List Mgmt. 2019 Draft Thread

[Mikka84]

Yes Flynn is developing nicely and exactly what we are looking for in a second mobile ruck/forward but has been under GWS Academy since his early teens

What about Chol from Tigers?

Mobile kicks goals and is filling that second ruck /forward role at Richmond currently

Apparently is unrestricted FA and could be worth a look

Hadn’t thought of him. Good get. Would struggle as a true backup ruck if Roma went down, but as a tag-team during game, absolutely.

 

[kane22]

Now that we won't be getting Anderson and Kemp has done a knee, for me it is best we win more games with Ratts this year to boost confidence and then take Dylan Stephens from Norwood say with our 6-8 pick. He is an outside midfielder being compared to Gaff, he could be an Aish worst case but for me there is no other obvious pick for us.

 

[cooperrules]

No doubts he could play up on a wing. When I talk about midfielders I mean someone that plays in the centre.

Until hes in the guts its hard to say if hes any good. Looked good in match sim preseason.

 

[Gosaints12]

really depends where their first round pick lands and whether or not we think there will be top end talent of the kind we need.. right now this draft seems pretty heavy with back flankers.. doesn't seem like something we really need, and you'd be pretty brave to bet on sydney having two down years in a row.

Personally I just hold onto the players that make up our spine, carlisle, battle, roma, king, bruce. I'd entertain a trade for bruce should that nab us ben king but bruce has impressed me lately.

Sinclair is definitely on the table however for mine

I was talking about next years first.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[joop]

If we are trading the pick I wouldn;t mind looking at our pck for Brodie and King

I tell ya what, the amount of crap Dunstan gets would be nada compared to what Brodie would get if we signed him.

 

[Gosaints12]

What makes you say Papley wants North? Rumours? I’ve heard he’s after a lengthy contract back in Melb. Doesn’t mind where he plays.

Facebook.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[bird_man]

I tell ya what, the amount of crap Dunstan gets would be nada compared to what Brodie would get if we signed him.

People seem to think he's going to be cheap as well. He's a former top ten pick, contracted and in their best 22.

He may end up being a good footballer but he's not the type we should be going after unless you were to get him on the cheap.

 

[Mikka84]

Hill x 2 looking more and more likely the more people I speak to. Giddy up.

 

[St Kilda Death]

Hill x 2 looking more and more likely the more people I speak to. Giddy up.

How much trade value do we reckon fellas?
Freo got brad for p23 yeah?
So surely hes worth less now 3 years older.

 

[RWB4life]

How much trade value do we reckon fellas?
Freo got brad for p23 yeah?
So surely hes worth less now 3 years older.

Easy first round pick. I'd be after Caldwell and Essendons first for our first then ontrade that for hill. Take the other a free agent and get them an end of second round.

 

[bird_man]

How much trade value do we reckon fellas?
Freo got brad for p23 yeah?
So surely hes worth less now 3 years older.

No he's worth more. He's a much better footballer than he was then. He's won a best and fairest and may well win another since moving. He finds 50% more of the footy then when he was traded.

My opinion is he's probably worth a pick around 10 being contracted.

 

[St Kilda Death]

Easy first round pick. I'd be after Caldwell and Essendons first for our first then ontrade that for hill. Take the other a free agent and get them an end of second round.

No he's worth more. He's a much better footballer than he was then. He's won a best and fairest and may well win another since moving. He finds 50% more of the footy then when he was traded.

My opinion is he's probably worth a pick around 10 being contracted.

Fair calls.
Maybe our first for hill and their 2nd?
Or hill and langdon?

 

[RWB4life]

Fair calls.
Maybe our first for hill and their 2nd?
Or hill and langdon?

Have to remember it's Freo.

They asked and got pick 2 for lachie Weller. Hill is the same if not better. Yes they got overs but around pick 10 for hill seems fair.

 

[Savage Kent]

Send pick 5 + 2020 2nd round pick to the suns for Ben King & Pick 17 (tied to the lions ladder position). Doesn't look like we will be in a position to pick up a gun mid early on in the draft. Have the twin towers in our forward line for the next decade.

If the draft is as even as they say after pick 2 then we may get our hands on a quality mid at pick 17.

 

[bird_man]

Some good news.

Nick Riewoldt just had his third boy...

 

[hayes]

Some good news.

Nick Riewoldt just had his third boy...

He’s obviously trying to single handedly make up for all the father sons we’ve missed out on. True St Kilda man.

 

[gringo2011]

Have to remember it's Freo.

They asked and got pick 2 for lachie Weller. Hill is the same if not better. Yes they got overs but around pick 10 for hill seems fair.

They also traded Lauchie Neale a top 5 player in the AFL last year for 6, 19 and 55. Freo gave Brisbane pick 30. So a high first round pick an 11 spot upgrade on a second rounder and a throw away pick.

Hill isn't any where near Neale but a pick between 10 and 20 seems about right.

I think it would be like if GC wanted Coffield, we'd tell them to **** off, he'd come and say he wanted to go then they would have to get it done to save embarrassment.... then they overpay. I don't think that was Freo, that was GC being reckless.

 

[Mowman]

They also traded Lauchie Neale a top 5 player in the AFL last year for 6, 19 and 55. Freo gave Brisbane pick 30. So a high first round pick an 11 spot upgrade on a second rounder and a throw away pick.

Hill isn't any where near Neale but a pick between 10 and 20 seems about right.

I think it would be like if GC wanted Coffield, we'd tell them to fu** off, he'd come and say he wanted to go then they would have to get it done to save embarrassment.... then they overpay. I don't think that was Freo, that was GC being reckless.

Weller Neale Hill & Langdon losing some quality last couple of years

 

[Sarcoidevo]

Some good news.

Nick Riewoldt just had his third boy...

One more Nick please .... keep em coming

 

[gringo2011]

Weller Neale Hill & Langdon losing some quality last couple of years

And as I suggested when they got Hogan, the navicular would be a huge risk...and it went again. They took Bennell, also an injury risk. Neither worked on top of that. Hogan will be a problem for them.

 

[Gosaints12]

One more Nick please .... keep em coming

Riewoldt from full back- to Riewoldt at Hallf back- there is another Riewoldt in the centre that goes for a run- put to a different Riewoldt at half forward line and he straightens and has put it threw of a Shepard from his young brother Riewoldt.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[VDS66]

Some good news.

Nick Riewoldt just had his third boy...

Elite athlete..

 

[VDS66]

He’s obviously trying to single handedly make up for all the father sons we’ve missed out on. True St Kilda man.

Knowing our luck, they'll all play for the Cowboys...

 

[Diehard Saint]

Knowing our luck, they'll all play for the Cowboys...

Look, I’m not greedy - if just two out of the three ( so far) are father/sons with the talent of their Dad I’ll be happy

 

[majortinkle]

Elite athlete..

Does his missus have any athletic pedigree do we know?