List Mgmt. 2018 Draft/Trade/FA Thread

[Kangaroos4eva]

A few north posters have strongly indicated that Hall is coming to north on a 2 year deal with a trigger for a 3rd year. What can you ladies and gents tell me about Aaron?

 

[Choppers]

I think he'll suit you blokes if true. Has speed, outside runner, lacks defensive capabilities.

 

[Kangaroos4eva]

I think he'll suit you blokes if true. Has speed, outside runner, lacks defensive capabilities.

Thanks, if we could add a defensive game to Hartung, hopefully we can iron his out. Are you guys looking to bring in anyone mature age or trade wise?

 

[SandyToes]

Thanks, if we could add a defensive game to Hartung, hopefully we can iron his out. Are you guys looking to bring in anyone mature age or trade wise?

Ben Brown

 

[Kangaroos4eva]

Ben Brown

I’m curious, what would you pay picks wise?

 

[Peel67skin]

Thanks, if we could add a defensive game to Hartung, hopefully we can iron his out. Are you guys looking to bring in anyone mature age or trade wise?

I think there is a plan to bring Josh William back . As much I like Ben Brown , I think GC need to go and find their own Mature age player .

 

[Basssman]

Where does this Josh Williams talk always seem to come from? I don’t know why the suns would be so keen to get him back besides the fact he is an academy kid who we didn’t match Norths bid on so obviously didn’t rate that high. He isn’t really flourishing into anything special so far at north I just don’t see the point of bringing in another list clogger who probably won’t make it to AFL level


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Camsta]

If May wants out - now is the time to do it.

We need a full burn down rebuild on a core of players who want to be here. If I was Tony I’d be sitting everyone down with a 3 year extension - sign it or GTFO

 

[eppo67]

A few north posters have strongly indicated that Hall is coming to north on a 2 year deal with a trigger for a 3rd year. What can you ladies and gents tell me about Aaron?

He's a massive downhill skier, sook and he's unpopular in the group (big head). Aaron has Aaron 1st mentality not team first.
However l think he might benefit greatly from a change of Club and l'm sure your leaders will pull him into line. Great line breaking speed and power.

 

[kreglze]

Thanks, if we could add a defensive game to Hartung, hopefully we can iron his out. Are you guys looking to bring in anyone mature age or trade wise?

Honestly not sure, don't know much about the North list. Josh Williams I can imagine we would angle for being a GC Academy product, but I don't know if the club would want him considering we didn't match. We would be looking at some mature bodies though.

 

[Peel67skin]

Where does this Josh Williams talk always seem to come from? I don’t know why the suns would be so keen to get him back besides the fact he is an academy kid who we didn’t match Norths bid on so obviously didn’t rate that high. He isn’t really flourishing into anything special so far at north I just don’t see the point of bringing in another list clogger who probably won’t make it to AFL level


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

Preuss is the other GC academy player, where North get him from Rookie Draft.

 

[Kangaroos4eva]

Honestly not sure, don't know much about the North list. Josh Williams I can imagine we would angle for being a GC Academy product, but I don't know if the club would want him considering we didn't match. We would be looking at some mature bodies though.

Josh’s big problem is he’s as skinny as the day we drafted him. He’s worth nothing and I doubt he’ll make it at afl level. He has good patches of games and then other games, you wouldn’t even know he was out there.

 

[Kangaroos4eva]

Preuss is the other GC academy player, where North get him from Rookie Draft.

We shopped him around last year and there was little interest. Adding that you got Witts flying, I doubt he’s coming back home.

 

[kreglze]

Josh’s big problem is he’s as skinny as the day we drafted him. He’s worth nothing and I doubt he’ll make it at afl level. He has good patches of games and then other games, you wouldn’t even know he was out there.

Yeah I know. IF we were interested I imagine we can pick him up for nothing, but I don't reckon we will be.

Not sure do you have any solid role players that may not be getting as many games as they should?

 

[gcsunsfc]

I

We shopped him around last year and there was little interest. Adding that you got Witts flying, I doubt he’s coming back home.

I'd love Mason Wood or Ed Vickers Willis up here
Not sure their contract situation
doubt you guys would be wanting to trade them anyway.

 

[Peel67skin]

We shopped him around last year and there was little interest. Adding that you got Witts flying, I doubt he’s coming back home.

Can you tell me about Nathan hrovat , why he is not a regular in your team after crossing over from Bulldog. Too small ?

 

[Kangaroos4eva]

Yeah I know. IF we were interested I imagine we can pick him up for nothing, but I don't reckon we will be.

Not sure do you have any solid role players that may not be getting as many games as they should?

Not really, we don’t have a lot of mature depth, so our vfl midfield is fielded by first year rookies with no tanks and LDU.

