List Mgmt. 2019 Draft Mega Thread - Pickett is not eligible as F/S or NGA

Remove this Banner Ad

Powerage

Club Legend
Aug 14, 2014
1,436
1,724
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Not saying I disagree, but I think you might be one of the few who think this way.

Having looked over his vids again, my concern is he doesn’t have any other weapons. No speed, average agility, short, average overhead. So if his kicking is as you say, he doesn’t have the tools to get away with this.
LOL. A euphemism for "I'm not saying I disagree, however almost everybody else and possibly myself disagree".
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Jonts

Brownlow Medallist
Nov 7, 2009
15,990
18,378
Adelaide
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Other Teams
Flagstaff Hill FC, Tottenham
He's Caleb Daniel as a half back.

I hate Caleb Daniel as a half back.
Nah he has a lot more midfield scope than Caleb Daniel, can find it a lot more even find it himself. Would love a highlights package from his game against Tassie Devils where he had 42(?ish) touches)

Caleb Daniel can't pierce his kicks anything like Bianco too
 

Tibbs

Premiership Player
Sep 9, 2013
4,916
11,310
Brisbane
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
shewho I am ok with drafting forwards to be forwards, just have trouble with believing we should draft forwards because they might become Nat Fyfe-esque mids.

At Port we have had so many ”he’s a flanker but with midfield potential” types and they largely stay flankers. Hartlett the primest example imaginable.

If we can’t make a case for ’Bergman as a career-long flanker’ being worthwhile in and of itself then I’d suggest theres better options. If we can make that case, and that has him high enough priority for us to draft, great.
Portia, who said that? I know I have referenced Fyfe, and I have seen a few others. But every time it has been in response to some expert saying "dont pick player X, he is too skinny."

So let's not rewrite the facts. If a draftee has the skills and attributes needed to become an AFL player, but is a bit skinny (probably covers 70% of all draftees), then I have no problems picking him, and can rightly reference Fyfe as an example of a skinny player who succeeded!

If a player doesn't have the required attributes, then sure. Otherwise happy to read up on all the quality research posters are putting up, both negative and positive on draftees.
 

Butters Made Me Do It

Drinking tea
Mar 16, 2019
4,610
23,367
Covidtopia, VIC
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Other Teams
Florida Mayhem
Portia, who said that? I know I have referenced Fyfe, and I have seen a few others. But every time it has been in response to some expert saying "dont pick player X, he is too skinny."

So let's not rewrite the facts. If a draftee has the skills and attributes needed to become an AFL player, but is a bit skinny (probably covers 70% of all draftees), then I have no problems picking him, and can rightly reference Fyfe as an example of a skinny player who succeed!

If a player doesn't have the required attributes, then sure. Otherwise happy to read up on all the quality research posters are putting up, both negative and positive on draftees.
That is precisely the reason we didn’t select Fyfe. We accidentally watched Fyfe kick 7 goals in a colts game as a third tall (we were there watching someone else) but overlooked him because he didn’t play midfield as was a third tall.
there you go
 

Tibbs

Premiership Player
Sep 9, 2013
4,916
11,310
Brisbane
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
there you go
That is precisely the reason we didn’t select Fyfe. We accidentally watched Fyfe kick 7 goals in a colts game as a third tall (we were there watching someone else) but overlooked him because he didn’t play midfield as was a third tall.
Which was in answer to this post about Fyfe being a third tall rather than a midfielder
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Rendaw

Club Legend
Oct 4, 2016
1,707
2,839
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Other Teams
LA Lakers, Anaheim Ducks, LA Rams
Well Kemp could be there but it means we get a second hit at the same tier of player.

I just think it would give us a greater chance of success considering who we are looking like drafting.
 

Macca19

Moderator
Jan 14, 2001
62,523
77,322
Albertr0n
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Other Teams
MUFC, Orlando Magic
Nah he has a lot more midfield scope than Caleb Daniel, can find it a lot more even find it himself. Would love a highlights package from his game against Tassie Devils where he had 42(?ish) touches)

Caleb Daniel can't pierce his kicks anything like Bianco too
You can watch it on the NAB app
 

all seeing eye

exquirentibus veritatem
Nov 26, 2009
195
285
adelaide
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
The lack of consensus across this thread and other clubs threads points to an interesting night. Cant remember a draft where there is so much uncertainty in who best to pick up and where they should fall. Apart from first few rankings there seems to be debates and concerns with most-players in the top 20.

Should be interesting in a few years as to who got it right and a real indicator of recruiters who can really judge talent.

Just hoping we dont balls it up completely with a young, moore type draft as there are plenty of Ok but average types in this yr.

I'm still on the Serong , Williams, Sharp bandwagon.
 

Remove this Banner Ad