Prediction 2018 trade hypothetical thread

[C4[2]Yo`DooR]

Pick #45 to Melbourne

Billy Stretch to Port Adelaide

 

[markm106]

Pick #45 to Melbourne

Billy Stretch to Port Adelaide

I’d like to keep Billy. Seemed to be on the outer for a while and finally got his shot and got injured. But I’d understand if he wanted out and that’s about what we’d get.

 

[buttermuffs]

Saints Lose : 2019 first round pick
Saints Gain : Hannebery + Swans 2018 second round pick + Pies 2019 second round pick

Swans lose : Hannebery + 2018 Second round pick
Swans Gain : Darcy Moore

Pies Lose : Moore, 2019 second round pick
Pies Gain : Saints 2019 first round pick

Saints probably think they’ll finish the top 8 next year with the acquisition of Hannebery, other experienced players and an easier draw.

I don’t think Moore is worth a second round pick as well as Hannebery.

 

[Mitchell54]

Saints Lose : 2019 first round pick
Saints Gain : Hannebery + Swans 2018 second round pick + Pies 2019 second round pick

Swans lose : Hannebery + 2018 Second round pick
Swans Gain : Darcy Moore

Pies Lose : Moore, 2019 second round pick
Pies Gain : Saints 2019 first round pick

Saints probably think they’ll finish the top 8 next year with the acquisition of Hannebery, other experienced players and an easier draw.

Pies are absolutely laughing!

 

[Virgin Dog]

Hypothetically, if Wingard does get traded to the Dogs, what does everyone think a realistic price ends up being? Keeping in mind Dogs probably won't want to lose pick 7, can it still happen?
Especially keen on hearing the unbiased views of fans not from Dogs and Port

 

[DaveLister]

Hypothetically, if Wingard does get traded to the Dogs, what does everyone think a realistic price ends up being? Keeping in mind Dogs probably won't want to lose pick 7, can it still happen?
Especially keen on hearing the unbiased views of fans not from Dogs and Port

Maybe if you trade next year's first and this year's second for Wingard and their second next year

 

[Suma Magic]

Hypothetically, if Wingard does get traded to the Dogs, what does everyone think a realistic price ends up being? Keeping in mind Dogs probably won't want to lose pick 7, can it still happen?
Especially keen on hearing the unbiased views of fans not from Dogs and Port

If port didn’t get 7 I doubt it would get done.

 

[Snuffaluphagus]

Hypothetically, if Wingard does get traded to the Dogs, what does everyone think a realistic price ends up being? Keeping in mind Dogs probably won't want to lose pick 7, can it still happen?
Especially keen on hearing the unbiased views of fans not from Dogs and Port

I cant imagine any possible realistic scenario you get Wingard and keep pick 7.

Its an SA draft (they dont want futures), he's contracted, he's always been happy at PA as far as anyone is aware. I would have thought it would be pick 7 and more

 

[markm106]

Hypothetically, if Wingard does get traded to the Dogs, what does everyone think a realistic price ends up being? Keeping in mind Dogs probably won't want to lose pick 7, can it still happen?
Especially keen on hearing the unbiased views of fans not from Dogs and Port

You’re getting a 25 year old 2 x All Australian. Also a best and fairest winner. If you don't give up pick 7 it’ll be next years 1st minimum. However he’s contracted and port will be keen on pick 7.

 

[Virgin Dog]

Maybe if you trade next year's first and this year's second for Wingard and their second next year

I guess that highly depends on how Port thinks we do next year. If they think we bottom out then it could be viable

 

[Virgin Dog]

You’re getting a 25 year old 2 x All Australian. Also a best and fairest winner. If you don't give up pick 7 it’ll be next years 1st minimum. However he’s contracted and port will be keen on pick 7.

Yeah I imagine it's either this year's pick 7 or no deal. I'm not against trading it since we'd be getting proven talent instead of taking a punt, but would be best case scenario if we got both

 

[THE_GUN]

#7 is most likely one of the King boys , Would any of you gents give up Max King for Wingard ??