Maybe Durdin or Nielson, handy KPD’s. I doubt Hvorat will be getting a new contract.

I

I'd love Mason Wood or Ed Vickers Willis up here
Not sure their contract situation
doubt you guys would be wanting to trade them anyway.

Wood is rated highly internally, not so much by fans, he’ll cost you too much to make it beneficial. Two Dads (Vickers Willis) is best 22 and our only decent lockdown medium defender, again, very cost prohibitive and is a Melbourne grammar boy. Both would be good for you though and fill your list needs.

Can you tell me about Nathan hrovat , why he is not a regular in your team after crossing over from Bulldog. Too small ?

Fan whipping boy and coach favourite. Works hard, is a nice kick, nippy and has decent composure. Negatives, he’s too small to nail his tackles, not a long kick, not a massive goal kicker and can’t break that 15 touch half forward average that a lot of middiling hff’s struggle to improve upon.

 

[SnusCG]

Not really, we don’t have a lot of mature depth, so our vfl midfield is fielded by first year rookies with no tanks and LDU.

Maybe Durdin or Nielson, handy KPD’s. I doubt Hvorat will be getting a new contract.

Wood is rated highly internally, not so much by fans, he’ll cost you too much to make it beneficial. Two Dads (Vickers Willis) is best 22 and our only decent lockdown medium defender, again, very cost prohibitive and is a Melbourne grammar boy. Both would be good for you though and fill your list needs.

Fan whipping boy and coach favourite. Works hard, is a nice kick, nippy and has decent composure. Negatives, he’s too small to nail his tackles, not a long kick, not a massive goal kicker and can’t break that 15 touch half forward average that a lot of middiling hff’s struggle to improve upon.

Not exactly a trade question but what is up with LDU this season. Was discussed as a 'ready-made player' but hasn't looked great at AFL or VFL really - has he been injured or just struggling to adjust?

 

[Kangaroos4eva]

Not exactly a trade question but what is up with LDU this season. Was discussed as a 'ready-made player' but hasn't looked great at AFL or VFL really - has he been injured or just struggling to adjust?

Body isn’t quite ready yet as he is built in the Josh Kennedy mould and is playing as a pure inside mid. He’s been quiet for the most part. Things have finally clicked for him though over the last month and a bit. Got 20 touches against the Swans and has had a few very good vfl games in a row now, 20+ disposals. Smooth mover with a lot of time, good contested nous, a brilliant burst and his kicking is excellent. Like Ahern, we won’t see the best of LDU until 2020.

 

[Peel67skin]

Not really, we don’t have a lot of mature depth, so our vfl midfield is fielded by first year rookies with no tanks and LDU.

Maybe Durdin or Nielson, handy KPD’s. I doubt Hvorat will be getting a new contract.

Wood is rated highly internally, not so much by fans, he’ll cost you too much to make it beneficial. Two Dads (Vickers Willis) is best 22 and our only decent lockdown medium defender, again, very cost prohibitive and is a Melbourne grammar boy. Both would be good for you though and fill your list needs.

Fan whipping boy and coach favourite. Works hard, is a nice kick, nippy and has decent composure. Negatives, he’s too small to nail his tackles, not a long kick, not a massive goal kicker and can’t break that 15 touch half forward average that a lot of middiling hff’s struggle to improve upon.

So far what club are interested in Preuss , could it be some three way deal . Durdin a bit like GC Leslie so no point getting the same type .

 

[Kangaroos4eva]

So far what club are interested in Preuss , could it be some three way deal . Durdin a bit like GC Leslie so no point getting the same type .

The three way deal has merit. A lot depends what’s happening with Lycett and English.

 

[SnusCG]

Body isn’t quite ready yet as he is built in the Josh Kennedy mould and is playing as a pure inside mid. He’s been quiet for the most part. Things have finally clicked for him though over the last month and a bit. Got 20 touches against the Swans and has had a few very good vfl games in a row now, 20+ disposals. Smooth mover with a lot of time, good contested nous, a brilliant burst and his kicking is excellent. Like Ahern, we won’t see the best of LDU until 2020.

Sounds a similar mould to Will Brodie really. Contested beast and great in traffic but without the body to utilise it at AFL level year 1

 

[kreglze]

I reckon once next week roles around we start having some idea about delistings and possible movement as we start with exit meetings. The most pivotal trade period in our history coming up this will be the first trade period with all the new people in place. So we will start to see these people hopefully leave a positive mark.

 

[GcSunsfan]

It's officially the crazy season Just noticed Scrimshaw has unfollowed the Suns and started following the Hawks on Instagram.

I wonder if his dad who just happened to be a huge Hawks supporter and drop by in hear on occasion has anything to say about this

 

[kreglze]

And so it begins...