MVP 2019 Bob Skilton Medal

Jun 19, 2011
11,085
15,832
Sydney
AFL Club
Sydney
Other Teams
Wallabies

New awards beginning tomorrow night. Adam Goodes Trophy for 2nd and Peter Bedford Trophy for 3rd in the Skilton. Love it.

My predictions for the top 10 and major awards below:

1. Dane Rampe (comfortably)
2. George Hewett
3. Luke Parker
4. Isaac Heeney
5. Callum Mills
6. Tom Papley
7. Jake Lloyd
8. Jordan Dawson
9. Aliir Aliir
10. Josh Kennedy

Not how I'd have the top 10 personally but I think for various reasons that might be how it looks roughly.

Rising Star: Nick Blakey

Most Improved: Jordan Dawson

Best Clubman: Dane Rampe

Player's Player: Dane Rampe
 
Last edited:
How I’d have it:
1. ___ _____
(Daylight)
2. Aliir Aliir
3. Isaac Heeney
4. Callum Mills
5. Tom Papley
6. George Hewett
7. Luke Parker
8. Jordan Dawson
9. Ollie Florent
10. Jake Lloyd

How it’ll end up:
1. Luke Parker
2. Jake Lloyd
3. ___ _____
4. George Hewett
5. Callum Mills
6. Tom Papley
7. Isaac Heeney
8. Josh Kennedy
9. Aliir Aliir
10. Sam Reid
 

Humph

Debutant
May 1, 2007
145
138
Adelaide
AFL Club
Sydney
Other Teams
S.M.W. Rovers
To help people making their predictions, here's a list of all the guys who played at least 15 games.

22 Heeney, Papley, Mills, Reid, Parker, Hewett, Aliir, Lloyd
21 Florent, Blakey, Rampe
20 Dawson
19 JPK, McCartin
17 Jones, Melican

I'll say :
1st Rampe
2nd Parker
3rd Lloyd
 
1. Rampe
2. Parker
3. Heeney
4. Papley
5. Mills
6. Aliir
7. Hewitt
8. Dawson
9. Kennedy
10. Florent

Rising Star: N Blakey
Most improved: J Dawson
Best Clubman: Papley
Players Player: Rampe
 
If Reid can’t crack the top 10 it confirms where he truely stands in the game

I.e bog ordinary

Hard to rate our best and fairest when Lloyd won last year

At one point in the year (Think round 13 or so) I had him in our top ten this year.

His form tampered off though so can't see it happening now.

Thinking

1. Dane Rampe
2. Luke Parker
3. Hewitt
4. Aliir
5. Heeney
6. Papley
7. Llyod
8. Mills
9. Kennedy
10. Dawson
11. Florent (Really should be in the top 10, but had a slow start to the year).
 

Jack2Jack

Club Legend
May 3, 2011
1,903
2,441
Western Australia
AFL Club
Sydney
1. Rampe - Outstanding season, finish 2nd at absolute worse...any lower would be a bit of a joke
2. Parker - Probably the only other with a realistic chance to win, not his best season but far better than given credit for
3. Lloyd - Polls well and consistent, personally would have at 8 or 9, but he won last year with similar season
4. Allir
5. Hewett
6. Heeney
7. Papley
8. Dawson
9. Kennedy
10. Mills

Rising Star - Blakey
Most improved - Dawson
Clubman - Cunningham?
Players - Rampe
 
At one point in the year (Think round 13 or so) I had him in our top ten this year.

His form tampered off though so can't see it happening now.

Thinking

1. Dane Rampe
2. Luke Parker
3. Hewitt
4. Aliir
5. Heeney
6. Papley
7. Llyod
8. Mills
9. Kennedy
10. Dawson
11. Florent (Really should be in the top 10, but had a slow start to the year).

i agree with your top 5

id move hewett 5th and aliir second

id have lloyd 10th, but bet he gets top 3
 
Jun 2, 2014
21,780
55,138
AFL Club
Sydney
Other Teams
The Rebel Alliance
How good is this my 3 just about favs and then there is Kels and a few others . What great people on and off the ground
I think you hit the nail on the head there, Bedders. Just as great off the ground as they were on it.
 
Jun 19, 2011
11,085
15,832
Sydney
AFL Club
Sydney
Other Teams
Wallabies
Yep he'll do better than most think IMO. Doesn't ever play a bad game

He had a really good year (I thought he actually should have won the Skilton last year) but he had a couple of poor games this year where he was either off the boil or looked a little disengaged for whatever reason.
 
My guesses/biases below. Have the full time mids scraping in to the top 10. They were usually soundly beaten during the year.

1. Rampe
2. Mills
3. Heeney
4. Aliir
5. Papley
6. Dawson
7. Lloyd
8. Parker
9. Hewett
10. Kennedy

Rising Star - Blakey
Most improved - Dawson
Clubman - Parker
Players - Rampe
 

Tedeski

Brownlow Medallist
Oct 2, 2006
21,806
26,870
Melbourne
AFL Club
Sydney
Other Teams
Mava Fan Cooler
1st. Rampe
2nd Hewitt
3rd Parker
4th Heeney
5th Lloyd
6th Papley
7th Aliir
8th Kennedy
9th Dawson
10th Mills

Rising Star. Blakey
Most Improved. Dawson
Best Clubman. Jack
Players. McCartin
 
Back