ok now do something similar for st kilda:
2014
Clinton Jones 30 yrs 133 games
Lenny Hayes 34 yrs 277 games AA 2003, 2005, 2009 Norm Smith 2010
Leigh Montagna 30 yrs 212 games AA 2009, 2010
Nick Riewoldt 31 yrs 259 games AA 2004, 2006, 2008 MVP 2004
Adam Schneider 29 yrs 200 games flag 2005
Sam Gilbert 27 yrs 140 games
Farren Ray 28 yrs 176 games
Dempster 30 yrs 160 games AA 2012 flag 2005
Fisher 31 yrs 191 games AA 2008
Gwilt 109 games 27 yrs 109 games
border line: Geary (>90 games), Steven (>70 games), Armitage (>90 games)
2015
Leigh Montagna
Nick Riewoldt
Adam Schneider
Sam Gilbert
Farren Ray
Dempster 30 yrs 160 games AA 2012 flag 2005
Fisher 31 yrs 191 games AA 2008
border line: Geary (>100 games), Steven (>90 games), Armitage (>100 games), Savage (> 70 games)
2016
Leigh Montagna
Nick Riewoldt
Sam Gilbert
Dempster 30 yrs 160 games AA 2012 flag 2005
Fisher 31 yrs 191 games AA 2008
border line: Geary (>120 games), Steven (>110 games), Armitage (>100 games), Savage (>90 games), Carlisle (>85 games), Roberton (>80 games)
In summary:
Year 1: Stk 10 v Hfc 10
Year 2: Stk 7 v Hfc 8
Year 3: Stk 5 v Hfc 6
So you can see there really isnt a difference, which is no surprise given our list build was designed by Chris Pelchen based on the experiences of hawthorn