- Jul 24, 2015
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
I think this is a reasonable trade but on the basis that i rate JMac alot higher than you and others here.Macmillan + 2020 R2 for Papley is a decent trade for the Swans for a bloke they got for nothing. They also have academy kids next year they will need points for which may be of interest to them.
And he's not a perfect player by a long shot - yes he has flaws. But the Swans wanted Clarke so I imagine they don't value hardness in every player.