2018 Rate My Team (Post JLT)

[Faz 2000]

Christensen to Waterman or Fog or P McCartin

Thanks for options/ideas, I'll give it a look. I feel like Waterman and Fog are all but guaranteed to be out of their respective sides within a few weeks when JJK, Tex, Lynch come back, but who knows. McCartin is actually a really interesting option, as he *should* played all year. Hmmmmnnnnn. Or of course I might stick with Bundy on the faint idea that he's way way better than his price.

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

Thanks for options/ideas, I'll give it a look. I feel like Waterman and Fog are all but guaranteed to be out of their respective sides within a few weeks when JJK, Tex, Lynch come back, but who knows. McCartin is actually a really interesting option, as he *should* played all year. Hmmmmnnnnn. Or of course I might stick with Bundy on the faint idea that he's way way better than his price.

Waterman has at least 3 price rises in him. safe bet for 50s or 60s, whereas the other WCE bois are 20-80 range.
Fog, I hope he holds his spot as he is 10x better than Jenkins, but Jenkins is the back up ruck.
McCartin's base is probably about 55-60, but if he kicks 3 or 4, he can push the 90-100

 

[keithrichards]

After plenty of good advice from you lot, have (currently) settled on the following:




Any advice from here?

With $200k sitting there I have options. Could go a $123k rookie to Brayshaw, Armitage or Omeara across their respective lines.

Or upgrade a mid-pricer to a premium.

Only interested in league wins for what it is worth

stevebbb TheBeardAmigos toxic Seymour Skinner

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

After plenty of good advice from you lot, have (currently) settled on the following:

View attachment 473424
View attachment 473425

Any advice from here?

With $200k sitting there I have options. Could go a $123k rookie to Brayshaw, Armitage or Omeara across their respective lines.

Or upgrade a mid-pricer to a premium.

Only interested in league wins for what it is worth

stevebbb TheBeardAmigos toxic Seymour Skinner

Barry to JOM

 

[GT619]

Thanks for options/ideas, I'll give it a look. I feel like Waterman and Fog are all but guaranteed to be out of their respective sides within a few weeks when JJK, Tex, Lynch come back, but who knows. McCartin is actually a really interesting option, as he *should* played all year. Hmmmmnnnnn. Or of course I might stick with Bundy on the faint idea that he's way way better than his price.

I have Fogarty I also have protection for him in my bench as Security. I like him better than jenkins he gives Adelaide a different dimension

 

[Better Loosen Up]

After plenty of good advice from you lot, have (currently) settled on the following:

View attachment 473424
View attachment 473425

Any advice from here?

With $200k sitting there I have options. Could go a $123k rookie to Brayshaw, Armitage or Omeara across their respective lines.

Or upgrade a mid-pricer to a premium.

Only interested in league wins for what it is worth

stevebbb TheBeardAmigos toxic Seymour Skinner

Heeney > Petracca
LDU > Coniglio

 

[Suma Magic]

Here is the final version. Feel free to make me second guess myself now that I'm all locked in...

80k left for corrective trades.

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

Here is the final version. Feel free to make me second guess myself now that I'm all locked in...

80k left for corrective trades.

View attachment 473471

L Fog > Barry

 

[Suma Magic]

L Fog > Barry

I'm firmly on the Barry train now. Saw him live in JLT1 and he looked awesome. I'm backing him in to score well and stay in the team, probably against the prevailing wisdom. I think you will have a good win against Freo and he will look the goods in it.

If he doesn't then I've got cash for sideways rookie corrections in round 3.

Appreciate the feedback though

 

[Asho81]

Think I’m set on this. If anyone can see any obvious issues, let me know.
Cheers

 

[toxic]

After plenty of good advice from you lot, have (currently) settled on the following:

View attachment 473424
View attachment 473425

Any advice from here?

With $200k sitting there I have options. Could go a $123k rookie to Brayshaw, Armitage or Omeara across their respective lines.

Or upgrade a mid-pricer to a premium.

Only interested in league wins for what it is worth

stevebbb TheBeardAmigos toxic Seymour Skinner

Danger to parker or kelly and LDU to cogs.

Solid team

 

[Goats]

FRIENDS! Help me please

Lloyd D2 + LDU M7 + Barry M10 + Greene F2 + $137k
vs
Bonner D3 + Treloar M5 + Dahlhaus F3 + Barry M10 + $21k
vs
Bonner D3 + Treloar M5 + LDU M8 + Sicily F5 + $45k

See the full teams:

Spoiler: option 1

View attachment 473433

Spoiler: option 2

View attachment 473434

Spoiler: option 3

View attachment 473436

Currently leaning towards option 3 because I think LDU will be a great rookie, honestly think he can average 80 playing full time mid. Check his CP ratio from the JLT. Yes he didn't score well, but with that many of his touches being contested, he's bound to throw in a few 80+ scores

I like option 3 the most. Hopefully Bonner comes on.

 

[keithrichards]

Danger to parker or kelly and LDU to cogs.

Solid team

Thanks for the reply. I’ve kinda been set on having Danger regardless of injury situation, so this one is a big call for me. Do like the idea of cogs tho.

 

[LegendLewis]

Finally done. Looks reasonably vanilla I suppose
JOM and Armo should do well but if they don't they will become the rookies that breakout who I don't have.
Already 1 trade down as Kreutzer will be out, I'm a bit sad by that because he was looking so good before his tweak.
any thoughts appreciated
best of luck all!



EDIT: I put this down here so only the astute will see it. I think its worth going a cheap ruck/forward at R3 just in case Cox does go boom

 

[ROOINYOU]

Finally done. Looks reasonably vanilla I suppose
JOM and Armo should do well but if they don't they will become the rookies that breakout who I don't have.
Already 1 trade down as Kreutzer will be out, I'm a bit sad by that because he was looking so good before his tweak.
any thoughts appreciated
best of luck all!

View attachment 473499

EDIT: I put this down here so only the astute will see it. I think its worth going a cheap ruck/forward at R3 just in case Cox does go boom

Good to see a team without 1 of the top 3 mid guys.
I'm running with JOM+Armo too. lets hope they come out flying and we get some good cash gen from them.
Cox will tease you, don't get sucked in!

 

[KardiniaPark]

This isn’t mine but a team I did for a mate.

 

[King_Steele]

This isn’t mine but a team I did for a mate.

View attachment 473582 View attachment 473583

Armitage?

You’ve cooked it.

 

[KardiniaPark]

Armitage?

You’ve cooked it.

He’s a saints fan, will probably sideways to JOM after R2. I think Armitage is worth a look for a couple of weeks, if it doesn’t work it doesn’t work. Can be fixed easily enough.

 

[nameless]

Why? Petracca isn’t an in and under player. May as well say you’re going Petracca because Tom McDonald is out.

Who will benefit from Viney being out then?

ANB? Maynard? Brayshaw? Jones?

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

reckon this thread can close now.

would like to congratulate Wayne's-World for being twice as indecisive as the rest of us with his team

 

[Jiska]

would like to congratulate Wayne's-World for being twice as indecisive as the rest of us with his team

I'd like to thank 647 people who tweeted on Twitter to make those posts a reality.