. His transition into our senior team would be seemless.

With Shaz out for 2019, and a liability to do another knee at some point... it makes even more sense to draft him for a 2 year deal. Can always re-rookie, trade out or release later if need be.

 

[MyManLynch]

If Hore ends up anywhere but Collingwood, I'll be filthy. Plays our system already and excels in it. His transition into our senior team would be seemless.

With Shaz out for 2019, and a liability to do another knee at some point... it makes even more sense to draft him for a 2 year deal. Can always re-rookie, trade out or release later if need be.

I think that Clubs should get 1st bite at one VFL player per draft (similar to Academy/FS).
The Club develops them...then loses them to the draft.
1 VFL player per club per draft (include NEAFL/WAFL/SAFL).
From your own reserves or affiliate team.

 

[TradeDraft]

I think that Clubs should get 1st bite at one VFL player per draft (similar to Academy/FS).
The Club develops them...then loses them to the draft.
1 VFL player per club per draft (include NEAFL/WAFL/SAFL).
From your own reserves or affiliate team.

100% Agree MyManLynch

 

[liquidbilliam]

Sam Collins on the radar of Melbourne, Hawthorn and GWS, Marty Hore also of interest to the Dees:

https://www.theage.com.au/sport/afl/free-agent-target-collins-sent-to-the-draft-20180813-p4zx9t.html

I'll spew if Marty Hore ends up at the Dees. I hope we can snag him in the draft.

 

[Unknown Identity]

We've dragged our heels with Hore.
Could see last year he could potentially make the cut at AFL level, should have rookied him.

Ah well.

 

[TradeDraft]

We've dragged our heels with Hore.
Could see last year he could potentially make the cut at AFL level, should have rookied him.

Ah well.

Heard we said we where but Changed out Minds about it

 

[Chrispiesssss]

Who would you have not taken instead?

Oxley was contracted on the main list.
Mihocek has been amazing.

Appleby very very serviceable.

Max Lynch? Maybe. Not sure how he’s going in the VFL. But he’s a raw ruckman. Deserves time.

Tough decision

 

[nahnah]

Who would you have not taken instead?

Oxley was contracted on the main list.
Mihocek has been amazing.

Appleby very very serviceable.

Max Lynch? Maybe. Not sure how he’s going in the VFL. But he’s a raw ruckman. Deserves time.

Tough decision

Lynch will be on the main list next season

 

[jackcass]

I think that Clubs should get 1st bite at one VFL player per draft (similar to Academy/FS).
The Club develops them...then loses them to the draft.
1 VFL player per club per draft (include NEAFL/WAFL/SAFL).
From your own reserves or affiliate team.

Love the concept but still not sure that'd mean we would take Hore.

 

[MagpieBat]

 

[Soups]

Getting talked up massively. Think it’s his year. Reckon he’ll go up north though.

 

[MagpieBat]

Getting talked up massively. Think it’s his year. Reckon he’ll go up north though.

Woolloongabba or Carrara?

 

[Soups]

Woolloongabba or Carrara?

Carrara!

 

[MagpieBat]

Carrara!

RIP Marty Hore's career, it was nice while we knew ye...

 

[Apex36]

RIP Marty Hore's career, it was nice while we knew ye...

TBF, a career at GC is still more impressive and lucrative than a career in the VFL, so....

 

[barrackers]

Who would you have not taken instead?

Oxley was contracted on the main list.
Mihocek has been amazing.

Appleby very very serviceable.

Max Lynch? Maybe. Not sure how he’s going in the VFL. But he’s a raw ruckman. Deserves time.

Tough decision

Mackie the year prior

 

[CFC2010]

Mackie the year prior

I am pretty sure it was Appelby that took his promised spot.

Geez he would be handy now with Shaz and Howe out.

 

[BPikkers]

I actually think it was disappointing list management. The kid won our VFL B&F yet we delist and rookie Oxley last year.

I’d hate to lose him, however, we probably don’t have the draft picks to keep him.

 

[TradeDraft]

I actually think it was disappointing list management. The kid won our VFL B&F yet we delist and rookie Oxley last year.

I’d hate to lose him, however, we probably don’t have the draft picks to keep him.

We can be too Nice with Players Contract. I agree that Hore is Miles better then Oxley

 

[BPikkers]

We can be too Nice with Players Contract. I agree that Hore is Miles better then Oxley

You said it Dave. We seem to hang on to players longer than we should. Particularly guys who have had their opportunities at senior level.
Maybe Ned Guy will be different.

 

[TradeDraft]

You said it Dave. We seem to hang on to players longer than we should. Particularly guys who have had their opportunities at senior level.
Maybe Ned Guy will be different.

and Paying too Much

 

[DialMforMagro]

We have draft him because we all know a'la Mihocek, Bucks will turn him into a forward and then we get to hear Bruce commentate "Cox... straight down Hore's throat!!!" makes life worth living

 

[Matt_352]

I think that Clubs should get 1st bite at one VFL player per draft (similar to Academy/FS).
The Club develops them...then loses them to the draft.
1 VFL player per club per draft (include NEAFL/WAFL/SAFL).
From your own reserves or affiliate team.

100%