Personally i dont think he is worth a #7 more around #15 specially if he wants big dollars

 

[cotter101]

Pick 7 at minimum required for someone like Wingard.

 

[Virgin Dog]

#7 is most likely one of the King boys , Would any of you gents give up Max King for Wingard ??

Personally i dont think he is worth a #7 more around #15 specially if he wants big dollars

Given the state of the Dogs list, I'd definitely take Wingard over King (since we already have a tall key forward who dominated at junior level, no way to know that King would be any better than Boyd).
Still would be nice to keep pick 7 and still somehow get Wingard, as unlikely as it is

 

[THE_GUN]

Given the state of the Dogs list, I'd definitely take Wingard over King (since we already have a tall key forward who dominated at junior level, no way to know that King would be any better than Boyd).
Still would be nice to keep pick 7 and still somehow get Wingard, as unlikely as it is

There is a real possibility at the Doggies pick Izak Rankine will be available , Would be madness to pass up rankine to go for wingard

 

[Peel67skin]

Given the state of the Dogs list, I'd definitely take Wingard over King (since we already have a tall key forward who dominated at junior level, no way to know that King would be any better than Boyd).
Still would be nice to keep pick 7 and still somehow get Wingard, as unlikely as it is

Wingard worth pick 7 go and get him . 18 years old take time to develop .

 

[Virgin Dog]

There is a real possibility at the Doggies pick Izak Rankine will be available , Would be madness to pass up rankine to go for wingard

Yeah, if I could choose between the two I'd definitely take Rankine, I just have doubts about him still being there

 

[THE_GUN]

Yeah, if I could choose between the two I'd definitely take Rankine, I just have doubts about him still being there

I think with Talent like Rankine you just have to select him and trust your culture and club to keep talent
Cerra was / is a massive Richmond fan and was drafted to perth and has recently signed an extension no reason Rankine comes to melbourne and doesnt adapt to life here.

Rankine v Wingard ................ Rankine every day of the week and $1.6 million saving over the initial contract of 2 years which allows you to go hard for a free agent

 

[M Malice]

I can't see us knocking back Izak Rankine if he is still there at our pick 4-5, even with the supposed go home risk, we'll back in our retention & welfare team, similar to Cameron Rayner last year who many thought was a flight risk, already signed a 2 year extension.

 

[Mitchell54]

#7 is most likely one of the King boys , Would any of you gents give up Max King for Wingard ??

Personally i dont think he is worth a #7 more around #15 specially if he wants big dollars

I’d take Wingard over the Kings.

Wingard is proven. Kings are not

 

[Giant Strides]

Yeah, if I could choose between the two I'd definitely take Rankine, I just have doubts about him still being there

Problem is, you've got to make that choice before the draft - trade out #7 for Wingard, or give up Wingard if he wanted to come for a possibility of Rankine. FWIW, I don't think Rankine will still be there at #7, so you could end up with neither!

Such a choice is dependent on your perceived need and list state.

 

[Mitchell54]

Problem is, you've got to make that choice before the draft - trade out #7 for Wingard, or give up Wingard if he wanted to come for a possibility of Rankine. FWIW, I don't think Rankine will still be there at #7, so you could end up with neither!

Such a choice is dependent on your perceived need and list state.

With the introduction of draft night trading Port may broker a deal with Brisbane for their pick

 

[Giant Strides]

With the introduction of draft night trading Port may broker a deal with Brisbane for their pick

Correct - but that's a separate deal. Saying no to Wingard & holding 7 could get you Rankine, but probably not; but WB could trade for an earlier pick (before or on Draft night) and thus get Rankine - but still that's a chance WB would have to take. The only guarantee would be trading before draft night for Wingard.

 

[00Stinger]

Tom Potroro said there is another big name player he expects to move that hasnt been mentioned in the media

I wonder who it is?

Sent from my SM-G930F using Tapatalk

 

[Mitchell54]

Tom Potroro said there is another big name player he expects to move that hasnt been mentioned in the media

I wonder who it is?

Sent from my SM-G930F using Tapatalk

He’s just saying that so when an unexpected trade happens he gets credit for predicting it