Prediction 2018 trade hypothetical thread

[vozzon]

What do you think they are worth?

Would be filthy if that's all we got for both of them.

Chad is worth a top 10 at least, or that's what i would think the club would want for him. In this draft the player most like for like is Rankine and he would go top 10, and there is a huge risk factor involved that he may not be as good.

Out of curiosity what would say francis is worth?

 

[saintscott]

Pies: In Beams Out: Moore, pick 52
Sydney: In Moore Out Hanneberry
Saints: In Hanneberry, pick 22 Out pick 3
Brisbane: In Pick 3, 52 out Beams, Pick 22

Saints won't be giving 3 in any shape or form for hanneberry

 

[M Malice]

Pies: In Beams Out: Moore, pick 52
Sydney: In Moore Out Hanneberry
Saints: In Hanneberry, pick 22 Out pick 3
Brisbane: In Pick 3, 52 out Beams, Pick 22

Yes please!

 

[adammania9]

Collingwood’s first round pick for Jack Billings

 

[saintscott]

Collingwood’s first round pick for Jack Billings

Your 1st could beanywhere from 12 to 18. Not totally unreasonable but i hope not. Billings is worth more to us than any club would be prepared to pay i suspect

 

[Chrispiesssss]

If you think that is fair how about grundy for hickey straight swap. Maybe a third round swap your way to even it out? Wow just wow

Dude you get Hannebery. Are people stupid on purpose? It’s better than giving up pick 5 for Hannebery. But I guess that’s why your sh:t stain of a club is in the position it is.

 

[NeutralFan]

Collingwood Out: Moore
Collingwood in : Carlisle

St.Kilda Out : Carlisle
St. Kilda in : Hannebery

Sydney Out : Hannebery
Sydney in : Moore


Probably need a swap of few picks or so, but I think that’s fair.

This is beyond stupidity.

Carlisle is way more important to St Kilda than Hannebery and Carlisle is twice the player Moore is.

 

[saintscott]

Dude you get Hannebery. Are people stupid on purpose? It’s better than giving up pick 5 for Hannebery. But I guess that’s why your sh:t stain of a club is in the position it is.

I have 2 degrees and an iq of 160. Possibly I'm not the stupid one?

If you like hanneberry so much why don't you straight swap him for darcy moore? Hanneberry is half cooked and worth a second rounder at best before taking into account his alleged back ended contract worth over 800k a season

 

[Bored_Pie]

He requested the trade.

Who else would have requested it?

Read again.

 

[Bored_Pie]

Collingwood Out: Moore
Collingwood in : Carlisle

St.Kilda Out : Carlisle
St. Kilda in : Hannebery

Sydney Out : Hannebery
Sydney in : Moore


Probably need a swap of few picks or so, but I think that’s fair.

Keep these trades in our trade forum. You'll get even worse wtf responses here

 

[Tbone McGraw]

I have 2 degrees and an iq of 160. Possibly I'm not the stupid one?

If you like hanneberry so much why don't you straight swap him for darcy moore? Hanneberry is half cooked and worth a second rounder at best before taking into account his alleged back ended contract worth over 800k a season

Sorry but who gets on social media and says they have an IQ of 160?

 

[Clems Knee]

Sorry but who gets on social media and says they have an IQ of 160?

People with an IQ of 160?

 

[Prochard123]

Collignwood:

In: Michael Hurley
Out: Darcy Moore, 2019 2nd round pick


Sydney:
In: Darcy Moore
Out: Daniel Hannebury

St Kilda:

In: Dan Hannebury
Out: 2019 1st round pick

Essendon:
In: 2019 1st round pick, 2019 2nd round pick
Out: Michael Hurley

 

[CasuallyDressed]

Collignwood:

In: Michael Hurley
Out: Darcy Moore, 2019 2nd round pick


Sydney:
In: Darcy Moore
Out: Daniel Hannebury

St Kilda:

In: Dan Hannebury
Out: 2019 1st round pick

Essendon:
In: 2019 1st round pick, 2019 2nd round pick
Out: Michael Hurley

Essendon would want much more for Hurley.

 

[Magpie Monopoly]

Pies:
OUT - Alex Fasolo, 1st Rounder (14-18)
IN - Mitch McGovern

Crows:
OUT - Mitch McGovern
In - Alex Fasolo, 1st Rounder (14-18)

 

[citizen-erased]

Collignwood:

In: Michael Hurley
Out: Darcy Moore, 2019 2nd round pick


Sydney:
In: Darcy Moore
Out: Daniel Hannebury

St Kilda:

In: Dan Hannebury
Out: 2019 1st round pick

Essendon:
In: 2019 1st round pick, 2019 2nd round pick
Out: Michael Hurley

In the words of the great Dys, yeah nah.
Hurley ain't going anywhere.

We'll add players to our list now, not move them out.

 

[HTPunter]

Dude you get Hannebery. Are people stupid on purpose? It’s better than giving up pick 5 for Hannebery. But I guess that’s why your sh:t stain of a club is in the position it is.

Don't get upset, it was a ridiculous hypothetical.

 

[citizen-erased]

Pies: In Beams Out: Moore, pick 52
Sydney: In Moore Out Hanneberry
Saints: In Hanneberry, pick 22 Out pick 3
Brisbane: In Pick 3, 52 out Beams, Pick 22

3 is a massive price for the Saints to pay for Hanneberry and 22.

but the makings of a deal is there
Perhaps Saints' 2019 1st instead of 3.

 

[citizen-erased]

One for the Adelaide fans.
Rankine may be in reach at your first.
With Gov wanting out, what deals do you think could happen to get you earlier into the draft and a crack at Lukosius?

 

[jakefooty23]

One for the Adelaide fans.
Rankine may be in reach at your first.
With Gov wanting out, what deals do you think could happen to get you earlier into the draft and a crack at Lukosius?

Crows will most likely offer McGovern and there first for lukosius. I have heard rumours of Carlton being interested in wingard, and that potentially involving pick 1. Don't think chad would be keen but port would be if they could get Lukosius. Won't happen though

 

[Strahany]

Dude you get Hannebery. Are people stupid on purpose? It’s better than giving up pick 5 for Hannebery. But I guess that’s why your sh:t stain of a club is in the position it is.

I don’t know but, in your case, it seems like you can’t help it.

 

[Strahany]

3 is a massive price for the Saints to pay for Hanneberry and 22.

but the makings of a deal is there
Perhaps Saints' 2019 1st instead of 3.

Hannebery is cooked - has been on a massive decline in the past few seasons and is on a huge contract (around or over $800,000 per year). Sydney are trading him to make space for acquisitions since he and Buddy will be blowing up the cap.

The trade will be similar to an NBA salary dump trade, except instead of the receiving team getting a pick upgrade (as reward for taking on the salary), the receiving team will be giving up only a token pick for the salary dump.

 

[Rich01]

I have 2 degrees and an iq of 160. Possibly I'm not the stupid one?

If you like hanneberry so much why don't you straight swap him for darcy moore? Hanneberry is half cooked and worth a second rounder at best before taking into account his alleged back ended contract worth over 800k a season

Yep, on exposed form I’d rather Polec than Hanners. While North will probably pony up pick 9 for him, they may even gets something back as well. Wouldn’t offer any more than that. But unfortunately Dan looks cooked to me.

 

[Dez!]

Dude you get Hannebery. Are people stupid on purpose? It’s better than giving up pick 5 for Hannebery. But I guess that’s why your sh:t stain of a club is in the position it is.

Dude you came up with a shit trade.

 

[Prochard123]

Essendon would want much more for Hurley.

Hurley is 29 next season...