Butters Made Me Do It
Drinking tea
Only Schoenberg challenges him for worst selection and he had a good champsWhich other All Australian selected lads from this year are 'spuds?'
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Only Schoenberg challenges him for worst selection and he had a good champsWhich other All Australian selected lads from this year are 'spuds?'
Yeah I reckon if crows don’t take McAsey he falls to us (Hawthorn probably the only other threat, and Geelong might try and get Carlton’s Pick)sounds like McAsey could fall and fall to 12.......... so we go tall there with a decent tall, then mids mids.......
McAsey or Kemp or Roberson?
So what don’t you like about Weightman or Bergman by comparison?Potentially elite, natural goal kicker, good size, good athleticism, had a very Rozee type year and has gone under the radar a bit. At 16/18, I think he's absolutely worth a shot.
3rd best forward on my list behind Taylor and Taheny, but his ceiling is much higher than both.
So like a short Trent Riverssub 180cm small defender with minimal defensive capability. Plays the quarterback role but struggles to kick well under pressure (despite consistent reports he's an elite kick). Questionable midfield potential.
Sounds like the guy we had that ended up back at Centrals.sub 180cm small defender with minimal defensive capability. Plays the quarterback role but struggles to kick well under pressure (despite consistent reports he's an elite kick). Questionable midfield potential.
If he can't defend we don't need him. I want another Dan Houston/Joel Garner.sub 180cm small defender with minimal defensive capability. Plays the quarterback role but struggles to kick well under pressure (despite consistent reports he's an elite kick). Questionable midfield potential.
So what don’t you like about Weightman or Bergman by comparison?
Sounds like Ben Jacobs. Pass.sub 180cm small defender with minimal defensive capability. Plays the quarterback role but struggles to kick well under pressure (despite consistent reports he's an elite kick). Questionable midfield potential.
Sounds like Rory Laird who we apparently met with during trade week.Sounds like the guy we had that ended up back at Centrals.
I take your point but the world is changing. First round used to be reserved for mids and talls with flankers rucks and forwards only getting a look in the later rounds. After what Richmond did in 2017, some more talented kids are being kept forward more and so this draft looks strong on forwards and forward/mids. I believe you identify a draft's strengths and attack that.shewho I am ok with drafting forwards to be forwards, just have trouble with believing we should draft forwards because they might become Nat Fyfe-esque mids.
At Port we have had so many ”he’s a flanker but with midfield potential” types and they largely stay flankers. Hartlett the primest example imaginable.
If we can’t make a case for ’Bergman as a career-long flanker’ being worthwhile in and of itself then I’d suggest theres better options. If we can make that case, and that has him high enough priority for us to draft, great.
wild to think Gould, who earned u18 honours last year against actual good players, might slide later than spud like De Koning
What's the knock on Bianco?
FI can see the Crows ending up with Stephens, Williams and Sharp and me being very upset.
I hope that late interest in Williams holds up.The Age phantom draft picks for Port
Miles Bergman
Sam De Koning
Trent Bianco
They have Geelong taking Jones before our final pick and Worrell missing out in the first round.
Also saying Port has shown late interest in Dylan Williams.
Williams looks like a Luke Reynolds clone.
Will dominate SANFL but will it translate?
On SM-G960F using BigFooty.com mobile app
It's not late interest. The Williams- Port connection has been around for a while. It's the Day and De Koning links that are new.I hope that late interest in Williams holds up.
He looks like what we are crying out for.
Potentially elite, natural goal kicker, good size, good athleticism, had a very Rozee type year and has gone under the radar a bit. At 16/18, I think he's absolutely worth a shot.
3rd best forward on my list behind Taylor and Taheny, but his ceiling is much higher than both.
Not saying I disagree, but I think you might be one of the few who think this way.
Having looked over his vids again, my concern is he doesn’t have any other weapons. No speed, average agility, short, average overhead. So if his kicking is as you say, he doesn’t have the tools to get away with this.