Post BF Upgrade Feedback - Click Here

Remove this Banner Ad

List Mgmt. 2018 Draft/Trade/FA Thread

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Status
Not open for further replies.

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Mr Bods said:
Is there a Superstar amongst them?
Click to expand...
I think Ainsworth and Bowes can be 25+ touch a game mids personally. Brodie I'm not sure he has so much going for him but can't put it together like most inside mids do early.

No players with top 10 in comp potential in my opinion. Bowes is the only one who could purely based off what i saw him do as a junior. Suspect he'll just have a huge breakout year one year.
 
scoman said:
If Lynch goes do you think it would be a good move for you guys to nab the King twins? I know you still have a decent spine, but little coming through behind Day, 2mPeter, May and Thompson.
Click to expand...
Leslie, crossley
 
getting pretty concerned about attracting any good talent from other clubs this trade period and seeing GWS are going through a rough period maybe we have to target some players from there who are on the fringe or realise they aren't going to be the GF juggernaut they once thought
 
Thompson, may, leslie in defence
Wright, lynch, day, crossley (5 goals in neafl this week) in forward line.
If we lose lynch we still have 3 kpps per line.
Not many clubs have 4 KPD or KPF.
Especially with the current trend to follow the richmond model the recruitment team could go either way. Then also the recent history of poor form from top 10 KPF in the last 5 years.
 
scoman said:
If Lynch goes do you think it would be a good move for you guys to nab the King twins? I know you still have a decent spine, but little coming through behind Day, 2mPeter, May and Thompson.
Click to expand...
Doubt it. at this stage the three best prospects from our academy include 2 Key position players.
 
scoman said:
If Lynch goes do you think it would be a good move for you guys to nab the King twins? I know you still have a decent spine, but little coming through behind Day, 2mPeter, May and Thompson.
Click to expand...
Big No , why help interstate develop KPP , GCS need midfield that can play forward , the more the better , the King Twins won't be strong enough to play AFL in their first year , but Rankine ,Hately , Rozee, lukosious got the experience to play right away .
 

Remove this Banner Ad

SunnerSS said:
Thompson, may, leslie in defence
Wright, lynch, day, crossley (5 goals in neafl this week) in forward line.
If we lose lynch we still have 3 kpps per line.
Not many clubs have 4 KPD or KPF.
Especially with the current trend to follow the richmond model the recruitment team could go either way. Then also the recent history of poor form from top 10 KPF in the last 5 years.
Click to expand...
Yeah you have enough for the first team. But you have a list of 44-46 not 22. Most teams actually do have eight to ten KPP on the list. Lions have 11, Sydney 10, even Richmond have 9 including rookies. Looking at your list I would be shocked if you dont attempt to bring in a couple of young talls for the future. The King twins might be an option. However I do get the reluctance to use very high picks on skinny, unproven kids who will no doubt take a few years to develop.
 
scoman said:
Yeah you have enough for the first team. But you have a list of 44-46 not 22. Most teams actually do have eight to ten KPP on the list. Lions have 11, Sydney 10, even Richmond have 9 including rookies. Looking at your list I would be shocked if you dont attempt to bring in a couple of young talls for the future. The King twins might be an option. However I do get the reluctance to use very high picks on skinny, unproven kids who will no doubt take a few years to develop.
Click to expand...
Rubbish name them all
 
Peel67skin said:
Big No , why help interstate develop KPP , GCS need midfield that can play forward , the more the better , the King Twins won't be strong enough to play AFL in their first year , but Rankine ,Hately , Rozee, lukosious got the experience to play right away .
Click to expand...

Yiu have already won too many games for Lukosious most likely. Rankine has question marks about professionalism apparently (not a great fit at the coast i wouldnt think). Hately might be a good choice being a strong inside mid. Rozee seems to be more of the same same for you guys - talented flanker type.
 
scoman said:
Yiu have already won too many games for Lukosious most likely. Rankine has question marks about professionalism apparently (not a great fit at the coast i wouldnt think). Hately might be a good choice being a strong inside mid. Rozee seems to be more of the same same for you guys - talented flanker type.
Click to expand...
All this professionalism are bullshit just like pre draft Cam Rayner , as for Rozee with Ainsworth spending more time midfield that is a perfect spot for him to fill and can see him get better than Sexton , young ,Holman,and proof it by playing well in NeAfl ,if GCs draft him .
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

scoman said:
Ok for the Tigers.....

Reiwoldt
Grimes
Astbury
Rance
Griffiths
Balta
Cameron Coleman-Jones
Garthwaite
Moore
Chol

For the Lions

Hipwood
Walker
McStay
Andrews
Gardiner
Frost
Payne
Skinner
Ballenden
Paparone
Eagles
Fullerton
Click to expand...
So about 4 of them are KPP
 
GcSunsfan said:
So about 4 of them are KPP
Click to expand...

Really? Im not talking about KPP players playing in the firsts every week. Im talking about KPP players on the list developing/ providing depth. Your club, going by league standards as pretty light on in that regard. Will you address that late in the draft or early will be the question.
 
scoman said:
Really? Im not talking about KPP players playing in the firsts every week. Im talking about KPP players on the list developing/ providing depth. Your club, going by league standards as pretty light on in that regard. Will you address that late in the draft or early will be the question.
Click to expand...
Well I thought you ask us do we prefer to draft the King Twins or not and we said no , regarding to list need , let's not pretend you know better with your club problem and asking for priority pick last year
 
scoman said:
Really? Im not talking about KPP players playing in the firsts every week. Im talking about KPP players on the list developing/ providing depth. Your club, going by league standards as pretty light on in that regard. Will you address that late in the draft or early will be the question.
Click to expand...
You keep changing your question mate maybe just worry about your own club and don't look for another draft handout every year
 
scoman said:
Really? Im not talking about KPP players playing in the firsts every week. Im talking about KPP players on the list developing/ providing depth. Your club, going by league standards as pretty light on in that regard. Will you address that late in the draft or early will be the question.
Click to expand...
We do have some talented KPPS in our academy coming through this year witb Graham and koenan will definitely be recruited by the club this draft.
But if your stretching kpps to all in the list.
We have the initial 7 i said plus
Jaska, spencer and ballard brings 10 kpps
Im off the firm belief we will recruit best available player with our early picks. But i dont think that means we stretch for a kpp for the sake of it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom