- Jan 9, 2004
- 7,322
- 5,609
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
- Other Teams
- Kawasaki Racing, Falcons, Pelicans
- Thread starter
- #101
Discounting the lower classes is modern thinking but it used to be accepted as a legit career hence 6* of the inducted Legends weren't premier class champs.
If you take away Biaggi's 250 titles then he doesn't come within a bulls roar of a Hall of Fame rider. He was above average, best of the rest but never was close to contending for a title despite having factory equipment. His best year was his rookie year where he finished 52 points behind Doohan. His next best was his second year when he finished 73 points and fourth behind Criville. His status is elevated in the top class because he and Rossi hated each other.
Just to reiterate, I don't mind either way on Mamola, I just can see both sides. He at least pushed Kenny Snr and Luchinelli in 80 and 81 and was strong in 84 after a late call up. On top of that he's also been an ambassador for the sport for 25 years.
Pedrosa also has been a genuine top level rider, contending on a couple of occasions with over 100 top class podiums to go with his 3 world titles. So I can see him in the conversation.
* This includes Simoncelli which I disagree with. It also includes Kato which I have no problem with.
If you take away Biaggi's 250 titles then he doesn't come within a bulls roar of a Hall of Fame rider. He was above average, best of the rest but never was close to contending for a title despite having factory equipment. His best year was his rookie year where he finished 52 points behind Doohan. His next best was his second year when he finished 73 points and fourth behind Criville. His status is elevated in the top class because he and Rossi hated each other.
Just to reiterate, I don't mind either way on Mamola, I just can see both sides. He at least pushed Kenny Snr and Luchinelli in 80 and 81 and was strong in 84 after a late call up. On top of that he's also been an ambassador for the sport for 25 years.
Pedrosa also has been a genuine top level rider, contending on a couple of occasions with over 100 top class podiums to go with his 3 world titles. So I can see him in the conversation.
* This includes Simoncelli which I disagree with. It also includes Kato which I have no problem with.