2018 Rolling All Australian Team

[TW Sherrin]

Show us the numbers and we can all find out

In seriousness, given the high percentage of defensive one-on-ones he is documented as winning, it realistically can't be that many. Certainly not the numerous goals per game that some mark against him.

It was a genuine question. I dont know the answer.

 

[Damon_3388]

It was a genuine question. I dont know the answer.

Fair enough. Logic would say though that if he's winning a high percentage of the defensive one-on-ones he's participating in, he wouldn't be getting that many goals kicked directly on him (relative to the fact that he participates in more defensive one-on-ones than any other player in the league).

 

[Scotland]

Fair enough. Logic would say though that if he's winning a high percentage of the defensive one-on-ones he's participating in, he wouldn't be getting that many goals kicked directly on him (relative to the fact that he participates in more defensive one-on-ones than any other player in the league).

If you leave your man to go third man up at another contest then your man kicks a goal, when you still have a goal kicked on you.

 

[jatz14]

Fair enough. Logic would say though that if he's winning a high percentage of the defensive one-on-ones he's participating in, he wouldn't be getting that many goals kicked directly on him (relative to the fact that he participates in more defensive one-on-ones than any other player in the league).

That implies it's his opponent he is beating in one on ones, however with his intercept style, it's often not the case.
This style however means if his opponent does kick a goal, Rance may be nowhere near him.
So Rance could win all his one on ones, and still concede goals to his opponent, which isn't a criticism. It may well be a trade off Richmond are happy to make. If Rance rolling of his opponent stops 6 goals, but his opponent being loose means he gets 3, Richmond is still ahead.


Sent from my XT1068 using Tapatalk

 

[WWSD]

IN: James Sicily

3 goals off half back in the 3rd quarter alone. Number one in the AFL in intercept marks, marks, rebound 50s and goals per game amongst the half back flankers. Less then 12 months ago he was struggling to get a kick as a half forward. What a turnaround.

 

[Pack Specialist]

IN: James Sicily

3 goals off half back in the 3rd quarter alone. Number one in the AFL in intercept marks, marks, rebound 50s and goals per game amongst the half back flankers. Less then 12 months ago he was struggling to get a kick as a half forward. What a turnaround.

I can barely admit it but he is ridiculously good.

 

[WWSD]

I can barely admit it but he is ridiculously good.

He’s a campaigner and not well liked by opposition fans because of the way he carries himself sometimes but boy can he play when he’s on. His kicking skills are elite.

 

[Pack Specialist]

He’s a campaigner and not well liked by opposition fans because of the way he carries himself sometimes but boy can he play when he’s on. His kicking skills are elite.

Every team needs a few campaigners, including the AA team.

 

[benbanjo]

IN: James Sicily

3 goals off half back in the 3rd quarter alone. Number one in the AFL in intercept marks, marks, rebound 50s and goals per game amongst the half back flankers. Less then 12 months ago he was struggling to get a kick as a half forward. What a turnaround.

Very Punchable face, but cant deny he is pretty good!

 

[WWSD]

Very Punchable face, but cant deny he is pretty good!

Imagine if this was a half forward line...

HF: De Goey, Sicily, Greene

 

[Luv_our_club]

Imagine if this was a half forward line...

HF: De Goey, Sicily, Greene

 

[benbanjo]

Imagine if this was a half forward line...

HF: De Goey, Sicily, Greene

We can probably fit that in our salary cap for next year.

 

[robertg22]

Imagine if this was a half forward line...

HF: De Goey, Sicily, Greene

Melksham unlucky to miss out..

 

[Mr Meeseeks]

Every team needs a few campaigners, including the AA team.

Couldnt agree more. All the great teams had a couple of c****

Sent from my SM-G935F using Tapatalk

 

[Snake_Baker]

IN: James Sicily

3 goals off half back in the 3rd quarter alone.

Well, it's not as if he can kick them off a half forward flank.

Imagine if this was a half forward line...

HF: De Goey, Sicily, Greene

Except one of those players is a failure as a forward.

 

[RIOLINWITPUNCHS]

View attachment 513350

Hahaha gold.

 

[WWSD]

Well, it's not as if he can kick them off a half forward flank.



Except one of those players is a failure as a forward.

Sicily did kick 30 goals as a forward two years ago. He also kicked 5 goals on Scott Thompson.

 

[Grand Uncle Horace]

This.

#2 in goals per game
#9 in goal assists per game
#3 in inside 50s per game
#1 in marks inside 50 per game
#4 in contested marks per game
#12 in metres gained per game
#1 in score involvements per game

The complete forward - Playmaker, target man, and finisher.

No way does Buddy or Grundy come close to AA, unless it is coffee with team mate Allirx2.

It is not the Swans way to be in AA running .... just an average team plodding along.

K Cornes clearly is astute when he noted there are no stars other than Buddy and further the Swans have an ageing list are so slow and are no threat.

 

[RIOLINWITPUNCHS]

View attachment 513350

Can someone smarter then me please put De Goey Sicily and Greenes faces in place of those creatures.

 

[Burtman]

Well, it's not as if he can kick them off a half forward flank.



Except one of those players is a failure as a forward.

 

[adammania9]

Sicily in for Laird

 

[Pack Specialist]

Melksham unlucky to miss out..

He'd make the squad.

 

[Jhye Clark 13]

IN: James Sicily

3 goals off half back in the 3rd quarter alone. Number one in the AFL in intercept marks, marks, rebound 50s and goals per game amongst the half back flankers. Less then 12 months ago he was struggling to get a kick as a half forward. What a turnaround.

He was in even before last night.

 

[Collins-Langford-Ayres]

Very Punchable face, but cant deny he is pretty good!

 

[Jhye Clark 13]

Very Punchable face, but cant deny he is pretty good!

Yea he's a star. I'd hate to admit it but he's as good a field kick off half back as I've seen.